Thread Number: 55293
American Top Loading Washing Machines
[Down to Last]

automaticwasher.org's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate automaticwasher.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 776909   8/12/2014 at 12:10 (3,537 days old) by paulinroyton (B)        

HI Guys.

I am interested in buying an American top loading washing machine. I wondered which is the best model.

The machines I can get hold of are,

Whirlpool 3LWTW 4800 Classic

Whirlpool 3LWTW550YW 6TH Sense

Maytag 3LMVMC400YW

Speed Queen LWS17

Huebsch LWZ17.

Which model is the best for cleaning.

Regards

Paul





Post# 776913 , Reply# 1   8/12/2014 at 12:44 (3,537 days old) by henene4 (Heidenheim a.d. Brenz (Germany))        

I shortly searched all of them and the Whirlpools are most likely the same modell, one just rebaged, at least the data is somewhat simmilar. They Maytag shoul be Whirlpool made as well, AFAIK.
The Huebsch and the Speed Queen are the same as well if I am not totaly wrong.
Investing this amount of money, I'd go with either SQ of Huebsch, depending on which of both is cheaper.


Post# 776914 , Reply# 2   8/12/2014 at 12:47 (3,537 days old) by washman (o)        
get the Speed Queen

and enjoy.

Post# 778971 , Reply# 3   8/23/2014 at 23:59 (3,526 days old) by paulinroyton (B)        
Best American Top Loader

Hi Guys.

I have been looking at the Whirlpool 3LWTW4800YQ & the Speed Queen LWS 17. Which machine is best?.

Also, are the hot & cold fill pipes designed to fit the UK water supply, are they the same diameter as UK machines.

I like the Speed Queen LWS 17, seems to wash well and looks a sturdy machine.

Cheers

Paul


Post# 778975 , Reply# 4   8/24/2014 at 03:08 (3,526 days old) by MatthewZA (Cape Town, South Africa)        
Speed Queen

I would definitely recommend the Speed Queen.

Having used, bought and sold many Speed Queen and Whirlpool top loaders, the Speed Queen is definitely my pick of the bunch. We had a Speed Queen for 8 years and never had a days hassles (sold due to lack of space when we moved to my grandparents house), but I have see and used Speed Queens that are older than me (I'm 19) and still going strong with never needing any repairs.

We had a SQ at the same time my aunt had the Whirlpool equivalent, and I noticed the SQ just did a better job, and I'm not much of a fan of the Whirlpool double action agitator The SQ agitator does a better job, and takes up less space in the drum so I found I could get more into the SQ than the Whirlpool. But that was just my personal observations and opinions.

But with those 2 options, I would join many members and say,"Get the Speed Queen and be done with it!" And the SQ inlet hose fittings should fit your UK taps, as they fit on our SA taps, which are 3/4 inch in diameter - same as most (if not all) washing machines.

Keep us updated on your choice and leave a review when you get your machine

Matt


Post# 778980 , Reply# 5   8/24/2014 at 05:09 (3,526 days old) by marky_mark (From Liverpool. Now living in Palm Springs and Dublin)        

marky_mark's profile picture
Hi Paul.

Hopefully I can give you some information that might help you. I am from the UK but I did live in Arizona for a year in 3 different houses. So I used 3 different types of washing machines. One of them was a Whirlpool pretty much the same as the one you are considering.

I found that the Whirlpool had had an Energy Star makeover. I had to set the rinse selector to "fabric softener added" for it to do a deep-fill rinse. Otherwise it would rotate the tub slowly while filling about a quarter full with water, then draining with no agitation. Selecting "fabric softener added" along with second rinse would only do the first rinse as a deep fill and the second rinse would be as previously described unless using "Super Wash" in which case they were both deep fill.

Also the temperatures were interesting -- I measured them. Options were cold, cool, warm and hot. I found that if using "super wash" then the hot temp was 50 °C. If the incoming hot water was any hotter then it would add cold and would not go over 50° unless you shut off the cold water valve. Warm was 40 °C. I don't know about cool and cold. However if using the regular wash cycle (not Super Wash) then hot was 40° and warm was basically cold (30° or probably less).

Cycle times on this machine were longer than traditional American TLs. I found that Super Wash with a second rinse was close to 90 minutes. The actual wash portion was 20 minutes of agitation. The other hour or so was filling, draining, rinsing, spinning etc. This machine seemed to fill strangely slowly like the value was partially closed and would take about 8 minutes or more to fill up, but water pressure/flow at the sink was normal. But that could have just been this machine/house. You could use the regular cycle (select HOT to achieve WARM 40 °C) and set the rinse selector to "softener added" and you will get one deep fill rinse. This cycle might be about an hour or so.

Also, this machine didn't work like a traditional American TL with the transmission, clutch and brake. There was no brake. The lid locked until the drum coasted to a halt. The motor basically just pulls the agitator back and forth as the motor continuously reverses direction. This sounds quite different to the traditional type were the motor runs constantly and the agitator's direction is reversed through the transmission.

Having said all that, results were pretty good. And the temperatures were consistent, thanks to its ATC. So if you are just interested in the end result, then the laundry will probably come out pretty similar to laundry washed in the Speed Queen. But personally if I wanted an “American” TL then I would be a little disappointed with this machine because it has lost its “Americanness”. I don’t know specifically about the Speed Queen model you are referring to, but if it’s anything like the American AWN542 then I would DEFINITELY go with the Speed Queen. Although the AWN542 has had its max fill water level reduced slightly, that can easily be “corrected”! And you check the ratio of hot & cold water going in on “Warm” to make sure you get the desired temperature, even if that means enlarging its hot fill valve. The Speed Queen should also be made very solidly and will work the same as a traditional American TL (if it’s the same as the USA models).

Let us know what you decide to do!
Mark


Post# 779070 , Reply# 6   8/24/2014 at 13:00 (3,525 days old) by paulinroyton (B)        
Top Loading Washer

Hi Matt & Mark.

Thank you very much for you input and information, I found it very useful.

At the moment I have a few vintage front loading machines and after a new one as my daily driver. I use to have a Whirlpool to loader a few years ago, it was the direct drive model, and loved it very much. Quick wash times and washed great. When I moved in with my partner I sold it and wished I kept it now.

I have been reading a few reviews on a few American top loaders such as Whirlpool and Maytag. Most of the reviews have been negative, especially the HE models.

A friend of mine can get hold of a Speed Queen for a good price. Been on youtube to find out more about these machines and look good. The model in question is built for commercial use and can do a full load in 37 mins.

I don't know if I should stick to a front loader or buy a Speed Queen.

Will keep you posted.

Regards

Paul


Post# 779277 , Reply# 7   8/25/2014 at 09:35 (3,524 days old) by matthewza (Cape Town, South Africa)        

I've used commercial SQ top loaders many times when we're away on holiday and use the hotel laundromat. They're just as good as the "domestic" machines. And as I've always said, the only machine that can PROPERLY clean, rinse and spin a load in 30 mins (there or thereabouts) is a SQ. I don't trust the 30 mins quick wash on any new machine, I don't even use the 30 min cycle on my LG front loader

Post# 779516 , Reply# 8   8/26/2014 at 13:23 (3,523 days old) by paulinroyton (B)        
American Top Loader

Hi guys.

Thanks for all input on Speed Queen top loading washers.

My main concern is the large amount of water they use. If I was to fill the machine on the hot water setting by the time the machine has filled up to its level how warm will the water be. I always wash my whites on a 60c wash and colours on a 40c wash.

My partner and I had a trip to currys on Monday and we looked at quite a few front loading machines. I do like the new LG front loading machines.

Will keep you all posted.

Cheers

Paul


Post# 779647 , Reply# 9   8/27/2014 at 05:40 (3,522 days old) by marky_mark (From Liverpool. Now living in Palm Springs and Dublin)        

marky_mark's profile picture
Although the majority of homes in the UK do not have a water meter -- I'm guessing you do? Even so, without a second rinse the machine will probably use about 140 litres per cycle. Check your water bill. Do you pay a couple of pounds per cubic metre? If so, 0.140 cubic metres per cycle will probably cost you somewhere around £0.30 per cycle in water. Is your hot water heated by gas? If so, although the machine will probably use about 3 or 4 times as much water for the actual wash portion of the cycle (somewhere around 80 litres?), the cost to heat that much water to 40 degrees by gas will not be too different to heating 20 litres in a Euro FL machine. Yes the TL will still cost more to run but do you mind it costing a few more pounds per month?

I suspect the Speed Queen will not have ATC (automatic temperature control) and may only have COLD, WARM and HOT. You may find that HOT fills only with hot water and WARM fills with a mixture. You could try playing around with the valves to get the fill ratio of cold & hot to achieve the "warm" temp you prefer.

I found that if I set the machine to HOT and it filled only with hot water, the temperature of the wash water in the machine was only a couple of degrees lower than the temperature of the water coming out of the tap. It fills with so much water that it doesn't cool off too much. Whereas if a Euro FL fills with hot water, the temperature will drop a lot as heat is absorbed from the small quantity of water. I also had a Maytag Neptune FL in the States without a heater. This was a problem but I still managed to achieve good results just by understanding its limitations and adapting.

As for washing whites as 60 degrees....yes I wash mine at 60 and sometimes at 90. But when I lived in the USA with a toploader I had to adapt. Generally I found that normally using Tide Vivid White and Bright with Bleach and a booster pac worked well most of the time when set to hot. Occasionally I would add chlorine bleach too.

While living in Arizona, friend of mine (also from the UK) said that his white shirts were all starting to turn yellow and looked horrendous with stains under the arms. He just couldn't get them clean in a toploader. I told him to bring the shirts round to my house. I turned up the water heater and set the old Maytag toploader to HOT. I measured the temperature in the tub, it was 66 degrees. I started washing the shirts with Tide and a booster pac. I stopped the machine a couple of times during the wash to allow them to soak. Then after they had been washing/soaking for about 90 minutes I added chlorine bleach and allowed the wash to continue on and finish with an extra rinse. The shirts came out completely perfect. He was amazed how bright and white they were! Just as good as in a Euro FL machine. Although in a Euro machine we are used to just tossing in the clothes and expecting them to come out 100% perfect completely automatically after a 2-hour cycle. In an American TL with a 30-minute cycle, you may find you have to do some pre-treating etc., but I believe you can still achieve good results if you adapt. On the Clorox website they tell you how to check if clothes with colour can be bleached -- they give you a colourfastness test. So don't worry about occasionally bleaching whites that have some colour. This advise is not really seen in the UK as we don't need to use bleach on laundry normally. Hope this helps!!!! Mark



Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy