Thread Number: 6163
Dishwasher Caught Fire
[Down to Last]

automaticwasher.org's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate automaticwasher.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 126144   5/3/2006 at 06:27 (6,559 days old) by gadgetgary (Bristol,CT)        

gadgetgary's profile picture
This is an interesting threat posted on the 'Appliances Forum':

Didn't find anything on a search...
Our POS Jenn Air (made by maytag I believe) dishwasher was 12 years old. Pretty noisy so we always set it to wash during the night when we were sleeping.... so, two weeks ago I am awakened by the SO with "Do you smell that?".

Downstairs we go- yes, it is smokey...and it is coming from the dishwasher. Open it up- Yep definitely. I declare that it must be a plastic tupperware on the heating element.

We open the house up and air out the smoke. Run the whole house fan for a few minutes.

But still a strong smell and some smoke coming out of the DW.... I reach in, and feel the element...cool... uh, oh.

Tools.

Remove the lower panel: Insulation on the underside is ON FIRE! Red smoldering embers, smoke... Pull it out and toss in the sink... put it out.

Ultimately I determine the cause: one of the wires to the heating elements broke at the crimp connector (stress concentrator).... over the years the vibration led to the wire failure. Once the wire broke the current arced and caught the insulation on fire.

Sobering... another way for appliances to kill.

So, we have a new Bosch SHE66C05.... sweet.

Gary





Post# 126146 , Reply# 1   5/3/2006 at 06:29 (6,559 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        

toggleswitch's profile picture
OMG scary. Never thought of that possibility.



Post# 126163 , Reply# 2   5/3/2006 at 09:48 (6,559 days old) by maytagbear (N.E. Ohio)        
And that is why it is

not a good idea to run appliances at night or when the house is empty!



Lawrence/Maytagbear


Post# 126179 , Reply# 3   5/3/2006 at 11:03 (6,559 days old) by tomturbomatic (Beltsville, MD)        

Well, I guess you got a heated dry with that load whether you selected it or not.

Post# 126181 , Reply# 4   5/3/2006 at 11:24 (6,559 days old) by designgeek ()        


(Tom, you got the Tasteless Tidbit of the Day award for that comment:-)

Seriously though, I never understood how someone can press a button on a washer, dryer, or dishwasher, and then leave the house or go to sleep. The rule has always got to be that when the machine is running, you can see it or hear it, and you're in the same airspace with it so you can smell smoke if there's a fire.

Same case for stoves, ovens, microwaves, breadmakers, toasters, coffeemakers, and all the other little electric wonders we have around the house, and the fireplace if you have one.

Low wattage isn't an excuse either; after all a switch or small motor can also short out and cause a fire. For that matter unplugging stuff when not in use will prevent trouble if there's a short in the plug. And always unplug by grasping the plastic plug itself, not by tugging on the wire, which will cause the wire to fray internally and is a major fire hazard.

Last but not least: You've got your smoke detectors and so on, now spend another few bucks for a couple of large boxes of baking soda. When thrown on a kitchen fire, it will soak up grease and will also release CO2 to help extinguish the fire.


Post# 126198 , Reply# 5   5/3/2006 at 12:41 (6,559 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        
Hey hey hey

toggleswitch's profile picture
That was NOT tasteless. It was genius!

Tasteless, as well as classless and inappropriate, would be MY domain.....and don't you forget it.

*LOL*

Who loves ya baby?


Post# 126205 , Reply# 6   5/3/2006 at 13:32 (6,559 days old) by cybrvanr ()        

I was wondering if anyone sold a power cutoff system for the home similar to the systems that are used in commercial buildings. In those systems, the electrical circuit in the affected part of the building is shut off to minimize the danger of live wiring, or if the fire was caused by an electrical source.

I just recently purchased a nifty smoke detector system that will transmit a radio signal that causes other smoke detectors in the home to sound, even if they are not picking up smoke.


Post# 126215 , Reply# 7   5/3/2006 at 13:57 (6,559 days old) by peterh770 (Marietta, GA)        

peterh770's profile picture
When our kitchen was remodeled in the very early 70's, the dishwasher was put on its own switch above the counter for emergency shut offs. We never used it, and every few years someone would ask "What does this switch go to?" I was the only one who ever remembered.

If someone would like a 4 cycle Waste King dishwasher in central NY, please let me know...


Post# 126246 , Reply# 8   5/3/2006 at 14:43 (6,559 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        

toggleswitch's profile picture
Said: I was wondering if anyone sold a power cutoff system for the home similar to the systems that are used in commercial buildings.

Response: Not sure exaclty what is being asked, but I did find ARC interruptors in Home Depot, which I understand is now required by code for bedroom circuits.

Like a GFI /GFCI [a/k/a residual current detector] there is a commection to neutral required in the circuit-breaker panel (consumer unit=> UK).


CLICK HERE TO GO TO toggleswitch's LINK


Post# 126482 , Reply# 9   5/4/2006 at 09:33 (6,558 days old) by fredriksam (Sweden)        

Oh no that is so sad. A similar thing happened to me once but i could restore the machine. It was the motor in my Hoover Keymatic that almost caught on fire. Lyckily i had just come home from shopping so i could turn off the machine before it could spread. The wires in the motor looked really bad i can tell. Now it has a working motor in it again and the machine works tip-tip as far as i can see.

Post# 128722 , Reply# 10   5/14/2006 at 12:46 (6,548 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Fire is of course a concern. I know one family that not only doesn't leave anything on when they sleep or leave the home, but they also unplug any appliance once they are through with it.

I'm quite the opposite. Everything - except those things with parasitic energy drains above 1 watt - stays plugged in when not in use. I also don't have a problem setting the dishwasher to run before I leave for work or go to bed, although usually I set it to run in the evening while I'm still awake. My feeling is that a quality appliance with a good safety record is safe to leave plugged in and to run unattended occasionally. I don't like to leave stoves or ovens run unattended, though.


Post# 128764 , Reply# 11   5/14/2006 at 17:50 (6,548 days old) by mixfinder ()        
Agreed

I am with you Sudsy.
I have to trust a few things to do what they are supposed to do.
I may unplug the dishwasher after only running when I am home only to die from something else.
Life is too short to take on every worry.
Kelly


Post# 128781 , Reply# 12   5/14/2006 at 19:43 (6,548 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        

toggleswitch's profile picture
.... I am with you boys.........then the wear-and-tear on the outlet will cause a fire from the constant Plugging and Unplugging. Especially if you pull cords rather than properly pull plugs.

And I'm not telling what I pull; and if it's burning from the "P & U" get thee to a doctor.
[Ducks and runs].


When *yo' time is up, yo' time is up*.


Post# 128783 , Reply# 13   5/14/2006 at 19:49 (6,548 days old) by irishwashguy (Salem,Oregon.............A Capital City)        
I am glad that you were ok!!!

irishwashguy's profile picture
Ther is a house around the corner from my mother that the people were not so lucky. In Vancouver,Wa( where I grew up) A dishwasher burned the house to the ground. No one was hurt, They have since rebuilt the house and all is well. That is a very good idea having a seperate breaker for the dishwasher so close to it.

Post# 128792 , Reply# 14   5/14/2006 at 20:21 (6,548 days old) by awooff (Peoria, Illinois)        

awooff's profile picture
Same kind of fire happened to me with a haier 18 in dW!

Post# 128843 , Reply# 15   5/15/2006 at 01:07 (6,548 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
I would say that exposed heating elements present a greater fire risk than the in-line water heaters of euro models like Bosch and Miele.

Interestingly, just tonight I was washing a new set of glass storage bowls in the '57 KA KD-2P portable dishwasher. The lids are red vinyl or similar sort of soft rubber. During the spraying they kind of flew around the bottom of the washer. One landed between the cutlery tray (empty) and the heated air inlet. During the heated air dry, the air flow was hot enough to melt one of the lids pretty thoroughly, and damage another one. There was no danger of fire, but... probably the last time I put in anything meltable that can become airborne in the KD-2P's powerful spray action, unless I can check before the heated air dry starts.

On the plus side, I definitely know the heated air dry function is working!


Post# 128894 , Reply# 16   5/15/2006 at 11:27 (6,547 days old) by mr_sparkle ()        
Electricals

Im kinda in the middle myself, I will leave appliances on and pop out, but only if I know I will not be gone long, and again it depends on what kind of appliance. Anything that heats Im wary of, so I would never leave the tumble dryer on or a dishwasher, because of its drying cycle. However when I had a washer dryer, I did used to leave that running and go out, mostly cos the damn thing took so long to dry!!!

I DEFF would NOT leave an oven on auto, or microwave thats just asking for trouble, but I do use my teasmade every day , and thats next to my bed!

As for better quality appliances not causing fires?? I dont agree, a loose wire is a loose wire no matter how expensive the appliance is.

I think most of all tho - why would you leave appliances on when you out? - You dont save much money by doing stuff at night, and I actually like to know when the dishwasher has finished or the dryer.

I dont think we can be silly tho, all this unplugging everything if its not in use is pointless, tv's radios' clocks, microwaves, these need to be plugged in all the time, Im not gonna scrabble behind my big tv just to plug it in. But these are all realitly low power users, i think the trouble comes with white goods.

Oh British Telecom over here do a great wireless home system.

Its a series of smoke alarms, burgular alarms, carbon monxide detoectors and cameras, that all link up wirelessly to one another and to your phone line.

If anything happens it calls you and tells you, and if it cannot contact you then it calls neighbours or friends.

ALso you can check everythings ok on the web cam.

A little OTT but its nice to be protected.

Oh god look at me going on!! this was only meant to be a short reply - sorry guys!


Post# 128908 , Reply# 17   5/15/2006 at 12:52 (6,547 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        
..and if the phone line burns?

toggleswitch's profile picture
I actually slow-cook in my electric oven, leaving it unattended. I set the oven to turn on, do its business and turn off. (But then the oven is less than 3 yrs of age). I feel safer doing that with electric than gas, and 250*F (120*C +/-) appears to be tame. (Paper auto-combusts at 451*F).

At that temp., the water/moisture the food gives off (Cooking makes food tastier by reducing the food's water content therby concentrating the flavor), exceeds the evaporation losses. There will be more water in the pan than when you started. Not to mention fat and grease and drippings. There is very little chance of burning a pan, IMHO.

One of the reaons raw food is healthier than cooked is that it has a higher water content. The moisture has not been driven out by heat. Ditto frying~ removes the most moisture/water; results in unhealthiest foods.

So we are back to=> Be careful don't become consumed by fear. The universe gives you what you think about most, good or bad.

When you time is up. It's up. NEXT IN LINE PLEASE.



Post# 128923 , Reply# 18   5/15/2006 at 14:21 (6,547 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
I tend to gnosh until just before retiring, so it's handy to wait until then to fill up the dishwasher and start it at that time. In rhe morning, clean dry dishes, and nothing dirty cluttering up the sink.





Post# 128925 , Reply# 19   5/15/2006 at 14:42 (6,547 days old) by gadgetgary (Bristol,CT)        
Evening Wash

gadgetgary's profile picture
I too tend to start the dishwasher and then retire to 'dreamland' but now am concerned that I should be 'up' while the dishes are being 'spit shined'. Perhaps there is a more appropriate TOD to run this very useful appliance.

Post# 129006 , Reply# 20   5/15/2006 at 22:07 (6,547 days old) by awooff (Peoria, Illinois)        

awooff's profile picture
ive heard of stoves catching on fire without even being on. happened to a woman i work with, the electronic controls caught fire when the stove hadnt even been used

as far a leaving things running when i leave........sometimes i look at it like, who the hell wants to be home if it catches fire? lol


Post# 129014 , Reply# 21   5/15/2006 at 23:48 (6,547 days old) by gadgetgary (Bristol,CT)        
Aaron

gadgetgary's profile picture
Point well taken.......Who the HELL want to be home if it catches fire??????????


ROFLOL


Post# 129024 , Reply# 22   5/16/2006 at 02:18 (6,547 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
appliance fires

panthera's profile picture
I have to agree with Mr Sparkle...qualtity means nothing. Never had one of my babies catch fire, but just think about it for a moment. You would never, ever leave a 100W bulb burning in a closed wardrobe or clothes closet.
Yet we feel comfortable leaving 3250W heating coils merrily running away in an even smaller space while we sleep.
What, there are no clothes in the dishwasher?
Hmm, forgot that plastic doesn't burn.
Silly me.
Interesting side note. People who install smoke detecters over here in Germany are seen as being hysterical. My new place came with one installed by the builder. All my acquaintances saw it (it kind of did stick out) and said "ach ja, typisch amerikanisch". The German trains refuse to install them.
Not surprisingly, Germany has a much higher rate of smoke-inhalation related deaths than all the countries surrounding it...all of whom require smoke detecters.
Makes you wonder.


Post# 129062 , Reply# 23   5/16/2006 at 08:12 (6,546 days old) by agiflow ()        

Wow, talk about bull-headed people.

Post# 129077 , Reply# 24   5/16/2006 at 08:28 (6,546 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        

toggleswitch's profile picture
We beleive in preventative maintenance and pre-emptive strikes.

Scenario: on a train from Paris to Amsterdam. Beautiful girl in a red sleeveless dress with spaghetti straps. [Even I looked!] UNTIL she raised her arms to light a cigarette. Can you say overgrown jungle? Then she stuck the cancer stick in her mouth full of rotten teeth. *FAINT*

Culture and *norms* are a learned thing, I guess.

But to defend Germans, aren't structures there generally concrete and steel/rebar whereas we still have wood-frame construction?


Post# 129080 , Reply# 25   5/16/2006 at 08:36 (6,546 days old) by agiflow ()        

I have nothing against Germans as there is german ancestry in my background.

Those rebellious Germans, and here i thought they were supposed to be an orderly people. LOL


Post# 129258 , Reply# 26   5/17/2006 at 01:12 (6,546 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Well, in defense of trusting an appliance, most light bulbs don't have safety devices that shut them off if the temperature gets too high. Most dishwashers (built since 1960, anyway) do have such devices on their heaters. Sure it's not foolproof, but then nothing really is, because fools are so ingenious.

Even if german homes were constructed of steel and concrete, there's still a lot to burn in a typical home besides the walls. Furniture, bedding, drapery, rugs, wooden floors, clothes, rafters, roofing, books, plastic electronic goodies, people.


Post# 129266 , Reply# 27   5/17/2006 at 05:44 (6,545 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
they were, till I arrived

panthera's profile picture
Germans were orderly and organized, until they made the mistake of letting me into the country.
Chaos �ber alles!
The trouble with smoke detectors being accepted here has its roots in several things.
First, they are seen as "amerikanisch". The German intellectual left resents the US tremendously. I can not count the times I have been talked down to and lectured in the last 20+ years (in bad English). There is a firm belief among many that all countries in the world have culture and tradition - just not the US.
Because the Americans are seen as the originators of these smoke detectection systems (they aren't) they are automatically bad.
Second, many of the first generation (some still do) used a miniscule amount of alpha-radiation to analyze the air-quality. Germans were up in arms about nuclear energy in those days (with good reason, I think) so anything "radioactive" was seen as dangerous.
Third - despite the severe damage done by tornados, high winds, hail and flooding here in Germany over the last several years there is still a firmly rooted belief that Americans only have "leicht-bau" homes - and German homes are massively built of stone and concrete. The truth is, as Rich said - who cares whether the walls don't burn - it is the toxic fumes from the content which are deadly.
I truly wish the Europeans would shake off some of their knee-jerk "if it is from the US it is bad" mentality. I also wish the US would acknowledge that their are other ways of doing things on this planet - and some of them might even be better.
But not much chance of that...60% of all Americans of European stock sind deutsches Blut... which brings us back to the bull-headed beginning of the topic...
Oh, yea - the girl with the teeth and the under-arm hair. Not all European women are that way, but the man-hating/castrating-women-are-only-free-when-men-are-subjugated- mentality is still to be found here. I never cease to be astonished at the total wimps who put up with their wives/girl friends treating them the way they do...and wonder what sort of woman would want that sort of man.
Me, I like a furry man who smells good. I do understand why a woman might not want to shave such sensitive areas...you ever really thought about what you have there, pressed against your throat every morning?


Post# 129472 , Reply# 28   5/17/2006 at 20:44 (6,545 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
I had the fortune (or misfortune) of sharing a house with a Swiss-German man when I attended college several decades ago.

Overall he was pleasant to the point of boredom. But he had this thing about how anything American was automatically inferior to that which could be obtained in Switzerland. He would go into hysterics if we happened to be watching TV together. Not at any comedy, but at the commercials. Oh, they were so stupid, stupid Americans for allowing them, he's say. I found this extremely annoying because like most of us, I would go into a trance when the commercials came on, just waiting for them to end, not really paying attention to them. By drawing attention to them, and to himself, he was being very obnoxious.

Finally I got tired of listening to the "oh, it's so much better in Switzerland" prattle. He knew I was born in another state (Connecticut, to be exact). He hadn't been there. With the collusion of the third housemate (American as well), I started observing about just about anything that came up, that Oh, my, it was SOOOO much better in Connecticut. The look on his face, ("Uh-HUH!?") was priceless. He was not a stupid person (PhD in Physical Chemistry), but had limited social skills, but even he caught onto the satire, eventually, and his Swiss-is-better remarks slowly petered out.

This genious also used to lament about how awful American women were, and his inability to date any of them. He attributed this to his old world habits of treating them deferentially, such as holding open doors, etc., and that they were too uncouth to appreciate his gentility. Finally after hearing a lot of that stuff, I lost it and told him that I couldn't think of any American women who would want to go out with him, holding a door or not.

Overall, I did not get a postive opinon of the Swiss nation as a result of this 1 year experience. But I'm sure there are some nice ones, and they may even have smoke detectors.

Re: German homes built of stone and concrete. I just hope they never have a minor to major earthquake! California homes are deliberately built light, and of wood, so they can flex and sway with a quake, and not tear apart.

To be fair, though, as I'm sure you're aware, there is a LOT of ribbing of Germans in American (and English) comedy, and among friends. Witness Conan O'Brien's late night grouesque impression of Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's thick Austrian accent. I'm sure most Germans are aware of this attitude and perhaps their haughty dismissal of anything American is some compensation. And not without any reason, because there is a tremendous amount of junk produced here, for the sake of planned obsolescence and profit before function. But the German's refusal to protect their lives with smoke detectors simply because they are perceived as being an American invention... that is like cutting of one's nose to spite one's face. Is there a German word for that, besides "Dumbkopfistch"?


Post# 129505 , Reply# 29   5/17/2006 at 22:19 (6,545 days old) by awooff (Peoria, Illinois)        

awooff's profile picture
you all are missing the point, its not the heating element that overheated and caught fire!

Its the wiring underneath that caught fire or shorted out.

Thats what GADGET GARY meant when he said

"Ultimately I determine the cause: one of the wires to the heating elements broke at the crimp connector (stress concentrator).... over the years the vibration led to the wire failure. Once the wire broke the current arced and caught the insulation on fire."

This is the same short out that happened on my Haier DW also.


Post# 129533 , Reply# 30   5/18/2006 at 01:45 (6,545 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Well, in my opinion, a wire that breaks at a crimp connector is the victim of shoddy engineering and/or manufacturing/assembly. We all know the quality problems Maytag has had in the past decade, so perhaps it shouldn't be a big surprise that one of their dishwashers should self-immolate. Perhaps this is a lesson - if you have a major appliance that you consider a "POS", then perhaps the safest plan to is get rid of it ASAP, out of the house, and either replace it with a quality unit, or do without.


Post# 130354 , Reply# 31   5/21/2006 at 12:07 (6,541 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
sich ins eigene Fleisch schneiden

panthera's profile picture
Rich, that is how you say it in German - tho' there are certainly somewhat, less jungendfreie, ways of saying it.
It is hard not to be critical when you switch cultures. Part of it is that one is, oneself, very unsettled.
Part of it is the tendency in Europe to be hyper-critical of everything American Why? Because!
I have often been told "aber, dieses wirst du sowieso nicht begreifen können" - you won't be able to understand this, anyway - because I grew up in the US.
Having said all this: Here in Germany (and, except for Poland) all of the European Union gay people can live their lives in peace. In many countries we can marry. Nobody cares one bit who you love.
The entirety of Wester Europe together does not manage in one year all the violent crime of some major American cities in one month, alone.
Christianity (outside of Poland) is defined by how one expresses their god's love and not by the US definition of hatred.
I could go on and on - certainly, under the current US administration the opinions have not exactly improved.
Ultimately, 99% of the problem is, quite simply, jealousy. The US is such a great, big, beautiful country with people who are entitled to pursue happiness. The German consitution places "human dignity" at the same level.
Not happiness.
This said - there is still no excuse for the fact that machinery which the US exports to the rest of the world is of much higher quality than what is sold domestically. That just plain sucks.


Post# 130365 , Reply# 32   5/21/2006 at 13:06 (6,541 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Panthera,

Thanks. What exactly would be the German word or phrase for "cutting off one's nose to spite one's face"? Is it "sich ins eigene Fleisch schneiden"? (You can tell I don't understand much German...).

Strictly speaking, the definition of "happiness" in the Declaration of Independence was not personal joy. Rather, at that time in that colonial British culture being rocked by the concepts of the "Enlightenment", "the pursuit of happiness" meant being free to contribute to the public good. Which in turn, I suppose, could eventually result in personal joy for the majority. It was probably a big departure from traditional British society, where only the upper crust and nobility had much say in how things were run. And, of course, the Declaration holds no legal status in our society - it is the Constitution and Common Law that defines our legal system (except in Louisiana where Napoleonic law has a strong influence). A lot of the sentiments in the Declaration made their way into the Constitution, but you won't find "happiness" anywhere in it.

I wasn't aware that our domestic manufacturers supplied products of superior quality for export. However I have heard for some time that various european manufacturers have supplied shoddier versions for export to America. Volvo in the 70's and 80's springs to mind. I recall being told that the Volvo's sold in Sweden were much better than the ones they exported to America. I guess our reputation for being a disposable society got around.


Post# 130382 , Reply# 33   5/21/2006 at 14:28 (6,541 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
Hey Rich,

panthera's profile picture
Yup - that's it "sich ins eigene fleisch schneiden" which means, verbatim: ones' self in the one's own skin to cut".
You get the point.
I am not so sure but what the founding fathers actually meant it just the way they said it; they were mostly deists and free-thinkers - to them the concept of happiness would probably only be possible if it originated at the individual level. Of course you are right - there is a big difference between the preamble to a non-binding document (for the US) and German law - largely written by the US government, by the way in 1948.
The original consitution, unmodified by the "bill of rights" and other amendments is a rather, hmm, well not exactly the most empowering of documents. With the bill of rights, it is really something special and wonderful.
The basic mentality, tho', remains the same: The US is predicated on the concept of people determining their own fate to their own advantage; the German constitution is more concerned with limiting the evil which men do to a minimum. Can't imagine why...the 1930's and 40's were rather dull and boring here im Vaterland...I mean, Germany. Unless you were Jewish, devout Christian (there are such things, not the hate-filled US kind), homosexual, romany (gypsy), and so on...
A-hem.
I have worked (translating) with scientists from a few US companies who have two sets of standards: domestic and EC. The EC standards are often higher. The same applies to stuff many car makers built in the 90's: Chrysler reworked every auto they exported individually.
There are more examples, but the one closest to my heart is country music. You would be surprised how many groups do their experimenting and trying out over hear and stick to the s.o.s. in their home market.


Post# 130391 , Reply# 34   5/21/2006 at 15:46 (6,541 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Well, Panthera, perhaps the meaning of "happiness" in the Declaration would be more accurately translated into today's language as "the pursuit of doing the right thing". If you read the rest of the piece, this makes some sense, as it contains a laundry list of grievances against what the founders saw as immoral, corrupt, unfair, and unethical treatment of the American Colonies by the British King George. It basically said, "The King had a chance to do the right thing; he blew it; now we are going to do it on our own". The colonials were tired of being treated like second class citizens; they wanted the right to do things right. Of course, they were not completely successful, as the tacit approval of slavery in the first constitution indicates, and the British Empire abolished it in its territories long before the Americans did.

In any case, the "pursuit of doing the right thing" is an individual pursuit, that just so happens to benefit everybody. It implies both domestic and public peace, tranquility, and justice.

For many children, the "pursuit of happiness" means the right to cut school and eat as much candy as one likes. Obviously, this was not what the founding fathers had in mind.


Post# 130392 , Reply# 35   5/21/2006 at 16:17 (6,541 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Here's a good summary of what I think is the best definition of "the pursuit of happiness", as Jefferson intended it:

"Did the "happiness" of the Declaration, then, simply mean personal pleasure in keeping with individual taste? In certain respects, yes--for, like Locke, Jefferson believed that happiness was ultimately in the eyes of the beholder. Hence the need for liberty to allow individuals to follow it where they best saw fit. No government could deign to tell its citizens where true happiness lay.

"And yet it is essential to appreciate that Jefferson also held strong views on what constituted the highest source of happiness, the purest pleasure of them all. "Happiness is the aim of life," he affirmed, "but virtue is the foundation of happiness." No 18th-century Founder--whether a Christian, a classicist or a cultivator of simple pleasures--would have disagreed.

"Here was the common assumption--what Jefferson called a "harmonizing sentiment"--that united Americans in their differences through the magic of e pluribus unum, making one of many. For in Christian, classical or Lockean terms, virtue at its highest meant serving one's fellow citizens, working for the public welfare, furthering the public good. It followed that virtue was the indispensable means to reconcile the conflicts of individual interest. However else they might differ in their understanding of the critical phrase, early Americans could agree that by pursuing the happiness of others, they helped to ensure their own.

"Jefferson's colleague Samuel Adams once observed that "we too often mistake our true happiness, and when we arrive to the enjoyment of that which seemed to promise it to us, we find that it is all an imaginary dream, at best fleeting and transitory." Lest our moments of private pleasure be as ephemeral as a rocket's red glare, we might vow this Fourth of July to pursue happiness in keeping with the Founders' full intent. Jefferson himself put it well. The best means to serve "the happiness and freedom of all," he noted in his first inaugural address, was to perform "all the good in my power." As much as the search for individual satisfaction, that too is an American way, the foundation of a truly noble pursuit."






CLICK HERE TO GO TO sudsmaster's LINK


Post# 130401 , Reply# 36   5/21/2006 at 18:00 (6,541 days old) by mr_sparkle ()        
Eurovision

I was watching the Eurovision song contest saturday - any of you in the US see it?
Even being part of Europe, I all the european countries a little strange, they are just so far removed from my countries way of life. Strange.

Here we all have smoke detectors, and dont really care where they come from, since they allow us to live. Radiation? i think they all still have radiation in them dont they? but then lots of things do Im sure.

Also english women always shave - arm pits, legs, amongst other places, our men also do a fair bit of trimming too!!!!!

LoL

Even our men can marry other men!!!! thats happyness to me!







Post# 130454 , Reply# 37   5/22/2006 at 02:40 (6,541 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
Rich,

panthera's profile picture
The depth and and breadth of your knowledge never ceases to amaze me. It has been too long since I read Locke to rightly remember most of his thoughts on the subject (and that, although I diligently listened to every word he said at the time, I did. Guess I am getting old :-))) - I did recall enough to quickly locate this:

"The constant desire of happiness, and the constraint it puts upon us to act for it, nobody, I think, accounts an abridgment of liberty, or at least an abridgment of liberty to be complained of."

(Book II, Chapter XXI, Of the Idea of Power. 51. A constant Determination to a Pursuit of Happiness no Abridgment of Liberty.)

Thank goodness for the internet, by the time I'd gone through my four volumes with a magnifying glass, it would have been the 22 century...

Everyone - from the days of the SPQR (actually the Greek democracies before) down to JFK's ...ask not, what your country can do for you..." has always argued that satisfaction lies in following duty and honor.
The question, to my mind is - do we ever "do" anything unless we want to? Either we do an unpleasant thing in order to avoid something even less pleasant - or we do what we want and look for a socially acceptable excuse afterwards.
Locke, JFK, Shakespeare in Marc Anthony's speech...all come down to this one point: Seeing the good of all as your own good - and therefore co-commitent to your own happiness. Co-commitent? O my paws and whiskers, it has too long been since I the English write...Hope you know what I mean.
Or maybe I just need a cup of coffee. It is early morning over here. Love to hear your ideas on this...I confess to having fulfilled my philosphy requirements at university with courses in logic and a few essays for final exams which were so peppered with Latin (now forgotten) that my profs. thought I must be competent...silly them.


Post# 130456 , Reply# 38   5/22/2006 at 02:44 (6,541 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
John,

panthera's profile picture
Don't be angry, but England and the US are far more similar than either country wishes to admit.
(OK, now the flame war can start.)
Nobody in my circle of US friends even knew what I was talking about when I asked them whether they had seen the Eurovision contest...nor did they care.
There is a very strong sense of "if it isn't here, it doesn't matter" in the US.
Just ask anyone who Juri Gagarin was...


Post# 130527 , Reply# 39   5/22/2006 at 10:50 (6,540 days old) by mr_sparkle ()        
The same only with an accent!

Yes I agree thom the US and UK are VERY similar! Of course we both have differnt landscapes etc, but culture is pretty much the same, we have walmart here, and costco, macdonalds, the lot. In fact where i am from we lived virtually on the American Air base, and it was weird that Amkericans used to come over, all excited about the UKl, but when they got here I heard more then one exclaim, how its just like the US, the food and culture etc. I think the UK is MUCH more like the US than we are any of our European neighbours. I think it stems that bouth our countries are based on the land of the free, listen to our anthems, also were joined in soooo many ways.

Post# 130536 , Reply# 40   5/22/2006 at 11:37 (6,540 days old) by toggleswitch (New York City, NY)        
Two countries divided by a common language and history

toggleswitch's profile picture
Agreed.

Some small differences exist. But I felt VERY comfortable in London. Paris was another story.

Other than Bruce Springsteen in the *import* section and driving in the left side of the street, oh and huge power-points(outlets) it is not so different.

There are also some customs and traditions that differ, but no big deal.


Post# 130559 , Reply# 41   5/22/2006 at 12:55 (6,540 days old) by mr_sparkle ()        
traditions

yeah, I have a foreskin!!!!

ha ha ha


Post# 130594 , Reply# 42   5/22/2006 at 14:42 (6,540 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
and you have the queen...

panthera's profile picture
Well, there are few differences. But most of them are to the advantage of the English. Since I used to live in San Francisco I guess I am entitled to comment on the weather. Other folks have climates, the English have weather.
This is more than made up for by the beauty of the countryside, the wonderful (don't laugh if you haven't been there in the last 10 years) cooking and the 99% of the English who are content to live and let live.
I often wonder what would have become of England and the US if Cromwell had crossed the big pond.
Hmm, the US might today be a fundamentalist, repressive society...nah, that's just a silly thought...


Post# 130714 , Reply# 43   5/23/2006 at 01:22 (6,540 days old) by mr_sparkle ()        
Oh on the subject of the weather.....

I really think climate change is taking its toll with us, water supply is a big thing at the moment, cos apparantly it dosnt raid enough here, AND WE HAVE THE WRONG TYPE OF RAIN!!! LoL



Post# 130724 , Reply# 44   5/23/2006 at 02:50 (6,540 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
Panthera,

You flatter me too much on that count. I'm not sure if my apparent knowledge is more educated guesswork than received wisdom. I passed most of my college English requirement in high school, and after that I had a mostly technical education, even at university, and never had formal study of philosophy. But I'm on my third professional career now and that must in itself force a broadening if not a deepening of my knowledge of some things.

It seems to me that observations such as from Jefferson and Adams on "happiness" are the result not so much of book learning as it is from examining their own experiences, and observing other's experiences, with the "purfuit of happiness", and they drew some conclusions about what really constitutes a successful bottling of that elusive elixir, i.e., one that will age gracefully, and not leave one with a sour aftertaste.

Since college I set about to broaden my knowlege. I used to pour through a borrowed set of Collier's Encyclopedia, and then my own set of Grolier's. Now the Internet is like a vast if somewhat chaotic and mostly unedited encylopedia. One of my favorite works is Gibbon's Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire. Can that man write, and of things that actually happened, too. I'm pretty sure my own writing would generally improve when I read his work, and as you may discern, I haven't read him for a while. He is, I think, the ultimate journalist, because he makes ancient history almost seem like it is happening in the here and now. His exposition on the comparative suitability of soldiers vs. kings to govern is breathtaking, even if one doesn't agree with his point of view (which is predictably pro-British crown, but not without a little winking). I suppose it's one of those rare cases of a historical treatise also being a work of great literature.


Post# 130762 , Reply# 45   5/23/2006 at 08:01 (6,539 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
nah, Rich -

panthera's profile picture
I stand by my comment. You got brains, baby.

Post# 130936 , Reply# 46   5/24/2006 at 00:33 (6,539 days old) by sudsmaster (SF Bay Area, California)        

sudsmaster's profile picture
OK, Panthera, I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree ;-)





Post# 130941 , Reply# 47   5/24/2006 at 01:46 (6,539 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
as you like it - still think you are pretty damn smart

panthera's profile picture
Just saw Enigma with Dougray Scott...Beautiful Mind is coming up this Thursday.
Must be "let's make Panthera feel inadequate upstairs" week over here.
One of my favourite definitions of "happiness" is from Robert Heinlein:
"Happiness is working long hours at something you enjoy."
- Jubal Hershaw

There is something to be said for that, IMHO


Post# 131000 , Reply# 48   5/24/2006 at 11:37 (6,538 days old) by rinso (Meridian Idaho)        

Some very good friends of ours came home to a smoke-filled house recently. The culprit was their 2 year old TOL KA dishwasher, whose detergent dispenser wiring caught fire when the release mechanism failed to function correctly. The fire spread to the surrounding cabinets, then petered out for some fortunate reason. The irony is that their insurance company replaced it with a nearly identical model. Needless to say, they no longer run any appliances while they are away from home.


Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy