Thread Number: 74750  /  Tag: Small Appliances
I need help to choose a new vacuum
[Down to Last]'s exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items
Post# 985626   3/7/2018 at 03:46 (198 days old) by thomasortega (Los Angeles - CA)        

Guys, yesterday Darryl surprised me with a cat.

I like the cat and I want to keep it, even discovering that cat is a mix of puma, jaguar and lion and even being extremely allergic to cats.

The thing is, i need a decent vacuum.

I have a brand new Hoover Constellation (AKA Torture machine) that i kindly stole from my husband's collection. (it was new in box, kept as a collection item and the night i moved to this apartment i was so pissed off with all the fine dust on the floor, and I almost had a nervous breakdown when Darryl suggested buying one of those cheap Eureka mighty mite (knowing he has a brand new supposely "premium" vac in the garage collecting dust) that i had a nervous breakdown and in 10 minutes he appeared with the hoover in his car.

Well, the joy of a brand new "decent" vaccum ended when I turnet that thing on... First it blews all the dirt on the floor, second, the canister hitting everywhere including my ankles and toes and when we really need the "amazing" floating feature, it get's stuck on his own cord and I have to lift it.

Well, there are two ways to vacuum using the constellation:
1) vacuum with one hand and hold the canister upside down, feeling that hot air on my armpit, sweating like a pig and ending with half apartment vacuumed and sore arms.

2) Team work. one holds the canister on it's side and the other vacuums.
Making the story shorter, the constellation is cute, it's historical, but it's a PITA and a huge No no no no no no no no no f-word way no.

Second vac: About a year ago I bought a Black and Decker Dustbuster Flex 20v. It was a pain because i paid for the model with a floor nozzle and they delivered the model without the floor nozzle. Ok, it was returned, days later i received exactly the same vacuum AND a refund. Ok, it ended up free, great. About a month ago i bought the floor nozzle kit.

It's interesting and that tiny vacuum is actually very powerful for a dustbuster. Incredibly it cleans very well and I'm amazed with it. But the "floor" nozzle looks like a toy and it's not THAT efficient. I love that vacuum but it's a no no if used for the whole house.

I won't even mention the Dirt Devil Reach 360° i have. I'll probably list it on craigslist as free stuff only to get rid of it.

For months I've been "dating" the Bissell home care big creen complete. It's a vacuum cleaner with water filter AND it can also be used as a carpet/upholstery/hard floor washer.

Ok, the idea is great, but it's not very friendly for everyday use. I mean, the device itself is bulky and heavy (according to Ibaisiac videos), it is also a pain to wash the dust collector and let ir air dry every time the vacuum is used. But anyway, I like it, the price is good (209 at walmart) but i think it may be a hassle instead of something to help me.

Then i had the idea to get a Ridgid shopvac, because of the extreme power and giant tools (i saw one that is 6.5 hp, has a super thick hose, and the possibility to buy a giant floor brush that would be great to vac the living room in no time). It is also possible to buy a HEPA filter for it and as you may know, there are dozens of attachments that i can easily buy at Homo Depot.
Also, it doubles as a leaf blower that would be great to clean the patio. and it would be great to clean the car, also, it's built to stand even the worst environments (like all shopvacs). Another pro is that i can buy a huge hose and use it almost like a central vac, keeping the vacuum in the closet and just grab the hose. As the sirflow is absurd, it would also help cleaning the air.

And the best thing its that the hose is so thick that I could accidentally vac the cat. and solve the problem at once. (of course I'm kidding, i like the cat)

Cons: Well, it's huge. I mean, REALLY HUGE.

I also think about the Shark Dualclean Apex. It's cute, it has very interesting tools, but at the same time, I always have the feeling that sharks are fancy toys like Dysons. Too much money for too many bells and whistles but not much real value.

The thing is: Now, with that little hairy and cute monster I can't postpone anymore and I can't spend much money now. What should I get?
I definitely need something with an excellent filtration because of my cat allergy and also that terrible black dust that sits everywhere here in Los Angeles.

Options are:

1) The bissell big green complete thing that has a water filter.
2) A shopvac (at least it's cheap at homeless depot)
3) That hoover React (because it comes with a baseboard cleaning attachment)
but just to add another option, I don't really love it and I don't know why, every time I see a hoover vacuum it reminds me one of those cheap Dirt Devils, even some accessories look exactly like Dirt Devil.
4) Bissell Hardwood expert deluxe
5) A cheap dirt devil (one of those that cost $50 at Hell-Mart
6) Bissell Crosswave (and I can use the black and decker i have for above ground cleaning)
7) The shark Apex (i love the tools that come with it, but again, it looks so fragile.

Please note that I don't have carpets at all. All floors are laminate and ceramic in the kitchen, laudnry room and bathroom. Sooner or later we will end up buying an area rug. And I'll provbably need to vacuum the whole house daly or every 2 days.

And no, Kirbys and Rainbows are completely out of question. It may be the best vac in the world, but i think they are horrible and absurdly expensive. I don't need a vacuum that lasts 50 years.

Miele could be an option (there is a model that is great and costs around $300), but then I'd be a hostage having to buy bags from the Miele dealer and here in Los Angeles they're like drug dealers charging a fortune for a paper bag, so the cost goes up to the sky.

Honestly, I miss so much the ELectrolux Easybox i left in Brazil. 2000W, strong as a shopvac, decent tools, simple, works super well, it has a HEPA filter.

Later, I also plan to get a robot, because nobody deserves vacuuming all the floors every single day and depending on the case, twice a day.

Post# 985629 , Reply# 1   3/7/2018 at 04:09 (198 days old) by Maytagbear (N.E. Ohio)        

Miele, Miele, Miele.

My Capricorn is the best vacuum I have ever owned/used, and its quietness makes Miele the best brand for apartment living. THE furnace in this apartment is louder.

Yes, the Capricorn was discontinued. However, there are many places in greater Los Angeles to experience the current Miele live.

The Miele "Parquet Twister" bare floor tool is perfect for bare floors. And for This Bear's floors! The kitchen/dining/living room are wood-look laminate. Only the bedrooms are carpeted.


This post was last edited 03/07/2018 at 04:40
Post# 985641 , Reply# 2   3/7/2018 at 05:35 (198 days old) by speedqueen (Harrison Twp, Michigan)        
Check your local CL and eBay

speedqueen's profile picture
Get a vintage Electrolux like a 1205 or an Olympia 1. Best vacuum of the canister and tank category in my personal opinion. A motor that lasts forever, tools that aren't toys, like a real horsehair dust brush and floor tool. Auto cord rewind that isn't cheap and breakable.

Post# 985648 , Reply# 3   3/7/2018 at 06:44 (198 days old) by Gyrafoam (Roanoke, VA)        

Be a hostage to the bags, and get the job done well.
If I had to buy new, Miele would be the brand.

Post# 985652 , Reply# 4   3/7/2018 at 07:25 (197 days old) by dermacie (my forever home (Glenshaw, PA))        

dermacie's profile picture
I agree Miele canister would be my number one choice. I don't have one yet but I may get one soon.

Post# 985654 , Reply# 5   3/7/2018 at 08:06 (197 days old) by Yogitunes (New Jersey)        

yogitunes's profile picture
I was never a fan of Dyson....between the price tag and the maintenance...worth it...

and I have been through a number of vacuums...some good, some bad, pros and cons to each....

if brand new, try a few out, keep the one your like best, and take the rest back...

but oddly enough, I do like the Shark Rotator Lift-Away, very durable considering the way my kids will bang things around...

I must have ever accessory available....its both a canister and an upright in a quick change out....

I got two of them at a flea market for 25.00 a piece......

I am on the lookout for the Powered Lift Away

but you do have to choose one that fits your needs best....

Post# 985670 , Reply# 6   3/7/2018 at 09:51 (197 days old) by nmassman44 (Boston North Shore Massachusetts)        

nmassman44's profile picture
I have a Miele Ariel that I use daily. I have to keep up with 3 cats and it does quite well. It’s going on 10 years now and no issues at all.
I also have a Dyson Animal upright that does not have the suction that the Miele has and it is a lot more work to use than the Miele. Plus the Dyson is hatless so one has to go outside to empty the bin into the trash can. If you empty it into a trash can in the house, all that dust and dirt goes matter how far down I go into the trash’s like a cloud.
You don’t have to get a fancy Miele vacuum because they are not cheap by any means. I paid $500 for the S5 Miele Ariel and that was bottom of the line. I have seen a couple of Miele vacs that are canisters that start at $299 at Bed, Bath and Beyoncé....

Post# 985674 , Reply# 7   3/7/2018 at 10:00 (197 days old) by johnb300m (Chicago)        

johnb300m's profile picture
Hmmmmm, I'd get a decent Bissell multi-cyclonic with a pet accessory tool.
Bissells are decent, durable, have Dyson tech in them now, and affordable.
The money saved on the Bissell can go to the robot later.... or now :)

However......the Dysons do have the best bare floor performance I've seen. They have a nice, durable squeegee behind the brush roll.
Other makes might have that feature too. It's one to look for.

Post# 985679 , Reply# 8   3/7/2018 at 10:49 (197 days old) by 48bencix (Sacramento CA)        

I sure like the Electrolux Tank cleaners. I had the 1950's model, pic one, but now have the 1980's model. Both use the same bag which I can get at my local Ace Hardware, Emigh Hardware. The bag has a seal on the end so when you remove it the dust stays inside. These cleaners have strong suction. Aerus still sells this type of vacuum and I believe the bags fit those also. I got the 1980's model on Ebay.

  Photos...       <              >      Photo 1 of 2         View Full Size
Post# 985681 , Reply# 9   3/7/2018 at 11:07 (197 days old) by washman (Butler, PA)        
I have a Riccar

washman's profile picture

they are assembled in USA, Had mine now for 14 years with no issues at all except one EASY belt replacement.

Post# 985692 , Reply# 10   3/7/2018 at 14:23 (197 days old) by RevvinKevin (So. Cal.)        

revvinkevin's profile picture



I bought a canister vac from Sears (made by WP?) 25-30 years ago and paid around $350 at the time.   It's the next model after this one in the photo (and it's white).  It has good suction and has been very reliable.  Only repairs I've had to do is replace a wheel, the hose, and the plug at the end of the power cord.  It's been a very solid machine.


Personally I don't like the bag-less vacs, never have.   If I have to replace a bag when it's full, so what!  There was a Bissel (something) here at work that I used a few years ago to vacuum our little office.  EVERY time I turned it on, it blew a noticeable "puff" of dirt out the vent.   It continued to do this, even AFTER I cleaned all 3 of the "filters" (2 washable foam, 1 paper).   I turned it on and off repeatedly (25 times) and the dirt never stopped blowing out when turned on!  Granted it's very dirty here and they probably never bothered to clean it properly, but still, yuck!


I will never buy a Dyson.  Too much $$$, the motor generates a LOT of heat and the high-pitched whine from the motor is almost like fingernails on a chalk board for me.



  Photos...       <              >      Photo 1 of 2         View Full Size
Post# 985693 , Reply# 11   3/7/2018 at 14:35 (197 days old) by RevvinKevin (So. Cal.)        
Never heard of Riccar before this........

revvinkevin's profile picture




Thomas, looks like this could be an option.  This model (Sunburst) has a HEPA filter and is under $200 according to the Co website.   There are also a number of dealers in the LA / South Bay & OC areas too.


  View Full Size
Post# 985697 , Reply# 12   3/7/2018 at 15:20 (197 days old) by thomasortega (Los Angeles - CA)        

Can anybody tell me how is the Bissell Crosswave filtration for super fine dust (that black dust from air pollution and the wall furnace that sits everywhere and cat allergens? Of course, using the dry vacuum mode only.

Sometimes i wash my laminate floors using the Hoover Floormate, but I try to avoid it because water and laminates are not a good match and also, come on, who really needs to wash the floors every day in an apartment with only 2 people and a cat? Nope, I'm not a germophobe, but I like things clean, specially my floors. If it's clean, ok, let's clean it or wash it, but i never wash the floor if it's not visibly dirty beyond what a vacuum can pick up. I'll have to vac every day (or maybe 2x per day) because I'm allergic to cats. And no, I don't want to get rid of that lion because I liked it and started to love him, even knowing he wants to dillacerate my body.

The idea I had is have a crosswave for the floors and keep using the Constellation or the B&D for above ground cleaning. The floormate is great, but it's an early 2000's model with a huge head that is a pain to use because it doesn't fit in many spaces.

Used vacuums, no, thanks!

Miele... I just changed my mind after I visited the website and saw the prices. Even if I were a millionaire I'd think a zillion of times before spending such fortune on a vacuum cleaner. I know it's probably the best vacuum ever but it's too expensive. Miele just became a no, no for me.

Post# 985760 , Reply# 13   3/7/2018 at 23:05 (197 days old) by superocd (PNW)        

Too bad you don't have carpets, lol. Hands down, I would have recommended the Sanitaire SC886 with an F&G conversion bag to replace the shake out bag these come with for better filtration. Every time I hear someone speak about vacuums, I have to sing its praises because it cleans really well and will last a very long time.

However, a Sanitaire would be as good as useless for your intents and purposes. I have to admit, though, life without carpets must be a bit easier.

Post# 985762 , Reply# 14   3/7/2018 at 23:46 (197 days old) by Spacedogb (Lafayette, LA)        
Just my 2 cents

I own Miele, Kirby and rainbow. I’m blown away by my Dyson V6 absolute. It hangs on the wall when not in use and does everything my other vacs can. I also have a Hoover Lynx with the rechargeable battery. It too is an amazing small vacuum that does everything a larger vac can

Post# 985772 , Reply# 15   3/8/2018 at 02:46 (197 days old) by thomasortega (Los Angeles - CA)        

Yep, When i was in Brazil I also had an Electrolux Ergorapido.

I got it for free (I worked at Electrolux-Sulclean and it was our "souvenir" for some important clients or business partners) That little thing was great on hard floors and even some quick pickup on rugs. The battery lasted enough to vac the whole apartment (3 bedrooms) and I was done much before the battery think about loosing power. The head size was also perfect because it would fit around the toilet and if the area was really tight, i could just snap off the handheld and vac the area and then snap on again and continue vacuuming.

The only down on that is the filter. It's not HEPA, otherwise I'd run and get another ergorapido without thinking twice.

Anyway, folks. an update:

Today i had a severe allergy crisis and freaked out. Unfortunately I had to ask Darryl to get rid of that cat. (He took to his father's house, where he has other three). I'm sad because I started to love that cat and now I miss it, but my health is more important. I can't simply be allergic to my own house because of a cat.

Now I have to clean the whole apartment as if I were a germophobe, to make sure not even a single cat hair is left behind. Just in case I'll vac everything, from the floor to the ceiling, wash the floors using the floormate and, just in case, use my steam cleaner to steam everything.

To make things much worse, on Monday I'll have guests coming from Texas to spend 4 or 5 days here.

Crazy days to come before my guests arrive.

As we're spending a lot of money buying more dinnerware (Because of course I'll cook a lot for the guests) and I got rid of the cat, I'll postpone the new vac and deal with the Consellation.

I use Arm and Hammer bags on it as I can't find the original S-bag, but luckily there is one more original HEPA bag left in the box.

I love the tools that came with the Constellation The bare floor brush is great and the suction is excellent, but as I mentioned above, using that vac is a PITA.

Post# 985801 , Reply# 16   3/8/2018 at 07:48 (196 days old) by panthera (Rocky Mountains)        
If it has to be 'modern' and no Kirby

panthera's profile picture

Then Lawrence is right - Miele is the only answer.

Post# 985802 , Reply# 17   3/8/2018 at 08:06 (196 days old) by jmm63 (Denville, NJ)        

jmm63's profile picture
Big fan of Miele, have a White Pearl canister that is about 25 years old, and only 1 repair. I understand the newer ones are much smaller and easier to navigate with.

Have had a Kirby, nice vacuum but so bulky and hard to use, it's best for just carpets only.

Also have had a Bissell, really just JUNK, and a couple Kenmores, which were ok

Which brings me to my Shark Rotator Professional. I thought it was going to be cheap junk and I would be throwing it away in a year or so. Quite Honestly, its the best vacuum I have ever had. Fairly quiet, powerful, versatile and a great cleaner. I can't sing the praises of it enough, was so surprised. It's 4 years old now and never a repair.

Post# 985814 , Reply# 18   3/8/2018 at 09:28 (196 days old) by vacerator (Macomb, Michigan)        
Oh yes, Miele

is der "spitzenklasse". The newer ones have 4 wheels which rotate 360 degrees. The Alize model even has sprung wheels, but not the top line Brilliant. Go figure.
Maybe it's because the Alize doesn't come with a power nozzle, and meant more for hard floors with raised thresholds.
Bags and filters are pricey. Another fine German machine is Sebo.
Many on the companion site would chime in there, with varied opinions.
I've been using my central vac since 1996 when I installed it.
Hubby told me to buy vac bags that day for my hand me down form my mom Eureka model 1289 brandywine canned ham power team. I bought it for her in 1979. Still have it. It's heavy. When hubby got home that evening, we had a new central vac. He was livid. Then he loved it. Less dust in the house, quiet, no dog hair, no wheezing for me. No bags to buy, just empty the bin every two months, and brush the polyester permanent filter clean.
"No, it does not clog up". I left the elbow in the garage below the power unit un-cemented so if a large or heavy item goes in, it can be removed there.

Post# 985816 , Reply# 19   3/8/2018 at 09:29 (196 days old) by vacerator (Macomb, Michigan)        
Oh, and

a nice CV system won't set you back much more than a Miele brilliant or marin, less the install cost.

Post# 985817 , Reply# 20   3/8/2018 at 09:33 (196 days old) by askolover (South of Nash Vegas, TN)        

askolover's profile picture

There are very good barely used Kirbys on CL all the time for a fraction of their original price.  I have 2 and bought my mother one also.  I ain't payin' $2000 for a new one!

Post# 985822 , Reply# 21   3/8/2018 at 09:57 (196 days old) by MattL (Flushing, MI)        

Got to say I love my Kirbys. the last one I picked up at GW for $40 had EVERY attachment, the original receipt and even the video.  It's a G5 and I can't say I've ever had anything that has cleaned better.  I rarely use the attachments, I have canister vacs for that, but when I did use the hose a few weeks ago I was impressed with the suction, it rivalled my mid sized shop vac!


I will say they are a bit heavy, and I've been lucky enough to pick up 3 at very good prices so I keep one on each floor so no carrying up and down stairs.  Love the power drive and the HEPA bags too.  The bare floor nozzle is interesting but once I got used to manoeuvring it I was surprised at how handy it is.


Post# 985828 , Reply# 22   3/8/2018 at 11:07 (196 days old) by GusHerb (Chicago/NWI)        

I've had my eyes on the Sebo Felix for a few years now. I have mostly hard floors with one carpeted room and some area rugs. It comes with a powernozzle and the parquet brush for hard floors. The machine is extremely versatile and has several more attachment options to choose from. They are variable speed, extremely quiet even at top speed, and has great filtration. 

My daily driver has been a Dyson DC17 for the last several years which has been fine, I chose that because of it's versatility that I need for what I'm cleaning. I still overall do not like bagless though. The DC17 and DC28 are about the only really decent vacuums Dyson ever made. 


Post# 985832 , Reply# 23   3/8/2018 at 11:56 (196 days old) by pulltostart (Mobile, AL)        

pulltostart's profile picture

I was raised with a Filter Queen, and have always been a canister fan.  I have 6 Electrolux, and I use all of them.  They all use the same bags, same tools, same power nozzels.  Two are new enough that they require a different hose from the other four.  My favorite is a Super J.



Post# 985834 , Reply# 24   3/8/2018 at 13:04 (196 days old) by lakewebsterkid (Dayton, Ohio)        

I love my Miele U1 Dynamic Maverick. CR just tested it and said it didn't do as well as the Cat and Dog version. That's hard to believe, but who cares. I buy the bags through Bed Bath and Beyond with a 20% off coupon and the filters are included as well. It isn't a bad deal. I never have to clean anything out. Our old Bissel required a cleaning every time it was used. Because of this vacuuming was a hassle and generally made a bigger mess than what we were going to clean up. Also, it is by far the most quiet and powerful vacuum I have ever used. It will shit on a Dyson any day of the week. Also, I purchased mine through Bed Bath and Beyond when it was in sale and used a 20% off coupon. It ended up being approximately $260.

Post# 985864 , Reply# 25   3/8/2018 at 17:50 (196 days old) by ea56 (Sonoma Co.,CA)        

ea56's profile picture
I love vacuum cleaners! They were the very first appliances that I actually got to use as a child. Over my 67 years I’ve used and owned just about every brand and type there is,except for a central vac system. Right now we have a new generation Constellation that we got about 10 years ago, an Oreck thats about 8 years old, a Prolux Upright (a Riccar knockoff) and a Kenmore 29319 canister. We live in a two story townhouse that is all wall to wall carpeted, except for the kitchen and the bathrooms. Without doubt the Kenmore is the best of all and our daily driver. The Hoover Constellation is the other most used, the others just gather dust.

Both David and I like the Kenmore canister best because of the versatility and maneuverability. It also does an excellent job keeping our carpets looking like new. It’s easy to use, has on board attachments and is BAGGED. I hate bagless vacuums! They are a mess to empty and the filters are a PITA to clean.

Over the years we’ve owned 5 of these Kenmore’s, all great. On one the electircal connection in the handle wore out, so the power head wouldn’t work. but the others never had any problems. The only reason they were replaced was because of my irrational obsession with getting yet another vacuum, which I imagine most here can relate to.

But if one could only have one vacuum, I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend this reasonably priced Kenmore 29319, it will do everything you need it to do.


  View Full Size
Post# 985876 , Reply# 26   3/8/2018 at 18:47 (196 days old) by thomasortega (Los Angeles - CA)        

If I choose a Miele Darryl would kill me!

$1400 for a vacuum... well, if he arrived here with a Miele vacuum under his arm I don't know if I'd kiss him or divorce him. ROFL

Maybe I'd look at him with the same face I looked when he immediatelly got the message and took that cat away from here.

We have much things that are more important than a super premium vacuum cleaner and our budget is still comfortable, but tight.

A central vac... humm, I always dreamed about having one. But of course I won't even consider that in a rented apartment. (I won't even mention i want to move out ASAP.)

Post# 985885 , Reply# 27   3/8/2018 at 20:11 (196 days old) by Stricklybojack (San Diego, CA)        

stricklybojack's profile picture
Imo get the best used bagged canister you can find.
Riccar/Simplcity, Kenmore/Panasonic being my top choices. Miele vacuums have toy-like attachments and smailer more expensive bags and filters. Not a great value although they have a following.
Here is a place in Costa Mesa that may have a deal or two.
If you are planning a trip to San Diego I have a couple...hundred...vacuums, I very well could have one that you may like.

CLICK HERE TO GO TO Stricklybojack's LINK on Orange County, CA Craigslist

  View Full Size
Post# 985897 , Reply# 28   3/8/2018 at 22:03 (196 days old) by dartman (Portland Oregon)        

I set searches for things I want on Craigslist and one of them is for Royal vacuum as I have and like a couple of their cannister vac. I always get hits mostly for overpriced Kirby style uprights. I found my last 4650 canister from it for 25 bucks needing some work. Recently I saw a ad for a nice looking upright that turned out to be a Stark/Royal 5700/9700. Wrote asking how much and was told free with extra bags and belts, works great, wife wanted a lighter wood floor freindly version. I picked it up a hour or so later. It needed some cleaning but does run and clean my carpet great and is sturdy and less parts to wear out. I bet with a saved search and some time you could find almost any vacuum made you might like and free or cheap does happen as some folks have something else and just want it gone.

Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      

Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In

New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.

Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy