Thread Number: 93372
/ Tag: Modern Automatic Washers
Tear Down Video Series - GE vs. SQ vs. Maytag |
[Down to Last] | ![]() |
Post# 1180438   5/12/2023 at 15:25 (209 days old) by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1180439 , Reply# 1   5/12/2023 at 15:40 (209 days old) by qsd-dan (West)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 7    
![]() |
Post# 1180448 , Reply# 2   5/12/2023 at 17:25 (209 days old) by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() I think they are going to post a series of videos over the course of weeks or months.
I applaud SQ for doing this. I'm hoping that some miracle will happen and people will start buying machines based on how they're are made, not how they look on the outside.
Only thing that catches my eye besides the SQ is the capacitor and its mount on the GE, everything else is 🤮 This post was last edited 05/12/2023 at 17:46 |
Post# 1180523 , Reply# 3   5/13/2023 at 15:43 (208 days old) by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
I saw the video, and I'm curious about how Speed Queen stacks up to GE and Maytag in terms of their drive system and suspension. |
Post# 1180566 , Reply# 4   5/14/2023 at 02:45 (208 days old) by GRNAppliance (Whakatane, New Zealand)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 11    
![]() |
Post# 1181325 , Reply# 5   5/26/2023 at 16:57 (195 days old) by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1181352 , Reply# 6   5/27/2023 at 10:55 (194 days old) by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
I saw the pump teardown, and it was very telling about the simplicity and quality they have. Next, I'd like to see the drive system, including the motor. |
Post# 1181357 , Reply# 7   5/27/2023 at 12:41 (194 days old) by cfz2882 (Belle Fourche,SD)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
all 3 of those pumps are craptastic-only decent "magnetic"pump I have experienced is the Italian made"plaset"brand one in my '98 Neptune,The Ascoll pump in my '01 HE3 is ok. That GE is very similar to a VMW :) |
Post# 1181440 , Reply# 8   5/29/2023 at 04:40 (192 days old) by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 3    
![]() |
Post# 1181496 , Reply# 9   5/29/2023 at 21:34 (192 days old) by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
The Speed Queen top loaders have a real drain pump. I just don't like the early spray rinse and the low speed spin before the rinse and after wash. |
Post# 1182509 , Reply# 10   6/13/2023 at 17:24 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1182568 , Reply# 11   6/14/2023 at 10:13 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
I would take the Speed Queen any day of the week, especially how sturdy they are. |
Post# 1183634 , Reply# 12   6/28/2023 at 12:27 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1183652 , Reply# 13   6/28/2023 at 15:36 by qsd-dan (West)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 3    
![]() |
Post# 1183655 , Reply# 14   6/28/2023 at 15:43 by Maytag85 (Sean A806)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]()
If Maytag were still around, the Maytag in Newton Iowa that is, they’d probably have such a huge market share since their machines could easily be repaired and would easily last 20 to 30+ years. Even if Whirlpool beefed up their VMW machines along it’s the rest of the machines that are out there, they still couldn’t compete with the legendary Maytag helical machines. Only thing that probably would be different is they’d probably would use an inverter motor similar to the one Robert hot rodded back in 2019.
|
Post# 1183671 , Reply# 15   6/28/2023 at 19:15 by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1183679 , Reply# 16   6/28/2023 at 19:45 by qsd-dan (West)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1183682 , Reply# 17   6/28/2023 at 20:00 by RyneR1988 ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]()
A good portion of the public can get away with a front loader if used correctly.
I agree with this. It's what I plan to do once my direct drive Whirlpool top loader becomes unrepairable. There's not a top load washer on the market today, sans the Speed Queen TC5, that's worth much in cleaning performance or reliability. A front loader is the way to go if buying new. |
Post# 1183687 , Reply# 18   6/28/2023 at 20:19 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]()
I wish GE was still making Filter-Flos' and these as well. I think this WBSE3120B1WW model is my all time favorite GE washing machine along with the matching DBXR463EB0WW dryer at my cousin's cabin.
View Full Size
|
Post# 1183730 , Reply# 19   6/29/2023 at 09:06 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
It would be nice if GE brought back the filter-flo. |
Post# 1183764 , Reply# 20   6/29/2023 at 16:14 by wayupnorth ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 7    
![]() |
Post# 1183779 , Reply# 21   6/29/2023 at 20:58 by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() If everyone were like me the filter flo would still be in production somewhere. GE would also have faced multiple class action lawsuits, consumer fraud charges and a tribunal for their tax evasion, atrocious late 90s/2000s products and abusive customer service.
I wish the washer to the left in the video was a GE FF instead of what has become of modern day GE. This post was last edited 06/29/2023 at 22:30 |
Post# 1183803 , Reply# 23   6/30/2023 at 09:16 by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() The entire inner and outer tub shakes during agitation, sometimes causing the tub straps to break.
In spin I personally had the tub resonate to the point of banging against the cabinet. There are documented cases of these washer self destructing because of it. The suspension is to un-dampened and the basket accelerates way to fast.
Cleaning is good on small loads, but on large loads the turn over was very poor. The clothes around the agi would get shredded while the rest would just jiggle as everything else shook around them.
Post FF washers should never have seen the light of day. I also feel they're way to over-rated by the appliance community in general. |
Post# 1183822 , Reply# 24   6/30/2023 at 13:14 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
Common sense says they should've revamped the entire filter-flo laundry line. But no. GE engineers thought we were too stupid to notice. And don't even get me started about the gear oil smell and the leaks. |
Post# 1185203 , Reply# 25   7/18/2023 at 17:42 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1185216 , Reply# 26   7/18/2023 at 20:43 by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() Opportunity ruined.
What the video doesn't mention is that the Speed Queen motor is isn't just 1 HP, but also a 3 phase high frequency inverter driven where as the two other motors are across the line permanent split capacitor motors. Absolute night and day difference in terms of motor protection, torque, noise, vibration, speed control, tub control, braking, sensing, efficiency, heat generation, longevity, and data feedback. The video is essentially botched failing to mention these very important advantageous facts.
I feel videos like these are unfair to Speed Queen, they don't do justice to Speed Queen's quality failing to mention important technical details and countless ingenious engineering concepts built into Speed Queen.
Then again truth is much to profound. If all three machines were compared from a pertinent engineering, physics, design, mathematical and economic standpoint the Speed Queen would rack up so many points it would make the video look obscenely biased toward Speed Queen.
Hopefully the next videos will highlight how the tub seal, motor shaft and best top loading suspension ever built on the Speed Queen can out last the other two machines by 60 years.
|
Post# 1185419 , Reply# 27   7/21/2023 at 15:08 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
What they also fail to mention is how much force it will take to "agitate" the tub even on heavy duty. That takes a lot of energy. So how is that saving energy? |
Post# 1185424 , Reply# 28   7/21/2023 at 17:08 by Ultramatic ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1185506 , Reply# 29   7/22/2023 at 09:00 by chetlaham (United States)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1186511 , Reply# 30   8/1/2023 at 16:40 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |
Post# 1186519 , Reply# 31   8/1/2023 at 17:58 by John76 (USA)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 4    
Love the simplicity and quality of the Speed Queen TR series. |
Post# 1186520 , Reply# 32   8/1/2023 at 18:06 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
Notice how Speed Queen uses a beefy bearing system and an extra heavy shaft. Everybody else uses a transmission. |
Post# 1186540 , Reply# 33   8/1/2023 at 19:08 by qsd-dan (West)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1186557 , Reply# 34   8/1/2023 at 21:45 by DADoES ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 1    
![]() |
Post# 1186575 , Reply# 35   8/2/2023 at 06:30 by GELaundry4ever ![]() |
  | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]()      
Which obviously translates to poor wash action without a transmission. It's called the perfect wash system. Too gentle in my opinion. I have sturdy cottons. |
Post# 1188204 , Reply# 37   8/22/2023 at 17:16 by panasonicvac (Northern Utah)   |   | |
Checkrate/Likes
![]() 2    
![]() |