Thread Number: 52765
Europe phosphate regulations- all STPP out within 2016 in DW products?
[Down to Last]

automaticwasher.org's exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate automaticwasher.org if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 750737   4/17/2014 at 17:31 (3,683 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
HiI all, have just read a thing that terrorize me just to think of it, within 2015 all dishwashing detergents for domestic use in europe will come without STPP, but that's already happened in the US with pretty disastrous effect even though mitigated by institutional products discovery and pretty readily available pure stpp, but what scares me is that within 2016 they want to take them out even from all of commercial/institutional products.
I could see that in the US that is happening with Institutional cascade also, but as our dear Michael (Mich) posted in a thread P&G quickly found a stratagem to keep selling the good stuff as a fryer cleaner. BTW I could see bubble bandit keeps selling the stuff indisturbed why Bubble bandit no and cascade stopped even the posphate laden institutional DW peoduct?

And in Europe....
How they gonna do??? Actually I seriously hope that within 2016 I have already got te a$$ outta here, really I am getting mad in here cannot stand Italy and Europe anymore, so either I get outta here or I will finish tightened to a wall in a mad house...
Sticking to the Stpp problem
Cannot help but think that unlike in the USA, is hard to find places where to buy STPP over here, at least easily...
And EU dictators bitches up there in Bruxelles, stubborn as they are in these green BS are probably going to regulate severely and maniacally, not to mention that for these kinds of secondary unimportant regulations in Europe they tend to get pathetically knobsticks-like at making them respect, while about the important things nobody cares really of, I think they'll be hard times finding something containing it even in other forms...so gimmicks will be hard to be done by companies...
Also, I wonder of the sorts of the brands...Finish is #1 over here...
We can see how in the USA they pulled over the electrasol brand not to ruin the name reputation, naming it Finish, i wonder if they are gonna do the same here with Finish/neophos turning to electrasol then?

They'll be hard times......And not sure how it will end like...

Any thoughts?






Post# 750753 , Reply# 1   4/17/2014 at 18:39 (3,683 days old) by washer111 ()        

"And another one bits the dust," is all I can think of here... 

 

We're still blessed with Phosphates here in Australia, but only in dishwashing detergents. Some "Eco-Nazi's" got it mandated out of laundry stuff (I think Radiant has basically discontinued its phosphate-line - although I couldn't tell any difference, TBH). 

 

Perhaps I ought to open a web-store and sell Australian Finish?


Post# 750818 , Reply# 2   4/17/2014 at 23:43 (3,683 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Stop the bitching already. There are limited resources of phosphates in the world and most resources are in dubious countries. And as we need phosphates to grow food, the choice has been made all over the world to limite the use of phosphates as long as we are not able to recycle phosphates in a good and cheap manner. So, where ever in the world you go, you will find that phosphates will not be used in detergents anymore.

Post# 750826 , Reply# 3   4/18/2014 at 01:11 (3,683 days old) by joe_in_philly (Philadelphia, PA, USA)        

joe_in_philly's profile picture
Don't worry. The currently available phosphate-free detergents are much better than when they first came out, and work better than the older phosphate detergents. I am using up my last container of phosphate cascade pacs, and I use them for smaller loads since they don't leave the dishes as shiny as the new phosphate-free detergents. I have medium-hard water, and my dishwasher doesn't have a water softener.

Post# 750832 , Reply# 4   4/18/2014 at 01:45 (3,683 days old) by washer111 ()        

At least in my case, the phosphate product we have performs better than those lacking...

ESPECIALLY when one gets into "Eco" products


Post# 750836 , Reply# 5   4/18/2014 at 02:09 (3,683 days old) by tolivac (greenville nc)        

PCS Phospates are right here in Eastern North Carolina-the Southeast part of the US is rich in phospahte mining-so its out of detergents--BUT--did you realize you are DRINKING it in just about ANY soda drink?So---where does the phospate go after it leaves you???These phospate bans for cleaning products borders on silliness-again politicians poking there noses where they don't belong.Watch the PCS trains go by my place daily.

Post# 750840 , Reply# 6   4/18/2014 at 02:23 (3,683 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
The fact that trains with the stuff pass your place daily doesn't say a thing about the upcoming shortage. We've not run out yet, but will in the future if we are not careful. China is one of the countries with huge resources, but they are keeping it to themselves.

In the middle ages people used urine to do laundry. Now if only we could make a filter to get the phosphate out of urine. You could have your own STPP factory!



Post# 750845 , Reply# 7   4/18/2014 at 03:46 (3,683 days old) by arbilab (Ft Worth TX (Ridglea))        

arbilab's profile picture
Not to contracept anyone on a subject about which I know next to nothing, but if phosphates were the new platinum howzcome we buy them off the web for $5 a pound? Isn't the phosphate thing all just eco-knotzies?

We can't get fullsize persian limes since a month ago for ANY price. THAT's a shortage. Due to western drought filet mignon is now $20/lb and all other beef proportionally higher, THAT's a shortage. Just the forecast of a hurricane in the Gulf raises gas prices a dollar on a SPECULATIVE shortage that hasn't even happened yet.

And detergent prices have doubled as it is. The box that used to cost $6 is now $12. AFTER phosphates were removed.

Well nevermind me, I get grumpy around 3am waiting for I Love Lucy reruns to start.


Post# 750849 , Reply# 8   4/18/2014 at 04:43 (3,683 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
It's not exactly like phosphates are no longer available next year, but it will happen in the next 50 years or so. Problems are not as big in the USA with it's own resources than in Europe, that has no resources at all. In the future phosphates in Europe might be still available, but it's apparent that prices will rise.

Post# 750852 , Reply# 9   4/18/2014 at 04:59 (3,683 days old) by arbilab (Ft Worth TX (Ridglea))        
Can't argue with....

arbilab's profile picture
..."prices will rise". My car insurance just went up $70/yr and there's no shortage of car insurance. Nor have I filed a claim in 25 years with the company.

Post# 750861 , Reply# 10   4/18/2014 at 06:18 (3,683 days old) by tolivac (greenville nc)        

The trains coming from the PCS phospahte mine go North to New Jersey and such to the chemical plants.There is PLENTY of the stuff here.Same with in Florida,South Carolina-just about any Southeast state.We may use up the phospates faster in soft drinks than cleaning products.Its used as a preservative in the drinks.The mines here are one of the areas largest employers.I wouldn't worry about the mines going dry soon.And I see trains carrying fill material in the fill in ares that are mined out.There are also fossil hunts in the mines-they shut down for a day or so and let fossil hunters look for fossils of fish,shells,other sea life.The mine even has a fossil museam.Some of the largest dragline excavators work in these mines.The draglines dig to expose the phospate containing veins.Then when the phosphate is mined out-the fill dirt is put in the restore the area.The mines are in swampy places.

Post# 750867 , Reply# 11   4/18/2014 at 06:55 (3,683 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I start with the premise that my DW sucks, but could clearly see the difference by using products containing phosphatss and ones that does not...
So I think I am prone to claim my phosphates any day if this will happen, I think in the USA this problem has been felt greatly than maybe it will be in europe since dishwasher in the US didn't always had a built in water softener like about every model of european ones instead had, we could all see how dishwasher detergent in the USA were formlated to give perfect results even in hard water, moreover there were also pure Stpp additives such as Finish glass magic one could add to enhance cleaning power and shiny results, probably the lack of phosphates in DW products in the US has been felt greatly than how it may be elsewhere..Including the fact that too less time was given to detergent makers to find alternative ingredients (that IMO still does not exist)...and resulted in bad mineral depositating problems other than inferior poor cleaning abilities of these new versions.
But for what concerns europe, I could experience the same and could see how the phosphate free detergents I have used didn't give good or acceptable results to me in matter of cleaning, so I am one of the many ones who will probably and eventually seek desperately ways to keep using phosphated products...
Louis, sorry you see this as bitching, really is not, please respect others points of view, you know I am used to say what I think always....expressing an opinion should never been exchanged for bitching.....and even if were so please accept someone may not agree, is legitimate and I don't think people would really waste time "bitching" if it was not a real peoblem...no?
Said this, I cannot really say anything about the scarcity on phosphates in Europe for sure, all I could read is that it is done because of enviroinmentally reasons and pollutioning beliefs, nothing mentioned about this....but only the old story of phosphates in detergents as responsible for the "fertilization" of algaes in the waters, altering the water eco-system...
If so, I think it would have been wiser telling the truth....if what you say is the truth, not only the enviroinmentally side...
You know, the primar source of phosphates "pollutioning" of water does not come from detergents, but from farming....
Regarding other countries Louis, I see in Asia, South america and africa, the stuff is still present in detergents, but I suppose this phosphate ban will reach them too sooner or later...
I don't think this is a matter of costs though, From what I can see instead phosphated products are cheaper or same prices than ones without them also, over here even the cheaper store brand one has them still...
If there would really be a threat about them not being " naturally" available anymore in a next future, I think detergent manufacturers would be more insterested on their own, about this, I mean in finding alternative stuff, but I could see they are rather pushed to do so by governments, and for them is just a nuisance giving no few problems and extra costs for researches in reformulations etc...that otherwise they'd have never started on their own...
But again, these regulations being caused by a prevision a future shortage, as you say,is a reason I've never read,till now....not saying it is not true...it's just news to me and sure deserves further investigation...till now all i could read is about enviroinment only, so I speak accordingly.



Post# 750869 , Reply# 12   4/18/2014 at 07:05 (3,683 days old) by washer111 ()        

As for those claims about "Save the Environment," they are WAY out of line!!!

 

Did you know that domestic Phosphate output into the environment (from Laundering/Dishwashing) equates to a percentage value below 10?*

 

That is, the majority is out-put by CARELESS industry:

~ Farmers who think fertiliser is the Be-All and End-All, and haven't heard of properly calculating fertiliser quantities, or other means of improving the soil

Case in Point, this occurred at my family's farm - we managed to improve the soil far better with Lime and much less fertiliser, than with fertiliser alone. Less cost, less environmental impact and better yield from some pretty easy calculation. 

 

~ Mega-Corporations who don't give a damn about anyone or anything, only profits. 

 

The other issue is DOMESTIC fertiliser application where people live near major waterways, and again, over application of fast-releasing products, rather than slow-release products is the issue.

 

Ultimately, this problem stems from negligence (or carelessness, if you like). NOT laundering products. 

 

*AFAIK, when they banned Phosphates in detergent in Washington DC, apparently the rivers surrounding didn't clear up, as a result of industry (farms/factories) upstream continuing their output. Go figure, right? Industry = Problem, so Change for Average-Joe = Solution. 


Post# 750972 , Reply# 13   4/18/2014 at 15:55 (3,682 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Goodness, where do I start...

Wikipedia gives some more information about phosphates:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phosphate...

You can read there what countries have phosphate mines. No mines in Europe and some mines in countries that are political not the most stable.

As for environmental issues, phosphates never were the cause of polluting rivers. Phosphates will however increase grow of algae in standing water, especially when they disturb the balance in such waters. Yes, there are a lot of phosphates in other things than detergents. Phosphates in detergent were probably not the main cause of it. But filtering phosphates out of waste water would be a good thing. Now if only there would be a cheap way to recycle phosphates. It would be such a good thing to put them back in detergent then, because they work so much better than the alternatives like zeolites.


Post# 751007 , Reply# 14   4/18/2014 at 17:28 (3,682 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Goodness where do I start..... Calm down Louis! :) LOL
Thanks You for the link, really this is the classical debate about sources, , there's who says that they will last for 300 years, others just 100... Etc...
Really do not know what to think......or take for certain here, except factual stuff like lack of mines in Europe...
Again, didn't put in discussion your statement about Europe not having own mines, but I just talk based on what I read around, and what you say absolutely didn't appear to be the main concern for which is done... At least apparently..
Just take as example this EU press release (is in italian, google translate will help)
europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP-...
Always and only about enviroinmental pollution aspects, kinda like if detergents were the only responsible...
Like these countless out there...

I really think that if it is as you said, would be very more wiser that they let the people know of this, and not just screaming around regarding enviroinment only, and again, pointing fingers on detergents.
No one I have read ever stated that this is made to preserve phosphates sources...which is a fact that would shut up possible controversies about phosphate pollutioning responsability, letting them passz z for second...
Do not know where europeans gets the stuff, but until now it didn't appear to be a problem to be gotten..... Nor apparently seems will be in a next future...this always accordingly to what one can read around and the reasons why they said they're gonna take out phosphates, which looks are others...
Go figure!











This post was last edited 04/18/2014 at 17:51
Post# 751039 , Reply# 15   4/18/2014 at 19:48 (3,682 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        

I'm pretty sure the Finish powder I buy from Costco is now phosphate free. I am still pretty happy with it. Dishes come out clean and they even squeak when I rubb my finger accross. Unlike some of those other dw detergents with the blue stuff, it doesn't leave any sticky residue in the dishwasher.

As for washing detergents, I'm currently using Kirkland and some OMO that I bought out of curiosity. Both are phosphate free and my clothes are fine. I add a scoop of sodium percarbonate to towels and whites and I don't usually pre-treat either. Results are very good.


Post# 751109 , Reply# 16   4/19/2014 at 03:04 (3,682 days old) by tolivac (greenville nc)        

Excellent point-another thing about phosphate pollution-runoff from farms and yes,home lawns.Fertilizers have phosphates in them,too-unregulated.Its said most of the fertilizer applied to farm feild and lawns is lost to runoff after watering and rain.The runoff ends up as pollution in rivers,streams,lakes and such.Nothing is said about this from the nosey politicians!I don't use fertilizers on my lawn-nor weed and insect killers-so my lawn is sparse and weedy--the mower just cuts it all to the same height!!The clippings,leaves,and such make my "fertilizer" just use the mulching blades on my mower.Farmers around here do the same by bushhogging or flail mowing the feild before plowing.The mowing shreds the old crop.Next they "disc" it-the disc harrow chops the stuff more and mixes it in the ground.The discing also destroys underground insect grubs.

Post# 751166 , Reply# 17   4/19/2014 at 09:59 (3,682 days old) by washer111 ()        

Interesting point you make Rapunzel... Last I checked, the MSDS was updated late 2011, and still had Phosphates. I couldn't find that document tonight, but I checked my current 1KG bottle of Lemon 2X Concentrate. 

 

Under the small headline "Environmental Information," the sheet says "FINISH contains no Chlorine Bleach. FINISH surfactants are bio-degradable."

(It doesn't say that exactly - I've probably minced words. But thats the general "gist" of things). 

No "Phosphate-Free" labels either. 


Post# 751195 , Reply# 18   4/19/2014 at 11:55 (3,682 days old) by PassatDoc (Orange County, California)        

The owner of our local appliance store told me that his customers are getting decent results, even with low-water-use late-model dishwashers, and the new no-phosphate DW detergent, but the key seems to be priming the hot water line (using the sink faucet) to ensure the hottest possible first rinse water. Most machines do not heat the first rinse water, so the temp of the incoming water "is" the first rinse temp. With lower water use, priming is more crucial, since the amount of water taken in for first rinse is by itself not enough to prime the hot water line.

Post# 751265 , Reply# 19   4/19/2014 at 17:35 (3,681 days old) by washer111 ()        

You're completely right about that PassatDoc.

 

I always make it "my business" to prime the Dish-Drawer before starting, and anywhere between 16 and 42 minutes later (depending on cycle) for the rinses. Although, your incoming water temperature to the machine will be tempered (either Up or Down), depending on how hot the machine was to start with. 

 

I prefer to prime the lines, since it saves quite a lot of money with Aussie power rates. Maybe not so much elsewhere, but still good for the environment!

There is really no difference in cycle times on the shorter cycles with primed water lines... (At least on the drawers)


Post# 751354 , Reply# 20   4/20/2014 at 01:35 (3,681 days old) by tolivac (greenville nc)        

I run the hotwater before starting the dishwasher-my water heater is in a gartage utility room so it has a little way to go-when I take a shower-have to run the water for a few minutes before it gets hot.

Post# 751358 , Reply# 21   4/20/2014 at 03:52 (3,681 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Overhere in Europe all dishwashers start with a cold prerinse. Never had a problem with cleaning.

Post# 751363 , Reply# 22   4/20/2014 at 05:11 (3,681 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
My bosch start with a warm prewash, no pre-rinse..... And so did all the others I have owned.

Post# 751401 , Reply# 23   4/20/2014 at 08:25 (3,681 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
From what year was that Bosch?

Post# 751473 , Reply# 24   4/20/2014 at 14:39 (3,680 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I bought it new on ebay about 2 years ago now, not sure about the actual year though, it is MOL model, # sgs23e02 eu and deeply repent the purchase. it is worse than the chinese made ones I had before it at washing and materials, is really filmsey, it litterally swings if i push one side of it...could not believe it when I pulled it out of the box...
Anyway, the elettrozeta, haier, whirlpool, zoppas and rex I had before, all of them used to have an heated warm prewash, about 30-40 degrees...




This post was last edited 04/20/2014 at 14:56
Post# 751476 , Reply# 25   4/20/2014 at 15:13 (3,680 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
To say the truth, when I had the Zoppas ans Rex, that had an electromechanical programmer, we were usual to skip the prewash and run immeditaely the main wash....results were just the same as if I had run the prewash..
The Rex we had from 1986 to 2000 something, used to give good washing results till it died (motor), then we got a zoppas it was a little inferior at cleaning and sometimes a little traces were left back, the zoppas only lasted 4 years, then we got the Elettrozeta (chinese made) and was not so good at washing, so I wanted it changed, So I got a whirlpool and it has been really a disappointment (on par with the Haier that came after the whirlpol), the whirpool lasted just few days after the 2 yrs warranty expired ( the heater, placed in the pump pipe got broken)..
I was short of money so I got a cheap haier...
After the Haier that I dumped for desperation, came the bosch...which is even crappier...
Now I kinda use it as pot cupboard....I wash my stuff by hand most of the times, seeking desperately a dishwasher worth to be called so...




This post was last edited 04/20/2014 at 17:25
Post# 751493 , Reply# 26   4/20/2014 at 17:44 (3,680 days old) by jerrod6 (Southeastern Pennsylvania)        

I don't much bother priming the line before I start the DW. If the water is hot that's ok, if it's not the cold prewash doesn't make much difference to outcome quality that I can see.

However I usually put a small amount of powder in the pre wash cup so that greasy water is not spraying all over the place and running through the insides of the DW.

Lately I have been using a cycle without a prewash...nothing but the main wash, 2 rinses and dry about 3.18 gallons of water and everything seems clean. I like this cycle because it only takes about 1 hour 40 minutes. So starting from a cold main wash doesn't matter either. I don't know how bad this is on my electric costs but my bill has been decreasing every month so I feel good.

I've been using non phosphate Finish Quantum tabs and I get excellent results so if you guys in Europe have this available it will probably work well for you too.


Post# 751499 , Reply# 27   4/20/2014 at 18:35 (3,680 days old) by fisherpaykel (BC Canada)        
kenmoreguy89 et all re tsp stpp and phosphates

First off kenmoreguy89 I sure hope it never comes to that with you tied to the wall in a mad house, how would you be able to post to AW?!!! For your next DW you might try a single drawer FisherPaykel with water softener,steel outer cabinet,plastic resin interior, I've used mine, no softener, 9 years so far, no problems but I disconnect the switched power outlet between uses to protect circuit boards from surges. While I knew fertilizers were made from mined phosphate deposits and overfertilized agricultural and residential lawn runoff is mostly responsible for lake and stream eutrophication? pardon my lack of knowledge but is it correct that TSP and STPP are manufactured from these same phosphate deposits? I have soft water and still using my supply of phosphate DW detergent but presuming most EU and Australian DW have water softeners is it true most/some new DW formulas are poorer performing irrespective of water hardness? Well ok, PassatDoc and washer111 have good results IF they first prime the hot water line-is that the solution again irrespective of DW with/without softener? Which phosphate-free powders have you found to be good both in soft and hard water?

Post# 751512 , Reply# 28   4/20/2014 at 19:27 (3,680 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        

Australian dishwashers do not have water softeners. Maybe some of the newer European imports do, but that's not the norm.

Post# 751533 , Reply# 29   4/20/2014 at 21:22 (3,680 days old) by washer111 ()        

Rapunzel is right - we don't have softeners on most machines, since it really isn't necessary in most of the denser-populated areas of the country (excl. Parts of Perth and Adelaide. The former has "varying" hardness, depending on the source of the water. BUT its generally quite soft).

 

As the DishDrawer is of "European Descent" (in that Aussie/Kiwi {New-Zealand}) machines are capable of cold water intake), it doesn't require water-line priming or hot intake, as U.S. Member 'Dadoes' has pointed out previously. 

I prefer to that to save what amounts to about $20 in electricity yearly (Daily use on Delicates cycle {50°C Wash, 60° Rinse). The savings increase either as the machine is used more or when hotter cycles are used. With power rates going up, I presume that will now be a higher value, since I calculated that figure back in 2012, before the world ended.


Post# 751546 , Reply# 30   4/20/2014 at 23:01 (3,680 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        
"before the world ended"

Where there is an end there should also be a new beginning. Wink

Post# 751562 , Reply# 31   4/21/2014 at 00:25 (3,680 days old) by washer111 ()        

This new-beginning must be the removal of those Phosphor-Laden detergents from "The Old World..."

That can wait until I exhaust the current "stash" of detergent Tongue out


Post# 751590 , Reply# 32   4/21/2014 at 05:55 (3,680 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Tied to the wall in a mad house....
LOL.....that's not because of phosphates ban for sure, but is for so many reasons of which this phosphate ban adds to....but really phosphate ban is nothing compared to it all.
I would raise matters belonging to the dirty laundry forum if I say all the things that are driving me mad and that I think I cannot stand stand anymore about Italy and Europe, just saying that I could see that this country was already very bad back then and during ghe time it only had disadvantages in joining the EU and Euro, and everyone can see how this country now has lost it's authority to make the own business at home with the EU fascists telling what we should or shouldn't do at our home and killing the country identity and economy...
But this is not completely fault of Europe anyway, but of italian politicians that are all sold and care about their pockets, instead of country's future....and, eventually of italians that are all about complaining about it but no facts, the truth is that they do not even have skills to understand why everything is so bad...
Returning to the phosphate speech, it's clear how phosphates works better than alternative ingredients such as zeolites or policarboxilates, while I cannot say that it has been a great problem with laundry products I could experience it was instead so with dishwashing products...
I could experience generally that products without them used to give inferior results in cleaning more than else, and reduced shining results and spots on stainless and glass...
Have to be honest though in saying that phosphate products does not always means better, the proof is told by the fact that I have recently tried in a few loads some dishwasher tabs I got at the discount, they had phosphates, but results have been quite disappointing in cleaning.... So do not want to pass the wrong message that whenever there are phosphates you can be sure a product is better, but on a general scale I could experience that products with phosphates performed better and gave results that no phosphate free product ever did...
It's incontrovertible how in the USA it has been a problem for many, while some people didn't notice any differene for others instead it has been a huge problem, that can be related on so many aspects....but if it wasn't so, you wouldn't have had cases like bubble bandit saying "it's not your dishwasher, but your detergent without Stpp" or many people racing for institutional phosphate laden products finally getting again the results they were used to get...
Didn't want to drive the discussion in a political one, even though I realize it is kind of impossible to do not come to talk about governemnt decisions...
While I can see this phosphate ban may be the joy of some Eco maniacs people, I cannot accept how they claim that by doing so they're going to get rid of the phosphate problem in rivers, lakes etc...
When we can see, their presence it is only minimally or anyway greatly inferior compared to ones imputable to farming, fertilizing or other sources...This is not much fair....
It is not even fair, other than smart, keeping blaming them and play the card of enviroinment whenever one wants to take them off detergents in prevision of a future shortage or increase in the price....
Why not say the truth then?

Again, if it wasn't for Louis, this is a thing I couldn't really read anywhere and hear...








This post was last edited 04/21/2014 at 11:10
Post# 751592 , Reply# 33   4/21/2014 at 06:06 (3,680 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
P.s.. I can see how priming the line may help to get cleaner results in a hot fill dishwasher of course...but I don't believe this may always be enough to avoid disappointing results....
I think it really plays a marginal role in it, sure, as for washers for which is surely and absolutely more important this is an operation that of course needs to done in certain circumstances, would surprise me if there were people not realizing it...
But of course there are, and unfortunately nowadays more than they used to be....




This post was last edited 04/21/2014 at 06:27
Post# 751601 , Reply# 34   4/21/2014 at 07:14 (3,680 days old) by Mich (Hells Kitchen - New York)        
I'm not exactly sure...

mich's profile picture

What Joe is smoking? In my experience, those phosphate laden Cascade Action Pacs, leave dishes significantly more shiny, and gleaming than the Phosphate Free Complete Pacs. 

 

The Complete Pacs, leave lots of Water Spots (if rinse aid isn't added) and... I can tell dried on Food doesn't come off as well, as it used to with the Complete Powder & Just the regular Action Pacs. I can say they work (if you do add the expensive, chemical laden rinse aid, but... you really shouldn't have to, tbh)

 

Although, it really doesn't matter. Europe's Problem, is the water there is like 4x harder than it is, in the united states. Here most people don't ever even get near 7-8 GPG, but there, its quite the norm for 20-30 to be considered "average" while, 30-50 grains, can even be observed in some harder water areas. Even with Water Softeners, built in to dishwashers themselves, I still don't see the detergent working out so well. Phosphates are the only ingredient that can grab onto water minerals, and suspend them, so residues dont redeposit, if you take those away, and replace them with carbonate & polymers chemicals, I just see a recipe for disaster, esp in extremely hard water areas. 

 

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 

I want to make the point, of making this really, really clear. Detergents, have always been, and always will be better with Phosphates. Phosphates are a Builder, and there the best at what they do, and always will be. They grab onto water minerals, they trap & suspend dirt & grease, and they work with Enzymes to increase alkalinity. 

 

Consumer Reports, has repeatedly said over & over, that NONE of the phosphate free detergents, have the same power as those that did before. Although, some *do* come close, though, such as the Finish Quantum & Cascade Complete. 

 

One thing I that I think, we'll very much be noticed, is Phosphates get the job done, in much less time. With Phosphate Detergents, I can run our Dishwasher on "Normal" and everything will come off, and be really clean. When I use Phosphate Free, that just doesn't happen, I end up find myself, using a longer cycle such as Pots & Pans, or Smart Wash, because the Enzymes no longer have the ability to do there thing on a shorter wash. 

 

I'm sure, a lot will notice the difference. I sure did...


Post# 751615 , Reply# 35   4/21/2014 at 10:18 (3,680 days old) by PassatDoc (Orange County, California)        
@ fisherpaykel

I have a hot-fill Bosch from 2001, so since it fills from the hot water line, and since the first rinse is not heated by the machine (i.e. incoming hot water line temp is your first rinse temp), it would make sense to get the incoming hot water as hot as possible (roughly 140 F for the average hot water tank heater).

I should clarify----I am still using phosphated Finish. When a rumor spread on this board several years ago about the impending national US removal of DW phosphates, I went to Costco and bought 4-5 canisters of Finish PowerBall tabs. There are 80-100 tabs per canister. Shortly thereafter, I was at friends' home for dinner and they mentioned that they didn't like Finish tabs in their KA DW because the soap dispenser was too shallow to close the door easily over the tablet (I think the older non-Powerball tabs worked ok for them, but the Powerball tab is thicker). When I mentioned I had no problem with Powerballs in my Bosch, they immediately bequeathed me 2 1/2 canisters of additional Powerballs, one canister being so old that it still said "Electrasol" on the label (but with individually wrapped/sealed tabs, still good for use). As a result, I probably am sitting on a five year supply of phosphated DW detergent.

However, I did ask our local appliance store owner about the change, since I am concerned that if the Bosch should ever suffer a catastrophic failure and cannot be repaired (so far, 13 years' service with no repairs or any issues at all), I would have to replace it with a new, lower-water-use model and I was concerned how these machines perform, particularly for people who didn't hoard Finish and who have to use the new detergent. He said the new machines will work with new detergents but that priming the line is essential. I have started priming the line before each use, even though I'm using the original machine, though I always had excellent results without priming for 13 years.

My washer/dryer are in the garage, and share a common wall with the DW and kitchen sink (typically American design with direct entry from garage to kitchen). I don't have a laundry sink, but can use the kitchen faucet to prime the hot water lines supplying the washer and DW. I generally do this before washing clothes, because my washer is a BOL 2006 Frigidaire FL (2140) without ATC. If I don't prime, "warm" can be pretty chilly, since it appears to mix incoming hot and cold lines 50:50 and that is "warm". For "hot" loads, I'll prime if I need it to wash at 140F, if not I don't prime and I end up with a compromise between warm and hot. However, if it is a full/absorbent load, the machine will add water 2-3 times to bring up the water level, and the water from those additions is primed/hot.

Board member Golittlesport taught me a second way to prime: start a "hot" cycle, wait until steam builds up on door window (indicative that the line is primed), hit Drain/Spin to empty the water, abort the cycle, then load clothes/soap and start the intended cycle. For me, it's easier to just walk a few feet to the kitchen and use the faucet to prime, but his method would be very useful in applications where there is no nearby faucet to prime.


Post# 751621 , Reply# 36   4/21/2014 at 10:42 (3,680 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Louis, I think I owe an apology or at least had to let you know, i have run the Bosch now, and could see that what I thought being a warm prewash actually is a cold one, do not really know why I thought it was warm as well,.... but for sure I can tell my previous ones had a warm prewash at 40 c, also the Indesits have a warm prewash from what I know...
It sure helps a bit, but cannot see the lack of the heated prewash as responsible for the crappy results I
get from the Bosch....it is just the same...
I use detergent even the prewash even though differently than the others I have owned, it does not have a conpartment for the prewash....sometimes when I fotget something and it has started already the main wash from awhile, i have to reset and start everything again, this because this crappy electronic control when you stop and resume will do a partial drain before starting from where it left and results in too less water and pump sucking up air...
But even in these occasions I get crappy results, so I can tell that it is not because it lack an heated prewash.... It does not make any difference..
I hate it!
My uncles in Maine got a bosch as well, and they hate theirs as much as I hate mine, they regret their old whirlpool everyday...




This post was last edited 04/21/2014 at 11:15
Post# 751637 , Reply# 37   4/21/2014 at 11:35 (3,680 days old) by lavamat_jon (UK)        

I have used phosphate-free dishwasher detergents, and have to say I have not noticed a detriment in performance.  Our washing detergents haven't had phosphates for years and results are still excellent.

 

Jon


Post# 751670 , Reply# 38   4/21/2014 at 14:55 (3,679 days old) by jerrod6 (Southeastern Pennsylvania)        

One thing about the new DWs sold to North Americans is that along with using less water, they have motors with less power and anemic heaters. On some if you chose the regular cycle which is Energy Star certified it may heat the wash water to no more than 105F or 110f, so this in combination with non phosphate detergents causes problems and this is also why these cycle are taking upwards of 3 hours to complete. Most newer manuals for these machines say to run hot water before you start it, because the machine isn't going to do it's part to heat the water much hotter.

This is ridiculous for consumers because it negates any savings they get from using this type of dishwasher. You pay to heat the water inside the machine, or you pay to heat the water outside the machine.

In these machines the use of phosphate detergents certainly would improve performance.

I don't know if new machines sold in EU are using these type of low temps to wash dishes or not.


Post# 751675 , Reply# 39   4/21/2014 at 15:38 (3,679 days old) by joe_in_philly (Philadelphia, PA, USA)        

joe_in_philly's profile picture
While I haven't been smoking anything, it wouldn't hurt to clarify that I am comparing Cascade with phosphates to Finish Quantum and the latest version of Finish Power Ball, neither of which have phosphates. Both preform better than the Cascade pacs I have with phosphates. I did recently buy Cascade Platinum which doesn't have phosphates, but I haven't tried it yet. Currently trying to use up my stash of the first version of Finish Quantum. One package of the Finish Quantum seems to have gotten moisture in it, as the tabs are a bit swollen and sticky. Luckily, it hasn't impacted performance.

I have purchased but haven't yet tried the newer version of Finish Quantum which has a gel in one part of the package instead of two different powders. My guess is that the newer version would work even better than the original.

All my experience is using a Bosch dishwasher that has a long, 30-35 minute wash, which always is heated to 140F on the regular cycle, 155F on the Power Scrub Plus Cycle. My water heater is set around 120F, and combined with the long distance from my water heater to the dishwasher, the wash portion of the cycle always spends some time at the lower temps that the new enzyme detergents best work to break down soils, before heating to the higher temps where the bleaching ingredients work better. A dishwasher starting a wash with very hot water is not taking full advantage of the newer detergent formulations.


CLICK HERE TO GO TO joe_in_philly's LINK


Post# 751683 , Reply# 40   4/21/2014 at 16:34 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I am just the opposite of you....
I have tried every sorts of products, american finish , powder, powerball without stpp, italian finish powder and powerball with stpp... Cascade both with and w/ out stpp...
The finish without stpp didn't work quite well as the italian finish with phosphates instead did....even though the difference was not as noticeable as it is with cascade with and w/out stpp..

But if I had to choose among italian finish and cascade with stpp, I would get my cascads any day!
Time ago I have acquired a stock of Vintage cascade sheeting action off ebay, and it performed so much better than finish powerball and powder did, both the variations with and w/ out phosphates, of course...
I found cascade to be one of the best powders I have ever tried... I have also tried a box of new one without stpp as I was saying, it was not terrible but incomparable to the older version...it left white marks and some dried on stuff behind.

I am fan of finish phosphated powder though for what concerns ones sold here, I find it to be totally different from the tablets, I also like the old school phosphated regular finish gel lemon that we used to use for a period when I was little, now is simply too expensive....finish is one of the best phosphated powders that are sold here, I also like the one of the discount I get here for 1,99 made by McBride (it has phosphates), it is as good as the finish but for less than half the cost finish have...
I usually prefer using powders and sometimes gels rather than the tablets.....but I do not miss to try even tablets at times if they're on offer...





This post was last edited 04/21/2014 at 17:03
Post# 751686 , Reply# 41   4/21/2014 at 16:55 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
One of the most terrible products I have ever tried, were Lidl's w5 new tablets, that really could not even wash out dried mustard..... i ended up crumbling them and using to scrub the sink..
I used to be satisfied with the old white and yellow ones, I think they were called adritt, , but from a few years now they have changed them and canged the name to W5, infact the old ones were made in Luxembourg and had phosphates, the ones they sell now have no phosphates and comes from Germany, when first I bought them I got two packages, I returned my unopened one and claimed my money back quite pissed off...
They were the first experiences with non phosphated products....


Post# 751691 , Reply# 42   4/21/2014 at 17:18 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
I think again some of our American friends dont understand why European Technology is hitting America and why it is so beneficial.

Dishwashers here have been proven to use as little as 12 litres on a dirty full load and get the absolute best results known.

They can do this by utilising low wattage pumps, cycling between the wash arms so the water can cope being spread about. This adds extra time.

It is not the water usage per se but the ENERGY used to heat it up.

Energy is a valuable commodity no matter how rich you are or what you pay. Valuable considering the potential for short supply MANY MANY MANY generations down the line.

Folk who argue its up to them what water they heat and what they are willing to pay are just being short sighted to the future generations whom they wont even meet. They only care about themselves and their time here right now.

OK OK this extra wash time on an already shoddily built DW is detrimental BUT its our job right now to demand better goods that DO use resources more frugally and do so more reliably so they dont end up in land fill.

Not to whinge and moan about DW's using 12 litres instead of 120.

The manufacturers have this RIGHT.

Now as for the internal heating misunderstanding, Appliance manufacturers have started adding internal heaters so you can do away with wasteful hot water tanks not only saving you money as a bonus but to do away with their energy wasting.

That tank you have heats up, sits a while before you demand watern - perhaps over night or in the day while your at work, cools a bit, heats a bit , cools some more, heats again.
Lagging helps but your still cycling the heat on and off all the time wasting resources.

So before your water hits the DW its been heated and cooled potentially a few times. Very wasteful.

Now it cools in the pipework running to your DW, to be heated yet again.

Cold water fill eliminates this and along with your 110v heaters it needs extra time to also get to temp FIRST TIME rather than 3rd 4th or 5th perhaps.
This also benefits your Enzymes in the detergent helping them clean your dishes better.

I imagine traditional HW water tanks will go by the wayside now Combi/Instant demand boilers are getting better and better, more reliable. Quite rightly so,

We love ours and we have saved a fortune on gas bills - enough to pay for the boiler after 3 winters.

Its designed to last upward of ten years so after 6 it will have paid for its next replacement over our old water tank system.

We have worked hard enough for our money - giving it to XXXXpower is the last thing I want to do even if it is my choice to use litres and gallons more water.

Why when I dont have to?


Post# 751696 , Reply# 43   4/21/2014 at 17:30 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
p.s Phosphated and non phosphated user here.

No real preference as ive found no difference in performance over both types depending on brand.

Had phosphated dets that cant clean for toffee and has unphosphated that can.

Very much down to brand specifics!

Had 'green' label non phosphated that can clean away starch, grease, and protein but has left tannin stains and used 'phosphated' big brands and had them miss starch, grease, and proteins but rid tannins.

Its also been many ways round over the years.

Been thru them all I can tell you! Its so very variable out there,



Post# 751708 , Reply# 44   4/21/2014 at 18:07 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I disagree with most of what you said.....
Even american machines use to heat their water, they just are smart enough to fill it already hot and start from an hotter point, an electric boiler for hot water would run wheter you use your dishwasher or not....so do not see any difference...it's not like you run a water heater just for a dishwasher...
Moreover, gas is way cheaper than electricity so filling water already hot whenever you have a gas boiler or even better a insta gas heater is more than advisable and cheaper...
In any case it allows extra time saving from machine having to heat it's water from cold....which is anyway appreciated...and that is a thing even sone european dishwasher now finally gives the possibility to do, know of some people who actually did that even before even if not advisable...
Water usage, every machine use the level of water that needs to get the job done, we could see like modern ones uses almost the half less they used to, and IMO and from what I could see and experience apparently with no good results, I have seen and used some american machines and regarding water usage are not much different than europeans, but for sure I can tell you here that they were no paragonable to any european model I have seen as they all provided clean dishes, a thing that I cannot see from long now coming out my european dishwashers.
All I could see in Europe from some years are machines that generally takes forever to wash a load, which motor pumps are weak and which water towers are paragonable to ones of a toy.....And that gives crappy results...
For the rest they are no much different from american ones... Say the least!
What's the matter with European technology? It's not that I do not understand it, I think I understand it very well, and for that I would like to stay away from it!
Dishwashers that use 12 liters and gives the best results known, from who???.... Where?????? please, give me one then! Because it's like 10 years that I am keeping changing machines, but every one is worse of the previous!
I pray every day to find one that does it's job, either it's me unlucky with machines, or do not know what to think, all I know is that with the machines I have used in the USA I never had a problem in matter of cleaning...




This post was last edited 04/21/2014 at 19:06
Post# 751731 , Reply# 45   4/21/2014 at 19:53 (3,679 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        

My dishdrawers are connected to hot as well. I've got hot water on tap. Why should my dishwasher heat it from cold and use more power? Also the line run from the heater is short, so the hot water is almost instantaneous when I open the tap or turn on the dw. If one has to bleed the line the water doesn't have to go down the drain, it can go in a bucket and be used for the garden or whatever.

As for non-phosphate formulations, I have tried some of the other brands. Finish powder is my preference. I can't see anything on the current container that states that it contains phosphates now. My assumption is that it doesn't, since phosphates are now banned. With the other non-phosphate formulations that have those blue beads, there is always a sticky, blue residue that collects underneath the washarms and filter plate in places; not nice. Finish powder still does it for my flatware and cooking utensils.

As for banning phosphates from detergents, I think it's overkill. The phosphate content in cleaing products was already quite low, less than 5%. Since most people here live downstream 99% of river and lake pollution comes from agriculture and droughts, not detergents.

Some noisy action group forced our government to act on phosphates. They clearly thought that their emotional investment was more important than the facts on phosphate content in Australian detergents and their actual environmental impact. Some people here think that we are or should be part of Europe and ought to copy everything they do there regardless of whether it is pertinent to our conditions.


Post# 751789 , Reply# 46   4/21/2014 at 23:52 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

What some have to remember is that some of us have solar-heated water that is far cheaper to use than electricity in our Dishwashers...
So that includes me and my calculations above.

By the way Rapunzel, I'll get a picture of my Finish tabs "ingredient list" for you when I get back home.
I wonder if my supermarket is just receiving older stock?


Post# 751807 , Reply# 47   4/22/2014 at 02:09 (3,679 days old) by mrboilwash (Munich,Germany)        

mrboilwash's profile picture
While not exactly looking forward to the phosphate ban, I think it`s a step into the right direction. Eutrophication of the Baltic Sea still seems to be a major problem and food is already a "luxury" for too many in this world !

Maybe there will be a revival of phospates in cleaning products once phospates are recycled cheap and effectively from wastewater everywhere in Europe ?

I`ll use and enjoy them as long as availible but I think I won`t get myself a huge stockpile because I would be afraid that the somewhat limited shelf life of bleaches and enzymes might negate the benefits of the phosphates.


Post# 751820 , Reply# 48   4/22/2014 at 03:02 (3,679 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        
Okay washer111

Mine is Finish Advanced, 2xpowder concetrate, made in Korea. There is no ingredient list, only a statement about environmental info that says no chlorine bleach and that it contains biodegradable surfactants - that's all. Theoretically it could contain phosphates, but there is nothing to indicate that. There is no NP label on the bottle either.

Post# 751829 , Reply# 49   4/22/2014 at 04:29 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Freddie the steer is to get away from using Tank water heaters or at least smaller ones for just supplying hot water to taps and faucets. Tanks of hot water are not needed half as much as anyone thinks.

This is where tankless water heaters come in so wonderfully, so little waste compared to a tank!

Appliances that heat their own water save even Tankless heaters heating water and it cooling thru the pipes on the journey to the machine.

Gas prices may be cheaper now but here they are getting close and closer and have done for sometime.

I cant vouch for the dishwasher thing, I have never experienced what you say even on cheaper low end machines. Honestly I can only see it being down to user error. Cant be franker than that.

If you have the DW connected to hot water and are purging it to get hot water you are totally negating the use of Enzymatic detergents which need to start in cold water and work up to hot.

And while its very shortsighted to believe the Government only thinks about Phosphates and your washing habits im pretty sure here its just the tip of the iceberg in what they do actually do.

Its just because you are passionate about it that it makes you feel this way but you really dont have to. Just go with the flow and be surprised.



Post# 751832 , Reply# 50   4/22/2014 at 05:34 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I don't think I am shortsightened, I just say that for what concerns me I could see that there is a general race in going green, it's a fashion of nowadays, surely dictated by the fact that governments and international agreements decided to do something regarding pollution, co2 all that stuff...based on eco theories and policies that I do not really want to comment now...
So would not be strange they do a phosphate ban only for this reason, they do alot of silly decisions lately based on green policies...espcially in Europe which I consider the masters in silly decisions.. Even though USA is really keeping up thanks to the actual president in charge.
You see it in everything....for some cases they brought good things, for others just not, or anyway compromised them...
Regarding phosphates, again, I tell you that I go based on what I read, and can well see all they mention is about envioinment, if there is an iceberg down there about something else, they better tell clearly or shut up and avoid keeping blaming detergents in a very phatetical way...
I could experience phosphated detergents being better...I wish I could be okay even with dishwashing products w/out stpp as much as I am with laundry products, unfortunately to today, that's not the case...

Regarding hot water heaters, I really would not mind have a large one, bigger is better, and tell you again that if I could I'd be the first connecting my dishwasher to hot as IMO it saves time, and in certain circumstances even money!
Loss of heat in pipes is really not a problem for how I ses things,.....and sure plays a very little role in this...
Regarding enzymatic detergents, I tell you, I have used cold connected dishwashers all of my life, but as for everything, I don't care what is supposed to work best and when...but what I care about most of all of course are facts...results!
And a fact that I could experience in my life is that using a dishwasher that filled water already hot, ie an american model gave results I cannot really see an european dishwasher ever gave me... And faster!
As for everything, passion has really nothing to do with such matters, I am not even that passionate about dishwashers, but my thoughts and opinions are driven from what I could see and I always seek for the best, and preferentially I avoid compromise...I want the best I can afford!
Would be so beautiful, but I think that from theory and practice there is a huge sea in the middle....at least for me.
Again, I care about results i can see and touch, not theories, that's the only thing I care about...
Not saying and will never say I am absolutely right, as for everyone I do not have instruments to determine whatever is right....
But for sure can speak from what I have experience on my skin, others may have experienced differently, but nothing will keep me from saying my findings and related opinions.
I tried to follow as you say, and it is only been bad.... That's why I came to realize that speaking of appliances, vintage or "old school" means better, and eco means bad, and that's shy now I am looking for a vintage dishwasher, confident of the fact that it will work as I expect a dishwasher does, it will use more water? more electricity? I don"t care, I just want to finally open the machine and be sure that the stuff I am about putting away is really clean, without inspecting and eventually rewash part of the load..... A thing that from awhile I cannot do anymore...
If others gave the results, and other didn't I cannot really see how it may be my fault.....
Perhaps my fault is the logical will of not have to lay down for compromises, pretreat, presoak,prerinse etc...
Then what I have a dishwasher for?







This post was last edited 04/22/2014 at 06:23
Post# 751835 , Reply# 51   4/22/2014 at 05:46 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

"If you have the DW connected to hot water and are purging it to get hot water you are totally negating the use of Enzymatic detergents which need to start in cold water and work up to hot."

 

This is actually false. At least in my house, the water is tempered to 50°C per government regulations - whilst this only applies to bathrooms, it isn't feasible in our house to alter the setup without significant inconvenience and stuffing around.

 

Therefore, the dishwasher gets that temperature intake. Since there is about a 30cm run of pipe from the main line (kitchen tap) to dishwasher tap, the detergent gets an initial flush with cold water, before it heats up to the hotter temperature.

If I enable the diagnostic temperature-sensing display, it actually only gives me about 5-10° on the original tub-temperature, depending on conditions, due to the thermal mass of the machine + dishes. So, if the machine is at 24° when starting, I typically only see about 30° by the end of the fill - giving about a 10-15 minute heating period on the machine. 

 

Many machines, including the Dishlex from our old home (2007 model) and the Bosch machine (1980's) I used in Norway heat the water to the desired temperature BEFORE releasing the detergent - so on those machines, purging the tap only saves time, energy and makes little difference to washing performance (if/when they are connected to hot). 

The DishDrawer has a flow-thru detergent dispenser, so "hitting" the detergent with really hot water (probably more than 60°) would hurt the enzymes - then again, modern enzymes are designed for higher temperature washing anyway, so it doesn't matter all that much. 

 

The other "issue" you could describe is enzyme activity at colder temperatures. We all know that fat doesn't dissolve into the water readily at lower temperatures, and the activity of enzymes does tend to decrease at cold temperatures. So starting at cold inlet and heating into their most active zone (Around body temperature, to somewhere around 55-60°) isn't going to yield better results, except for soaking heavier soils. 

 

FYI, I never have trouble with cleaning, even when purging the taps. I'd rather save my $20 or so per-annum than use it heating water and potentially not even reaching the target temperatures (I've "caught" the machine doing this on heavy - where it has to heat from cold - 65° in short time, always in the final rinse. It will "cut" the heating at about 55° on cold inlet, but will always reach the temperature on Hot inlet). 


Post# 751838 , Reply# 52   4/22/2014 at 06:27 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Your government really tells you how your hot water should be hot????
Are you kidding????


Post# 751839 , Reply# 53   4/22/2014 at 06:32 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Freddie cut the anti government stuff and look into what it means before you post.

Its actually a great idea.

Its tempered water to stop mentally frail people and children SCALDING themselves while bathing or washing their hands.

Dosnt mean they get legionaires disiese as its tempered near the source I believe.

In the 1970's a baby died because of falling into a bath of scalding hot water - perhaps if all hot bathroom taps were tempered worldwide things like this wouldnt happen.

And before you give the 'its the parents fault' crap just remember what you got upto as a child and how easy it was for you to hide from your parents.



Post# 751840 , Reply# 54   4/22/2014 at 06:39 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
worth a watch

although the Jimmy Savile scandal is another topic and NOT for this website.



CLICK HERE TO GO TO aquarius1984's LINK


Post# 751843 , Reply# 55   4/22/2014 at 06:54 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

Just so everyone knows I'm not bluffing :)

Finish Quantum Lemon 20+10 bought about 2 weeks ago to replace Fairy Platinum (like Cascade Complete Pacs) with equal amounts of Phosphate. At least these don't have gel that will dissolve and wreck the other pacs!


Post# 751844 , Reply# 56   4/22/2014 at 06:57 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

No, the government doesn't determine the temperature of our water - only how hot it comes out at Bathroom taps (Not laundry/kitchen ones). Although in MY experience, you can still be scalded at 50° - maybe just my "delicate" hands :P

 

What I scoff at is how our water heaters cannot be set below 60° due to "Legionella risk," if that was so, why do people in the U.S. get to turn theirs down to 48°? 

The bug is only a risk at temperatures below about 45°!

And of course, to top it off, the manufacturer of our Solar-Water Heater "recommend" people leave the electric booster ON (wasting power) to ensure the Government Mandate is met, and the water doesn't get "too cold."

(I'll scan that too, if ANYONE is wondering). 


Post# 751846 , Reply# 57   4/22/2014 at 07:01 (3,679 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        
"how our water heaters cannot be set below 60°"

That must be new. Mine has holiday mode where it only keeps the pilot light on and about 5 or six different temp settings.

Post# 751851 , Reply# 58   4/22/2014 at 07:06 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

I was surprised too...

 

I found it out researching Electric vs. Heat-Pump. Vs. Solar... Seems Electric doesn't go colder than 60°, Heat-Pump not warmer than 55°, generally and Solar, well, that depends on the Sun and whether you leave the booster on or not. Since I've got some time, I'll fish that manual out tomorrow and see what AU/NZ Standard that is meant to be. I did post a *rant mode* thread last year when the system was installed... So you could search that too!

 

Of course, I guess the "official" settings on a heater might be counted, not "Holiday" modes that save energy. Who knows?


Post# 751852 , Reply# 59   4/22/2014 at 07:20 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
A great idea FOR YOU! I exactlly know what it means and really do not need you to explain it for me, Believe it or not I got a brain! thank you!
From awhile have been invented mixing valves, this does not prevent you to make a different line before it supplying washer and dishwasher, and the other line supplying taps...
Also I heard of taps who have one already incorporated...
Since one may have childrens or not, this does make the government able to tell me how water must be hot in my house...NEVER! And it is just absurd!
And just for you to know, I grew up in an house where water from the taps gets out at 60 degress, I never and say never got a scald, even when I was a child, just because I was smart enough to set tap to the proper temperature...
And yes, if that is happened in the 70s that was parents fault...not because they may have missed the survelliance of the child, but because they didn't take due precautions, ie lower themselves the water heater if they got a dumb child....
It's not that because a couple parents have been, let's say negligent they should make mandatory for all...


Post# 751853 , Reply# 60   4/22/2014 at 07:24 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Freddie your attitude stinks,

You reference to having a dumb child is foul mouthed.

YOu make no reference to older people with mental issues, perhaps its their fault if they scauld themselves too while living independantly?

You honestly dont know how lucky you are .really.


Post# 751854 , Reply# 61   4/22/2014 at 07:26 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Its is mandatory for BATHROOMS where you only wash your body. Bathrooms where children can access and use themselves - with their own dignity!

Not Kitchens where you need hot water to dissolve grease and clean.

Setting the water heater lower means the kitchen wont be hot enough!



Post# 751857 , Reply# 62   4/22/2014 at 07:32 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Mixer taps still require a user to put their hands under to see how hot it is.

Scauld waiting to happen.

The water is thermostatically tempered before it gets to the tap.

Reuces the risk of a scauld to a child/infirm/elderly.

Quite simple really.



Post# 751858 , Reply# 63   4/22/2014 at 07:43 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
I have understand it is for bathrooms now that it has been pointed out! THANK YOU FOR NOTHING!
Sounded like you had to keep water supply always that down everyhwere and in any circumstances...
I made a question.... That if so would have been kind of crazy, infact!
Then you came in....you are the one that should cut if the only thing you care about is discredit me, just because we have different opinions.
The matter of elderlies and invalids apllies to the one of the child...it is anyway not fair that a government would tell me assuming that... THIS IS WHAT I WAS SAYING! BUT THERE WAS A SIMPLE EXPLANATION!
Since first I have started using the bathroom alone, so washing my hand etc...I was teached by my parents to set taps in order to not get water too hot, and so I kept doing...if a child do otherwise is dumb, if it really so little to do not understand it, the parents should look after, and here comes their fault.
In any ways is silly a government mandates it for everyone and everywhere in the house, but since that is not the case, can we just go ahead???? Or you wanna drive the conversation further? The question was not even to you, so just mind your business ok?




This post was last edited 04/22/2014 at 08:07
Post# 751860 , Reply# 64   4/22/2014 at 07:47 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
I saw no name to the question on a public forum so i assumed anyone could answer and explain why seeing as you originally portrayed you didnt know why water in a bathroom is tempered.

If you did know the answer I have no idea why you asked the question.



Post# 751861 , Reply# 65   4/22/2014 at 07:48 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
p.s for mixer I meant safety valves that are usually placed next to a water heater pipe outtake that mix water automatically in order to do not provide water too hot, they also makes taps like these now...
Not for sure a mixer tap...
You think you are that smart, or either others to be stupid.... Don't you?



Post# 751862 , Reply# 66   4/22/2014 at 07:51 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Feddie dont back track.

Those mixer taps are exactly what we were talking about with the mandates.

You know that and the way your conversation has gone demonstrates that exactly,

I dont need to be smart, it dosnt suit anyone.

Not even you.



Post# 751863 , Reply# 67   4/22/2014 at 07:55 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
It is not much who replies to a question, but HOW IT REPLIES, you assumed it was a critic for the government, and said to "cut" cut what? It it was just a question. As you can see, washer 111, the one who the question was direct to, immediately replied pointing that it is only for bathrooms, which makes a little more sense than the whole house as I previously thought, which was absurd....and it was the exact reply I was looking for, without nonsense explanations or assumptions of any kind added....but you looked so much for them purposedly, don't you?


Post# 751864 , Reply# 68   4/22/2014 at 07:56 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
No dear, I meant exactly that type of valves! Otherwise I'd have said mixer taps, and not valves!
Also, if it was as you think the speech I made about making a different line to washer and before the valve would not have had sense!
Then believe what you want.....


Post# 751866 , Reply# 69   4/22/2014 at 08:03 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Time to get your facts straight.

I responded directly after you asked about the government.

GO back and look!

Rapunzel has made no comments about water temp. Just his tank settings.

I explained it to you as to why its not the government dictating. Its mandated bathroom water temps for good reason.

I explained long before anyone else psted.

YOur attitude about governments is getting boring. Sure there's bad things but they implement alot of great things to help people.

Wake up and smell the coffee with more of an open mind.

Having just spent 4 years worrying about a Grandparent with Alzheimers and dementure who would of given up on his life had he been put into a home to lose his independance - keeping him in his OWN home safely with hot water that wont scauld him in the bathroom yet be hot enough to clean dishes in the kitchen would of been a great bonus.

Same with his gas appliances.

I cant believe im having to spell it out that children with learning difficulties CAN be capable of going to the toilet, cleaning their own bottoms and washing their own hands with DIGNITY and PRIVACY yet dont understand the dangers of hot water is so hard for you to grasp.

Grow up Freddie and stop whinging!


Post# 751869 , Reply# 70   4/22/2014 at 08:14 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
No, actually not.
Washer 111 said this
"least in my house, the water is tempered to 50°C per government regulations", I assumed all the house in asutralia needs to have always water no more than 50 degrees in any circumstances, may it be kitchen or laundry...which was kind of absurd!
So here I made my question...
You came with your first reply with stupid assumptions you could have easily kept for yourself because they were of no help...a simple reply, only for bathrooms would have been enough! And that's what washer 111 said!
That's it, you are the one who raised problems PURPOSEDLY , you are the one who should grow up and stop acting pathetically!


Post# 751870 , Reply# 71   4/22/2014 at 08:18 (3,679 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
You dont like me explaining why?

You dont like me explaining why on a PUBLIC forum so that any other readers who might not know or understand why bathrooms only have tempered water?

How did I know you would know the reasons why?

Its called a conversation, its called sharing knwoledge.

My post wasnt just for you it was for EVERYBODY.

Anyway im thru wasting my time on you. Goodbye.



Post# 751871 , Reply# 72   4/22/2014 at 08:26 (3,679 days old) by washer111 ()        

Yes Freddie, BUT, I mentioned further in that sentence it only applies to the Bathroom areas (Ensuites, Bathrooms, Half-Bathrooms, WHATEVER you wish to call it)...

PERHAPS further when children are involved. 

 

I'll not mince words here, if it were AT ALL feasible to temper only the supply to the bathroom, we probably would've. But the tight space where the plumbing splits between the Kitchen/Laundry and Bathrooms is too tight, and the risk of flooding, damage if something bad happens too great. 

Keep it on the roof, temper the whole house. Yes, I object, but I live with it quite happily. We don't have any TL or FL machines that require very hot inlet anyhow, so no harm hey? 

BESIDES - Modern machines throw error codes if you give them water thats too hot for their liking... 

 

As for Kids or the Elderly, lapses in attention happen. Those who might not be in full possession of their faculties might not react the way other people might when presented with this situation, and instead choose to freeze or do something else out of the ordinary, hurting themselves even more. 

Parents/Carers might loose concentration for that moment, and the damage is done. No, you can't fix stupid, but even good parents will slip up on occasion.

In most instances, better to be safe than sorry.  

 

Here's my "rant" from last year too - Note for member Rapunzel, you can see the Government literature attached by Ronhic at the end of the thread. www.automaticwasher.org/cgi-bin/T...

 

That post should give you all the background on my "opinions" on this... Lest I post it again!

I too will bow down now - I think this might be getting towards a personal level, and I'd hate to see that happen. 


Post# 751873 , Reply# 73   4/22/2014 at 08:30 (3,679 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
No I like you explaining why, I just didn't like all the assumptions you made, you telling me to "cut" and keeping making problems purposedly in order to make my appear as an idiot....
So please, avoid "the posts are for everyone " blah blah blah...
They were meant for everyone in order to make me appear a fool, purposedly not getting the point of what I was saying, driving the conversation where you wanted to drive it!
When it was a simple question washer 111 replied straight to the point, but you wanted it to happen!
You did that purposedly hoping to make all the troubles you raised, as attempt to make me appear bad!
That's it! Attempt failed!


Post# 751883 , Reply# 74   4/22/2014 at 08:57 (3,679 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        

My house is older and I've got gas hot water. I've had a new burner installed in my tank two years ago. If I turn the dial to the highest setting it actually goes above 60 degrees, which is not necessary and can be potentially dangerous. On the medium setting it goes to 60 degrees and since I don't have individual temp controllers in my bathrooms I was concerned that the little ones might get hurt. A few years back I accidentally put the hot water on my little nephew once. Luckily he didn't get hurt, but that incident scared the tihs out of me. My hot water is set on 50 and that works fine. When it gets cold I might turn it up a bit, but during summer it doesn't need to be hotter.

Post# 751893 , Reply# 75   4/22/2014 at 10:24 (3,679 days old) by Mich (Hells Kitchen - New York)        
I don't have anything to say...

mich's profile picture

About Water. But.. I'll say this about Detergent. 

 

I like my Phosphate Laden Detergents, and will continue to use them. I will admit though, I know that Finish Quantum would blow mine out of the water, no question about it. However, I will say though, Finish Quantum, is close to .50 - .75 cents a load where I live, and that's just not in my price range. I can use my Phosphate Laden CC Powder, for about a nickle a load. 

 

There's no question about it though. Finish Quantum, can & will, blow CC out of the water. However, if you compare old Cascade Powder to New Cascade Powder, I will say the difference is far more than noticeable. Same goes for the Gel Pacs, and Gels themselves. None of them are ever going to perform as well, as they once did without the Phosphates. 

 

I don't do bob loads. I don't. I'd imagine, our dishwasher is considered 75% full on average, when I run a load. And to be quite honest, I don't wanna spare the cost of Quantum. Our dishes aren't that dirty or soiled, and there's no way for me to justify the cost & expense of it, when the old stuff works just fine.

 

I'll probably eventually switch to Phosphate Free Detergents, although, I'll continue using (the phosphate laden) them, as long as I can still purchase them, on an economical level. 


Post# 751898 , Reply# 76   4/22/2014 at 10:52 (3,679 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Quite a lot of posts, but a lot of them are off topic. We were talking about phosphates. I will add a few facts though.

I have never seen or used a European dishwasher that dispensed the detergent after the water being heated. Certainly not a Bosch. Don't know about the Dishlex though, I'm not familiar with them. I would be interested in the model # of the Bosch, want to ask my repairman about it.


A water heater needs to be set to 60 degrees Celcius/140 degrees Fahrenheit to avoid the hot water system build up legionella. However, how bigger the percentage of chlorine bleach in drinking water, the lower you can set the water heater. The Netherlands has very little chlorine bleach in it's drinking water, in the USA the percentage is higher. That's why it is less risky to set the water heater to a lower temperature in the USA than in the Netherlands.


Enzymes. It is true that enzymes work only at lower temperatures. Actually enzymes are living organisms that have their maximum effect around 37 degrees Celcius. On higher temperatures they loose their cleaning effect and around 60 degrees they are totally gone. I added a scheme for the effect of enzymes and temperatures. If we are going to loose phosphates in dishwasher detergents (some US states and Canada have banned them way before Europe) it's best to use an enzyme based detergent. Then it is better to start with cold water than use hot water from the tap. If you want to use tapwater, it is better to search for a chlorine bleach based detergent like the older type American dishwasher detergents.







Post# 751900 , Reply# 77   4/22/2014 at 10:56 (3,679 days old) by joe_in_philly (Philadelphia, PA, USA)        

joe_in_philly's profile picture
Here is some interesting information about temperatures related to Legionella.


CLICK HERE TO GO TO joe_in_philly's LINK


Post# 751948 , Reply# 78   4/22/2014 at 15:19 (3,678 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Do not want to contraccept anyone, am not a chemistry, even though I know quite enough about alimentar chemistry it is not the same of detergents...so take it as it comes,,,
I wonder if really it does not depend on the type of enzyme, while surely as it happens while baking our doughnut or bread will not rise anymore after it reached a temerature ( yeast simpky dies) I assume enzymes being living organisms ie fungus, just like yeast will die the same way, but perhaps certain types of enzymes just can stand an higher temp than others?
That's a question...
I could read several times online that enzymes in detergent are supposed to function optimally in a range from 20 to 60 degrees celsius (140 f)....
So we have Louis chart saying a thing, and other sources saying another, well, not like if it is totally different though, the drop of enzyme activity in Louis' graphic occurs over 60 more like 65 degrees, .all I can do is wondering that maybe does not apply to all the enzymes the fact of 60 degrees, enzyme is kaput...maybe some are more resistant?
Also...
I never had a problem getting rid of enzymatic stains in my GE washer, It fills water about 65 and even 70 degrees in low demand hours and after i prime the pipes for 20 seconds, and keeps it at temp for at least 10 minutes, even more if i prime the tub also.........but always had good results from enzimatic stains so I suppose they can stand the temp...
Who knows?

www.scribd.com/mobile/doc/1152393... ( page 3).

In any ways...as we are speaking of dishwashers...
I think that a dishwasher is really not like a washer, and that in that specific case you have water laying flat in a large tub thus losing part of it's heat, supposing an upcoming temp of 60 degrees I think enzymes in detergents are not much affected, not because of the enzyme type that is another matter that deserves more investigation, but bevause hardly they will be hit and dissolved in water that hot to denaturate them, so you have them active actually for a portion of the wash till heater kicks on and temperature rise...





Post# 751949 , Reply# 79   4/22/2014 at 15:43 (3,678 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
P.s
On the 4th page of my link you also have mentioned that most detergents have to stand temperatures over 20 to 50 and even above...
So maybe someway there is a method to increase their resistance, and or anyway some types are more delicate or resistant than others?




This post was last edited 04/22/2014 at 15:58
Post# 751963 , Reply# 80   4/22/2014 at 16:53 (3,678 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Actually most detergents contain several enzymes for best cleaning results. There is not much difference in what temperature one enzyme can take over another.

It's true that enzymes work between 20 and 60 degrees, but that is only part of the story. The schedule is not contradicting that, it's actually confirming that, but gives more details at what temperature they work best. Remember washing machines having a temperature stop in the main wash at 40 degrees? They stopped heating at that temperature, washed for a while at 40 degrees and then continued heating. It was to optimize the use of enzymes. Actually it is for the same reason heating elements in washing machines and dishwashers became smaller, because with less water usage, the heating phase went too fast. With smaller heating elements they took longer to heat to the set temperature and in that way taking better advantage of the enzyme phase.

BTW,in the link you posted you can see how enzymes play a big part in low temperature washing.

One more thing: The water lying in a dishwasher (actually recirculating) is heated for quite a while to remain the reached temperature for a while (check your electricity meter when the dishwasher is on), so I am afraid enzymes are killed in the cycle when the temperature is achieved or with hot fill dishwashers kept at a high temperature. Ofcourse there is always the option to use a lower temperature in the dishwasher, most detergents claim to perform just as good in a dishwasher at lower temperatures than at 65 degrees or even higher.


Post# 751966 , Reply# 81   4/22/2014 at 17:06 (3,678 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Probably I was not clear, I meant in the initial part of the wash in an hot fill machines, but of course both in cold fill or hot fill enzymes are killed once a certain temperature has been reached, so after the machine heats to X temperature.
What I said, was related to the fact some were discussing the possibility of enzymes being affected immediately in an hot fill machine because of the hot water fill, which I think being a thing quite impossible to happen...


Post# 751973 , Reply# 82   4/22/2014 at 17:36 (3,678 days old) by washer111 ()        

Thanks for 'waking me up' to the music, Louis. I was wrong about the Bosch - it spat out the detergent, started the heated and screeched to life each cycle :)

 

It was only our Dishlex that would heat, then you'd hear "CLUNK!" and the water start to circulate. One the very hot cycles, I wonder if this explains the poor cleaning some people experienced. 

 

For the record of everyone else on the board, it seems the old RB/MSDS page was taken down. So I had to do some research and dig up the MSDS for Finish detergent again. It seems that Australian Finish Powder (Made in Korea) contains Pentasodium Triphosphate, which, at least according to Wikipedia is that STPP ingredient we all know and love: http://www.rbanzinfo.com.au/dyn/IngredientsList?productID=1057 

 

In regards to that Enzyme "stuff," I can see why 50º is such a good temperature to wash at, since it has much better ability to bleach items, and suspend grease, but almost equivalent enzymatic rates. 

I guess a lot of the cleaning power in the heavy cycle comes from the 20minute (approx.) heating period, where the water is heated to 70º - and after that 60º point, we're onto Steaming/Bleaching action... Interesting stuff!


Post# 752010 , Reply# 83   4/22/2014 at 20:20 (3,678 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
You're welcome washer111.

Freddy,

That depends of the temperature of the incoming water, the hotter the water, the faster the enzymes are killed. Believe it or not!


Post# 752043 , Reply# 84   4/22/2014 at 22:47 (3,678 days old) by washer111 ()        

Not killed, just denatured. So they're there but useless

Post# 752069 , Reply# 85   4/23/2014 at 03:16 (3,678 days old) by mrboilwash (Munich,Germany)        

mrboilwash's profile picture
"Actually enzymes are living organisms that have their maximum effect around 37 degrees Celcius"

Louis, are you sure about this ?

To the day I always assumed that enzymes for detergents are proteins either made by living microoganisms, similar as artificial vitamins are made, or obtained from dead animals.

I always thought the enzymes themselves are not alive but as proteins may be denatured by too much heat.



Post# 752070 , Reply# 86   4/23/2014 at 03:32 (3,678 days old) by washer111 ()        

From what I understood, Enzymes are not living organisms, as they break down proteins. 

 

Instead, they are more like a chemical. They have an active site that only particular proteins will fit into (Lock/Key model). The enzyme can break down enzymes basically forever, provided the conditions are right (temperature, acidity etc). 


Post# 752071 , Reply# 87   4/23/2014 at 03:34 (3,678 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Yes, I think he meant "killed" as synonim for denaturation, which is a more technical term...
I have also used killed as synonym for denaturated, Infact I have used both the terms alluding for the same thing...."killing" was just to give the idea...even though it may sound incorrect for some more "learned" and precise hears...
I have also erroneously mentioned them being living organisms, even though they just act similarly,and are obtained from living organisms, and I Apologize for this Incorrect BS, they cannot actually be catalogued like "living" organisms even because they are no capable of multiplicate..




This post was last edited 04/23/2014 at 04:20
Post# 752073 , Reply# 88   4/23/2014 at 03:40 (3,678 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Yes, sorry, I was wrong. They are biological molecules, not really living creatures, but the effects is as I described. Denatured is indeed a better word.

Post# 752085 , Reply# 89   4/23/2014 at 06:11 (3,678 days old) by mrboilwash (Munich,Germany)        

mrboilwash's profile picture
Thanks guys for clearing this up.
I think there is nothing wrong with the term "killed off", you just made me insecure about the the "living organism" thing.


Post# 752101 , Reply# 90   4/23/2014 at 08:42 (3,678 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
You're welcome, biology classes were 40 years ago! lol



Post# 752151 , Reply# 91   4/23/2014 at 16:29 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Went to the store this evening, I took a ride in detergents isle, and started looking for which ones have phosphates or not still....
I was surprised to see that in the new Quantum packages they changed the list, while phosphates still appears in the regular powerballs, always the same 15-30% and regular powders...
Quantum didn't have them listed, Btw, they were new packages in a plastic bag, wrapped up to make a twin package with a paper base holding them, not sure if I have seen mentioned a minimum phosphorous content,, all I could read were usual ingredients and phosphonates....but no phosphates...


Post# 752210 , Reply# 92   4/23/2014 at 19:45 (3,677 days old) by logixx (Germany)        
Couple of thoughts

logixx's profile picture
I have my Bosch dishwasher connected to cold water. I had it on hot water (60C) for some weeks but didn't see any benefit. Sure, I probably saved a litte energy but I had to purge quite a bit of cold water from the line first. Cycles didn't get any faster, either - just a few minutes, as the drying phase had to be extended because my Bosch doesn't have Zeolith and it relies only on cold water for the condensation drying. Have also looked at some Miele manuals and their dishwashers don't run faster with hot water, either. The Eco cycle becomes all of ten minutes faster - from 3:19 hrs. to 3:09. Wow. :-/

Due to their heat exchangers, Bosch dishwashers create their own hot fill, using the heat given off by the hot water spraying in the tub. And even with 60C water going in... the little bit of water cooled down to cold as soon as the spray action began. Really didn't see the point in filling hot water in there when it cooled off in seconds.

As far as enzymes go, I know that many dishwashers are capable of heating in stages. I can hear the heater click on and off throughout the main wash. Even our crappy AEG from 1999 said it would heat in stages to activate enzymes and later oxy bleach.

I wonder which BSH dishwasher you have that is so bad. Mine is from 2010 and takes as little as 55 minutes to wash a full load. Really heavy loads are double-washed and triple-rinsed in 90 minutes. Add five minutes for options like Sanitize or an extra wash in the lower rack. And it achieves this without using crazy amounts of water like these modern Maytags that guzzle 45 liters and it can also wash hotter than modern Whirlpool/Kitchen Aids that max out at 41C unless you opt for High Temp to get either 55 or 60C. The 2006 Bosch at my mom's house will go up to 75C.

By the way, the pumping out during the wash is intended: it's to prevent hot water from being pushed out of the dishwasher by rapidly heating (thus expanding) air that's trapped in the dishwasher when you close the door. Different manufacturers solve this problem differently: newer BSHs will just pause for a moment and Mieles will do a few short spray bursts before resuming the cycle.

Our consumer magazine tested phosphate free detergents a while ago and many of them failed terribly. Those that claimed to also replace salt and rinse aid were particularly bad.

Alex



Post# 752248 , Reply# 93   4/23/2014 at 22:25 (3,677 days old) by washer111 ()        

Some interesting points their Logixx. 

 

Generally, I combine purging the line with washing hands, washing up some items too bulky for the dishwasher, or fill into a tub to place onto the garden, and all in all, maybe about 5-6L of water (seeing as the DD can do it in one fill with about 2.5L of water) is used. Being purposeful with it helps "save" water in reality too. 

I factored in the cost of water into my savings calculation, and it comes to about $4 of water yearly - though I save water elsewhere whenever permissible, which makes up for it

 

I too don't notice any reduction in cycle times on Delicates, but I on the rare occasions I run the Fast cycles. 

As I said before, it does "guarantee" the target temperature on the very hot Heavy and Heavy-Eco cycles, and of course saves some wear and tear on the machine. 

 

Given that your machine makes use of cold water to assist the drying process, and because EU machines often have the softeners onboard, they cannot make effective use of hot connections without compromising other functions, it seems (and long cycles mean you have to be standing by to purge again for the rinses). 

If one purges the hot tap, and runs a cycle with a short pre-rinse, that would probably do better for energy saving, though not for water :/ 


Post# 752287 , Reply# 94   4/24/2014 at 02:58 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Probably need to clarify a few things....
I do not know if the most modern or TOL bosch have "heat exchangers" that heats incoming water during the fill and so they fill water hot into the tub, never heard of such a thing anyway, mine does not and I can only imagine that if such feature even exist it will pull much electricty during the phase of filling.
I know my Bosch, as the Haier and the whirlpool did, had the classical modern Invisible/hidden heating element...the same element that in my whirlpool got broken after 2 years, reason why I had to change even if it really was a bad moment financially, the only thing more similar to an heat exchanger is that device , that is what maybe I call erroneously "hidden heating element" that takes it's time to get water hot like every water heater does, usually about 30 mins and or more from about 15 to 65, nothing paragonable to an hot fill machine anyway..
My model is reported above, I do not know what maytags you're alluding to, or KA, not even sure regarding the speech about the temperature, or at least I don't get it, how can they max out to 41degress at max if later you say you can opt for a hotter wash to 60 degrees? Isn't the same with every machine you can choose the wash temp???. Sorry, don't get it...
Anyway, I always and say always run the 65 degrees cycle in our bosch, and results are often disappointing at best as I described...
I came to realize that the fault of this is almost surely imputable to it's weakness for the most, I mean surges and pump power are really ridicolous...
So here I say, if using less water is synonym of silly toy-like surges/jets that cannot reach all the load properly and detach dirt like a dishwasher should do, then is more than welcome and neded a machine that use more water because it will be able to get stuff clean as I expect it to do...and generally I've found that dishwashers that use more water looks that meets this criteria, again, Generally, but anyway not always.
Anyway, even our old rex reached 75 degrees of temperature...
Temperature anyway it is not what matter for the most, you can even have water at 90 degrees, but if diswahser barely moves water then it's useless, you need a fair combination of heat and mechanical action that I could experience my machines were not capable to give, the results I get in the bosch running the heavy cycle at 65degress are paragonable to the ones I'd have gotten in my Rex if I had run the glassware short cycle.. Same was for the whirlpool and haier....
Do not really know what to say...
Regarding the speech about the dishwasher pumping out water during the wash, that is nothing I have ever experienced, never, would be anyway sort of crazy if so.....it already fills too less water IMO, let alone if it also do that purposedly.
All I said is that, sometimes has happened that I forgot something and had to open the machine either during the prewash or main wash to add it...
Or also that power went out suddenly....
When that happens, either because for reasons beyond your control as I said or because you stopped it to add something, the machine before resuming cycle when you close it, or when power returns, will do a partial drain before re-starting the cycle where it left, but since it will drain partially it will result in pump sucking air and the already silly amount of water it use will be nothing.
So, when you start it, you are forbidden to open it again, just let it go....and pray that power will no go out for some reasons, and wash the stuff you forgot by hand, otherwise you'll have to reset and start it again from the very start.








This post was last edited 04/24/2014 at 06:00
Post# 752300 , Reply# 95   4/24/2014 at 05:28 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Did some researches, didn't know the existence of this heat exchanged system in TOL BSH.... It's pretty new infact.
So, if I got this well, during the wash the heat exchanger heats some water for the next fill for the rinse thanks to the temperature inside the tub..
So it's like if the machine would heat the double amount of water because both if you heat for exchange or thanks to an element, the element is the one that gives heat and takes it's time....but this way allows perhaps little saving in time and sure avoid thermal shocks....cannot help but think that wheter before or after, the water amount has to be heated anyway, so the matter of time required to heat, would not change that much, so to the time to heat water in the wash you have to add also the time to heat the one in the heat exchanger since it would loss it to heat the other water for the next fill...
Do not see anyway much saving in this in term of energy and time, but sure is nice if you are washing fine glasswares that may suffer temperature shocks...
Nice idea after all. But still not comparable to an hot fill IMO.


Post# 752302 , Reply# 96   4/24/2014 at 05:47 (3,677 days old) by donprohel (I live in Munich - Germany, but I am Italian)        
Partial drain during wash

I cannot remember where I read (maybe in a User's Manual) that the partial drain during the wash is caused by an increase of he internal pressure if the door is opened and then closed again while the temperature inside is high and there is a lot of steam. The increased pressure triggers the water level switch, which causes the partial drain.

Both my previous Electrolux ESI682 (re-branded AEG) and my current AEG F99009 do that.

However, in the main wash sometimes they also do a partial drain followed by filling fresh water if they "believe" that the water is too dirty, but this is another story


Post# 752304 , Reply# 97   4/24/2014 at 05:56 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
That's not my case anyway because it does that even with cold water in the prewash and if I wait too much even when door is opened, btw, my machine has a floating sensor.....but not sure if it is a water level sensor or overfill prevention.. It shouldn't do that anyway...
Since it will fill while spraying supposedly as kind of load sensing method for customed-to-the-load water use (most machines do that nowadays) I also thought that perhaps it does that because once you stop all the water gathers in the bottom and it may result too high for the sensor, and start draining, but it would not drain almost half of the tub if so...it's not normal...
In any case, a thing more that I hate in it...
None of my previous machines ever did that....I am sure it's a problem in the electronic programmation it has..
To be honest...
I generally hate computerized electronic controls...they do not have the same flexibility and life of electromechanical ones.





This post was last edited 04/24/2014 at 06:53
Post# 752307 , Reply# 98   4/24/2014 at 06:10 (3,677 days old) by aquarius1984 (Planet earth)        

aquarius1984's profile picture
Logixx your right, Heat exchangers have been on Bosch machines for at least 16 to 17 years.

The Hotpoint machines based on Bosch even had it, even on the most basic models.


Post# 752309 , Reply# 99   4/24/2014 at 06:22 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Really? All of them? It looked quite a new thing in the bosch website...
Didn't know of that, so mine should also have it, funny enough never noticed of that, it always looked it filled cold water even though I have never opened it after the wash to see what water comes in the rinse, first (afterwash) rinse to be exact, but I know it does a warm short rinse after the wash and heater comes on as I can see it kicks on (the bulbs suddenly loose some power) and sometimes power meter would shut off if I am using the microvawe or something else, , then another longer rinse, , and the last long one at circa 60-70 degrees, then drain, fill water and dry by condensation, i also pretty dislike this drying system, not much good as a vented model, especially vented models on the fronts like Miele, not to mention ones with fans that are the top IMO, but one thing it does better than the haier and whirlpol is drying, with the whirlpool I always had to dry all of the stuff with the towel...with the bosch most stuff does not need to, ie pans and dishes..
Glasses and other items comes out with drops on them though..and still have to pass them with the towel.


Post# 752338 , Reply# 100   4/24/2014 at 09:39 (3,677 days old) by logixx (Germany)        

logixx's profile picture
washer111, using the water that is needed to purge the line is a very sensible idea. In my case, and I understand that everyone has different circumstances, I'd have to purge almost a small bucket (five liters or more) from the line and I have no use for so much cold water short of dumping it into the toilet after taking... never mind. ;-p At our old place, we had a recirculation pump and a hot-water connection would have made more sense there. Here, however, we asked out landlord to switch the recirc off because it made annoying noises in the pipes all day long. On top of that, the water cools off fairly quickly - like in ten minutes or so - and I'd have to be standing there purging the line as the DW goes through its cycle.

As aquarius pointed out, Bosch's heat exchanger has been around since "forever". I think it's the company's trademark just like Miele's cutlery drawer. Some of the cheapest models don't have it and special application units, like the counter top dishwashers, don't have it, ether.

The heat exchanger works during the post-wash phase, when dishwashers typically continue to wash without reheating the water. Roughly 15 minutes before the main wash drains, the heat exchanger fills with cold water and the temp inside the tub and inside the heat exchanger equalize. There's no extra energy or time needed to heat the water. This process takes place during every step of the cycle but the final rinse.

Vented drying in dishwashers? It's dead, I'm afraid. Most manufacturers have moved to some sort of condensation drying. I'm not actually sure why, though. For hygienic reasons? Because many people want fully hidden dishwashers these days? I don't mind vented drying - our AEG had it.

As for Maytag and KitchenAid: I'll add screen shots of the manuals for their current dishwashers:

The first one is Maytag's thirsty Pots & Pans cycle, which, by the way, is as fast or slow as the similar cycle on my dishwasher. Don't know what on earth you have to do to get the time up to 295 minutes.

The second picture is from KitchenAid. Seeing that you can use High Temp Wash even on the Though cycle, leads me to believe that even Though washes at 41C (or it might wash at 55C and HTW raises it to 60C).

Alex


Post# 752348 , Reply# 101   4/24/2014 at 10:34 (3,677 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
About your Bosch dishwasher Freddy,

I decided to download the manual of it. I see there are some interesting things about it.

1. The normal cycle doesn't have a heated prewash. But the Pots and Pans cycle has. The prewash is 50 degrees Celcius, the main wash 70 degrees Celcius. After the main wash it has three rinses of which the last one is heated again to 70 degrees Celcius.

2. There is a recommendation in the manual to connect the dishwasher to cold water. If connected to hot water, the temperature of it should be max. 60 degrees Celcius.

3. It looks like there is no heat exchanger in this model.

4. For shorter cycles they recommend only powder, no tabs.


Post# 752361 , Reply# 102   4/24/2014 at 11:45 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        
Sorry

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Louis, I think I told you a wrong number , i looked online as I was not at home (nor I am now) and should have got the wrong one, my correct number should instead be sgs43f02 , my machine has max temperature written next to the program you choose, the stronger cycle do have stated 65 degrees....so it is not the model you got the manual for, I appreciate your effort and if it is not much trouble please look for the correct one...
For istance, my dishwasher is like this
www.kelkoo.it/p-lavastoviglie-145...


Post# 752362 , Reply# 103   4/24/2014 at 11:47 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
You could spot it's knob type here in this thread from some time ago....
www.automaticwasher.org/cgi-bin/T...


Post# 752365 , Reply# 104   4/24/2014 at 12:05 (3,677 days old) by logixx (Germany)        

logixx's profile picture
No, this one ain't got the heat exchanger. As a matter of fact, it still uses parts that were used on the old generation (pump, heater, etc.).

Post# 752368 , Reply# 105   4/24/2014 at 12:10 (3,677 days old) by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, Friesland, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
Freddy,

That is not the right number, it's the model number of a Bosch dishwasher with a cutlery drawer.


Post# 752369 , Reply# 106   4/24/2014 at 12:14 (3,677 days old) by kenmoreguy89 (Valenza Piemonte, Italy- Soon to be US immigrant.)        

kenmoreguy89's profile picture
Sorry, looks like they mess up with models online and I am not at home right now to read the right one and tell you, hope you can determine the type from the pic though....



Post# 752433 , Reply# 107   4/24/2014 at 19:24 (3,676 days old) by washer111 ()        

For the record, our machine has vented drying.

 

Not that I let it run when I'm around. I cancel and open the drawer to flash dry, save some time and energy. 


Post# 753360 , Reply# 108   4/28/2014 at 08:11 (3,673 days old) by Mich (Hells Kitchen - New York)        
I've never understood...

mich's profile picture

Why anyone opens the door.

 

If you're using Rinse Aid, and your last rinse water, was of a decent temperature, the combination should dry your dishes. By opening your dishwasher door, you're letting all the hot steam & thermal heat out, that helps dry off anything still wet. Leaving it closed, you get powerful and good condensation based drying. 

 

I've always noticed, that if I open the dishwasher door, after the cycle, things stay wet. If I keep the door closed (for at least a couple of hours) everything is perfectly dry, even Plastics. 


Post# 753366 , Reply# 109   4/28/2014 at 08:32 (3,673 days old) by rapunzel (Sydney)        
Why anyone opens the door?

I like to use a cloth on concave surfaces like the bottoms of cups and glasses or any other place where water pools and doesn't completely evaporate. Then I just close the dishwasher again and in a couple of hours everything is really dry.

Post# 753486 , Reply# 110   4/28/2014 at 17:28 (3,672 days old) by washer111 ()        
Allow me to Explain :)

For me, it seems to save time and deliver better results - especially on the very hot cycles. In more humid weather, it just doesn't seem as if an environment at high humidity will be conducive to drying. 

 

I also haven't been using rinse-aid very much lately either, just on the minimum setting, and that stops all the spotting. The small addition makes flash-drying much easier.

 

Whilst it does work by letting the fan work, shutting the machine off saves whatever minuscule amount of power and drys everything in about 5 minutes - compare that to a 30 minute wait :)



Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      



Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In



New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.



                     


automaticwasher.org home
Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy