Thread Number: 35004
Machines that you have owned/owns that has gone faulty
[Down to Last]'s exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items --- [As an eBay Partner, eBay may compensate if you make a purchase using any link to eBay on this page]
Post# 523889   6/11/2011 at 09:45 (4,730 days old) by Fredriksam (Sweden)        

Since i moved from my parents home in 1991 i have had 5 washing machines. The one is have now is an Miele. Great quality. It works tip top.

However the 4 previous machines had quite some problems and here is the history of them

1 the first machine i bought was an very cheap one. It was an Ariston Margherita AR 670 Tx. I still have manual from it. Thats why i still now the name. The machine was quite silent, even when it span. What went wrong was that water leaked onto the motor and shorted the machine out. I did change the motor and tried to sealed the leak but later the same month the pump broke. It was time to get new machine.

2 The second machine was an Merloni. Also very cheap. I was upset that the machine didnt cleaned very well. The drum paddles was way too small. The biggest problem with this machine was that it jumped insanely around on spin. I had the seller come home 3 times. He couldnt do anything about it. Out of anger i kinda destroyed the machine by washing a very big rug. The machine didnt survived that.

3 The third one i had quite a long time. It was a siemens XL. It was very good the first 2 years i had it. Later it started making a racket when spinning. Heres a Youtube video with that.

Shortly after that, the module broke in it. I was able to get a new one pretty cheaply. The noise on spin grew worse and worse. Almost 1 and a half year later the mkodule broke again. This time i bought a new machine.

4 The third one was also very good the first 2 years. It was an Elektro-Helios. After 2 years and 2 monts the drum spider broke. Last time i used the machine it almost smashed itself into death. I had an video of that but took it down because i got a PM from Electrolux Group claimed i needed to remove this clip. It was up on Youtube. Assholes is what i say about them.

5 Now i have a Miele. No troubles. Just great Long live Miele!

So, please tell about your machines. The bad ones or the good ones.

Post# 523892 , Reply# 1   6/11/2011 at 10:01 (4,729 days old) by aquarius8000 ()        

1: my nan had 3 ecologics. machine no.1 was the drum-it exploded and somehow the machine carried on. It only ripped a pillowcase. Ecologic no.2 there was a burning smell so that got deadded and 3 I broke by not realizing after the end of the cycle the door stays locked for 2 mins I smacked the door realease button as hard as I could and the door would not oped so it was a case of smashing the door to retreive the laundry.

2:Before we got our current hotpoint we had an aquarius. The preassure switch broke so water was atleast 3 quarters of the drum was filled with water.

3: gran had a hotpoint like ours untill christmas 2010 when the bearings went and we had family coming from NZ and the decision was made that that should be scrapped beacause it was predicted that it would not cope so it was scrapped.

All the rest of my collection are fine though.

There you have it, Chris.

Post# 523893 , Reply# 2   6/11/2011 at 10:14 (4,729 days old) by aegokocarat (United Kingdom)        

The first automatic we had was in 1995 which was bought 2 years before i was born, it was a realy good machine up until 2003 when the bearings when and every time mum called hoover out the kept fitting generic parts and eventialy the spider collapsed and the bachine wouldent wash.
The second machine we bought was an indesit and it wa awful! it lasted for 18 months with normal use and eventualy we gave up cos it was to expensive to keep cos it broke every 3 months, bye bye indesit.
The third machine we had for 2 years and it was a hoover family 1300 (i think)
and it was good but it took four hours for a boil wash and 2 hours for a normal 40'c cottons wash, it died just before we were about to go on holiday (the pogrammer whent).
And so on to my current machine which is a hotpoint aqualtis (2006 b-new) only had one repaire and that was a new door seal and it has been a great machine!
these are mine :)

Post# 523897 , Reply# 3   6/11/2011 at 11:16 (4,729 days old) by cfz2882 (Belle Fourche,SD)        

the only machine i have bought new(though in damaged condition and fixed) that
has developed a fault is my Antonio Merloni built"splendide"combomatic 6100
-the motor commutator had a flaw in it causing a ticking noise and causing
the brushes to jump and arc at spin rpm;took the motor out,removed the
armature,turned the commutator true and reassembled.Washer has been problem free
for the last 6yrs since.
Washer was running good with this fault,but i wanted to fix it before the
motor was damaged.

Post# 523902 , Reply# 4   6/11/2011 at 12:26 (4,729 days old) by DADoES (TX,U.S. of A.)        

dadoes's profile picture


None of the washer/dryer pairs I've bought have as yet stopped working, I still have all of them.  The first pair was put into use in Sept 1991 (a KitchenAid 760 set).  Next, I bought an F&P GWL08/DE04 pair in Aug 1999.  The KitchenAids were still working fine, they went to my grandmother.  October 2004 I "upgraded" to another F&P pair, IWL12 & DEGX1.  The first F&Ps were again passed to granny, the KitchenAids went to storage.


Frederik says he's had 5 washers in 30 years (1991 -> 2011).  My parents have had just three washer/dryer sets since 1962.  A 1962/1964 Whirlpool washer/dryer.  A 1976 Whirlpool washer/dryer.  And a 1994 KitchenAid washer/dryer, which are still in use.

Post# 523918 , Reply# 5   6/11/2011 at 13:00 (4,729 days old) by gmmcnair (Portland, OR)        
I've had 3 in the last decade....none were unfixable

gmmcnair's profile picture
When I bought my house in 2002, the owners included the Frigidaire built Kenmore laundry enter. It never broke, but it wasn't what I wanted. Capacity was small, and I don't think it washed that well. The tall machine also blocked the faucet shutoffs, which made me nervous. Who wants to move a machine that tall and heavy in the event a hose splits?

I replaced it in 2007 with a rebuilt Whirlpool DD. Beautiful TOL machine that had in retrospect been used way too hard. It was a three speed model, with every bell and whistle there was, and it was glitchy. When the motor coupler failed in 2010, I replaced it with a BOL Admiral (Whirlpool). It's been very trusty if more than a little noisy. I like the machine just fine.

Post# 523952 , Reply# 6   6/11/2011 at 15:42 (4,729 days old) by MaytagA710 ()        

I had a Maytag/Norgetag Atlantis, stainless tub, auto temp control, it failed. Such a handsome looking machine, I loved the curved lid. I also had a 1990 Kenmore DD, it failed after 10 years, motor coupler, I was into appliances but I was young and didn't know a whole lot about the mechanical aspect. If I was a bit older, I would have been able to fix it!

Post# 524014 , Reply# 7   6/11/2011 at 22:06 (4,729 days old) by DADoES (TX,U.S. of A.)        

dadoes's profile picture


I consider a "failure" to be a problem catastrophic to the point that repair is not reasonable.  A broken motor coupler (current cost via online sources less than $15) is a routine repair.


My KitchenAid has had the motor coupler and agitator dogs replaced.  Total cost less than $20.  None of my F&Ps have had any repairs.


The parents' machines all had repairs.   The 1962 Whirlpool is too far back to remember everything clearly but do recall pumps, wigwags, belts, the mercury lid switch bracket rusted off, the bakelite agitator cracked, and bearings were replaced twice, the third time triggered a replacement.  The 1976 Whirlpool had the belt changed at least once that I recall, timer, and probably pump and possibly a wigwag.  Their KA has had the coupler replaced twice, agitator dogs once, pump once (as a preventive measure before it actually failed), and the lid switch broke and is bypassed ... which again, these are routine repairs, not failures that call for the machine to be tossed out.

Post# 524022 , Reply# 8   6/12/2011 at 00:07 (4,729 days old) by MaytagA710 ()        

I guess I define failures as anything that just stops working, I use it all the time at work regarding failed components on airplanes. I understand now the coupler would have been an easy fix, especially since the machine was designed to be so accessible, and its unfortunate good machines get tossed to the curb for such a simple issue, but I was only 14 when the coupler failed/broke, and I never understood how the machines drive system was set up. But after knowing about the motor coupler, and how the DD system works, I have replaced a few of them on family and friends machines over the last few years.

A lot of people I find don't like the DD machines, I'm more love/hate. Sometimes I love them, love the sound of it, but other times I scoff it off as boring. But I am always a fan of how the machine was designed, and how its extremely accessible compared to other designs on the market (aside from the fact that its a fast stroke, in a tall and narrow tub). A simple way to connect the motor and transmission together, that is a simple, easy, cheap fix, that when it does break it doesn't make the machine completely useless as you can still drain the water out.

Post# 524023 , Reply# 9   6/12/2011 at 00:23 (4,729 days old) by pierreandreply4 (St-Bruno de montarville (province of quebec) canada)        

pierreandreply4's profile picture
i had a direct drive washer from 1993 to 2004 and i love my inglis superb2 direct drive washer.

Post# 524476 , Reply# 10   6/14/2011 at 15:06 (4,726 days old) by KenmoreBD (Mass, usa )        

The only washer our family ever had that was headed for major breakdown was the 1987 whirlpool dd washer, It was starting to leak a good amount of oil from the gearbox when it left. The washer only had one other repair and that was to replace the timer. My grandma's late 70's kenmore beltdrive just quit in 2003 they could not drain it, start it anything. It also had never been worked once.


Post# 524588 , Reply# 11   6/15/2011 at 02:25 (4,726 days old) by mieleforever (SOUTH AFRICA)        

Well the first one I had was a Fuchware, bought it secondhand, and worked fine for a few years was really jumpy when started to spin. After about two years it started to leak water. So it was quite difficult to find the leaking spot. eventually found the leak and repaired with silicone. Lasted for a while and then started to leak again. Move to another place and bought a Samsung fl, brand new. I was very impressed at first but the machine was very loud and since the apartment was very small it was not that nice to have. And from the very first spin it had difficulty in trying to balance the load and always made some knocking sound when it started with its spin it will take about five to ten minutes to try and balance the load and then still it will sound like a Jetplane taking off. So it was not very nice, and sometimes it had difficulty in rinsing properly. Sometimes if you accidently overdosed the machine it will just carry on and you will not even see the clothes only white foam. I had it for5 years but had to change the pump, and belt and then some of its suspension went awry, so I had to work on that as well and the drum started to sag. I was single for most of the times so only one person's laundry. Not a very good machine gave it away and bought myself a MIELE W5740.

Wow what a rush, very quiet spins extremely fast uses little water, and washes extremely clean without any suds clinging to the clothes.

Also bought myself a Miele condensor dryer and 2 Miele Vacuums, I am a Miele convert now.


Post# 524600 , Reply# 12   6/15/2011 at 06:32 (4,726 days old) by freshlinen (south africa)        

Hi Aldo

May i use your first name?Anyhow much respect to you for stepping over to Miele.I am on my way there also.I just want your input as to servicing my 2 AEG Lavamats (pre-Electrolux take over).I asked around and was told that drum bearings on these machines and having suspensions checked are expensive?

Please if you will feel free to reply to my private e-mail:-

I do live in Cape Town,RSA.

Post# 524615 , Reply# 13   6/15/2011 at 08:39 (4,726 days old) by mieleforever (SOUTH AFRICA)        

Ridwaan, well if I were you call around to see what the charges will be on average. I had a AEG Favorite dishwasher also pre eletrolux, Was a wonderful machine until the repairs started, the back up service realy was terrible, and I had to pay an arm and a leg, for a part that at the end of the day did not work all that well, it was the main pump, I had to dish out more than R1500.00 just for the part, and that was about 10 years ago. So yeah I think it will cost you quite a bit at the end of the day to repair it all. But it usually they were very good machines, had a AEG vacuum as well was about 7 years old but then you had such a terrible time in finding bags and filters, and eventually the machines motor burned out. So I have lost my trust in them. Hopefully the Miele's will not dissapoint me.


Post# 524626 , Reply# 14   6/15/2011 at 09:04 (4,726 days old) by robliverpool (england Liverpool)        
my machine

robliverpool's profile picture
1. Top loader hotpoint was 2nd hand when i got it, first machine when i was 17
2. 1989 Hotpoint front loader also 2nd hand when i got it
3 Colston washer dryer given to me was on its last legs lol
4. Hotpoint washer also given to me on its last legs
5. Whirlpool washer bought 2nd hand, spider and the bearings went
6. Zannussi jetsystem given to me 2nd hand
7. Whirlpool First ever brand new machine, kept breaking so i sent it back after 4 months
8. Hotpoint Paid 50 quid and lasted for 2 years
9. Indesit A comet special, paid 189 and it died after 13 months
10. servis millenium paid 20 quid and had it over a year no faults and still works now in my friends house
11. Hotpoint aquairus paid 15 quid and had 3 years of service no faults and still works now in my aunts house
12. AEG bought 2nd hand 150 quid kept getting error code to say the brushes were worn so that went after 4 months.
13 Hotpoint aquarius paid 195 second hand wi gaurentee. sold it after 5 months
15. Haier Another comet bargain, lasted 3 days and they sent replacement
16. Haier Lasted an hour and put it in back of car to return to comet.
17. Swan 9kg steam washing machine. Broke after 5 months and couldnt be repaired
18. Hotpoint 6kg currrent machine paid 240 and its working great (so far)

I have had a lot of washers over the years and i have got to say even though i love the older hotpoints my two fav machines i have owned was my early whirlpool as it had great high water levels and never had to rewash anything and my other fav machine was the top loader hotpoint and i only got rid of it cos the clutch went and i was only 17 and didnt know how to fix it

Post# 524725 , Reply# 15   6/15/2011 at 18:58 (4,725 days old) by PassatDoc (Orange County, California)        
where shall I start?

I've been in my own home for 23 years. Prior to that, lived in an apartment building and used the building's coin laundry room.

1988: White Westinghouse washer and dryer set, $600 the pair. It was the only model sold at Price Club (now Costco) and I figured that anything sold by Price Club had to be decent quality, if not luxurious. Furthermore, I had a colleague at work who'd bought the pair (not her first washer, as she was married with teenagers) and felt that it washed well. Big mistake. The water level control was infinite and broke three times. The first time it broke, it was covered under warranty. The second time it broke, it was not covered, but the repair service found a used part to repair the water level control for about $125. Third time it broke the repair would have cost $300, so I decided not to "throw good money after bad". Gave the dryer to charity; washer not worth fixing.

1997: Replaced the set above with a GE pair for $800. The Neptune by Maytag was just being introduced and cost a fortune. This was GE's largest capacity top loader. It did not have special features like extra rinse. Washed decently and certainly held more clothes than the old one. After a while, developed hard water stains which I could not remove and developed a moldy odor, which partly went away by leaving the door up, but it never disappeared. Machine began to leak water in 2006, was repaired, then broke a second time. Repair service said it was not worth fixing. Washer given to charity (for parts value). Dryer given to neighbor (see below).

2006: When GE machine above was repaired, the technician said, "if it starts to leak again, best to look for a new washer". As a result, I began looking at new washers in case the machine broke again. Two weeks later, it did break again, but I had done my research and was able to go shopping the same day for the new one. I bought a Frigidaire 2140. Rather basic, and had I known more about the product, I would have bought the next model up the ladder, the 2940, because it offers delay wash and ATC (I use delay wash more than I expected, it is not a useless gimmick). My laundry area is in the garage (pipes don't freeze here!) and there is a concrete filled pipe sticking out of the floor (required by law) to protect the machines from a car. The pipe is directly in front of the washer area, and would block the door of any FL (but house was built 1988 when there were no FL washers sold in USA except a few Westinghouse machines or imported Mieles). To work around this, it was necessary to stack a pair of machines in the dryer space, where there is no pipe. As a result, I had to buy the matching dryer and a stacking kit. I gave my old gas dryer, which still works well to this day, to my neighbor, who wanted to get rid of his old electric dryer in order to save money on utility bills. He gave me his electric dryer, which I then donated to the same charity that took my washer for parts (in USA, you can reduce your taxable income by $500* per year if you donate used goods to a charity and have a receipt to prove it).

Neither of the first two washers lasted more than nine years. The first one also broke three times. At least the GE broke only once, near the end. The present Frigidaire washer works fine, but it's only five years old. My guess is that someday the aluminum spider will break, it will cost $300-400 to repair, and I'll simply buy a newer Frigidaire (one of their 4.4 cu ft models perhaps) or an Electrolux as a replacement. It would be nice to see a washer last ten years with no repairs needed. I take good care of it: I descale it four times a year, always leave the door ajar when not in use, and I use only powdered HE detergent.

*you can reduce the taxable income by more than this IF you have two professional appraisals of the item. I know a person who donated a piano to a charity, because she was moving to a smaller home without space for a piano. The instrument was worth $11,000 and she was able to subtract this from her income before tax was calculated. I.e. she avoided about $3500-4000 in taxes, and the charity received a product which they could sell and keep all of the price as a profit.

Post# 524727 , Reply# 16   6/15/2011 at 19:10 (4,725 days old) by PassatDoc (Orange County, California)        
relatives' machines

My aunt had to replace her 1964 Maytag in c. 2006. It was 42 years old. She and my uncle bought their present home in 1956, and the first washer lasted only eight years. She bought the Maytag on the advice of another aunt (now deceased) who advised her to buy a Maytag in 1964. Thus her present washer (a Whirlpool I think, TL) is only her third in 55 years, and until 2006, two washers had lasted her 50 years. I believe the Maytag had been repaired a few times, but never anything major.

My sister moved to her present home in 1993 and bought a new Maytag Dependable Care washer and dryer. They are still working today and have never had a repair. That's 18 years.

Post# 524731 , Reply# 17   6/15/2011 at 19:29 (4,725 days old) by mixfinder ()        
Color Me Lucky

I have never had a lemon or bad machine in all the houses, moves and changes.  All appliances were Frigidaire with Maytag laundry until GM tanked.  Then it was Maytag dishwashers and in 87 added a Maytag fridge.  Moved to a condo in 2002 for all new GE and again never an issue.  The Maytag Atlantis came along and they are still washing for the ex.  Since then its all been used and a blend of Frigidaire, GE and Maytag with a Kitchenaid dishwasher thrown in.  I might add that never overloading, keeping appliances clean and vacuuming condensers is easy and prudent.

Post# 524772 , Reply# 18   6/15/2011 at 23:59 (4,725 days old) by cfz2882 (Belle Fourche,SD)        
older breakdowns

here are the past breakdowns of machines myself or parents bought new or in
working order:
Ca.1960 HP silhoette dryer-$25 yard sale buy(in '79) lasted about a year before
roller shaft bushing wore through,letting shaft wear ended it's
days with a loud clang...motor lived on for years after in other app...
1970 HP solid tub washer-was problem free for 10 yrs then pump,sediment tube,
clutch and (possibly tranny)problems sent it to it's landfill grave in 1981..
1981 KM BD "70"replacement for the HP,it's timer quit when it was just days old
after that was fixed under warranty,next problem was in '89 when some string
wound up in the pump and i couldn't get it out-new pump fixed it.machine in my
fleet today.
1980 monkey norge dryer-bought new in '80 and lasted to 1998 when the motor
seized and none was avalible at bearing,drum bushing,latch and
elements were also bad.Scrapped-parts of it went into other uses...
1981 filter flo-very "high miles" machine over the last 21 yrs have replaced
-pump(with a used one)motor(used)belt,a couple clutch repairs,tranny repair,
and a couple boots-1st,aftermarket,lasted 2 yrs-2nd,genuine still good after
10 yrs. Agitator vibration damper developing lash so agitator will need
replacement soon...

Post# 524777 , Reply# 19   6/16/2011 at 00:50 (4,725 days old) by freshlinen (south africa)        

Dear Aldo

Thanks for your reply.I will think it all over (AKA planning budget for possible repair parts +service+ labour costs).

If I find that it is not fruitful then by my 40Th bIRTHDAY (Feb 2012) will see me buying a new Miele frontload washing machine BUT can you tell me which model of a Miele in their current range will be a good buy?

I always appreciate your reply.Thanks again my friend.

Post# 526661 , Reply# 20   6/24/2011 at 12:47 (4,716 days old) by mieleforever (SOUTH AFRICA)        
for freshlinen

Hi how are you? have as yet decided on what you are gonna do regarding your AEG's, would be a pitty if they were to go to the dumps.

Post some pics.

Cheers buddy

Post# 526674 , Reply# 21   6/24/2011 at 14:32 (4,716 days old) by Haxisfan (Europe - UK / Italy)        
Great Thread There :-)

haxisfan's profile picture
I think every1 loves to share their experiences with washing machines... so do I! I couldn't help noticing that many of you have gone through many washers in relatively short periods of time... and others have managed to keep 1 washer throughout their entire life... what we need now is something slap bang in the middle: my experience :-)

I left my family home some 15 years ago and I have experienced 4 washing machines to date. I was using my landlady/landlord's Bendix front loader 600rpm to do my laundry back in 1996 up to 1998 when it was put aside due to a broken door seal (and later given to me when I got my own place). It was replaced by a crappy Electra, which was nothing but trouble... spin problems and burning smells seemed to be the norm... and only after a few months after I left my landlord/landlady's place, they replaced it with a Bosch Maxx (or maybe Exxcel).

Let's go back to the Bendix... it was already about 10 years of age and in full working order but in need of a new door seal which was duly sorted. This washer was a bit basic, no frills, few programmes and low spin speed but it did the trick while I was settling down into my new home. After a couple of years, I was given a 4 year old Zanussi 800rpm which I regrettably accepted as a replacement for the Bendix. It was pretty basic too, but with a faster spin speed, so I figured I'd benefit from this through quicker drying times... well, that bit was true... but overall that machine was an absolute headache thanks to its lack of stability, and weird programme configuration (only one cycle had a final spin at the end, all the others would just do an automatic rinse hold... and even the cotton rinses did not foresee interim spins!).

As much as I disliked the Zanussi, it served me well (I mean... it kept on working) for 3 years on the trot, then, due to its jumping habits, some physical damage occurred to its programmer which did no longer allow for fabric conditioner intake: This was fixed and the machine was sold on eBay. 2004 that was... when I ordered a Candy Aquaviva 1300rpm through a catalogue. I could finally see what progress and evolution had done to washing machines... I was over the moon with it as it was cleaning soooo beatifully and above all, it was spin drying wonderfully allowing me to give drying times a definite cut! I only used it for less than a week... having realised that the detergent cavity had a crack in it, I rung up the catalogue to have it exchanged but they no longer had that particular model.

I was determined to buy another Candy Acquaviva as it'd made such an impression on me... so I started my Candy hunt online only to find that it had been discontinued... however, there were other Candy washers available. After a little search, I spotted a Hoover Nextra in an online store which was given away for the same price as some of the Candys I was looking at, but it featured some more appealing wash options and a nice Satin finish. That was final... and it marked the end of an era... I mean, the end of my washing machine ownership experience to date (except for the occasional machines used on holiday). It wasn't as easy as it seemed to start with as the Hoover I ordered presented some minor cosmetic problems that lead to the order of two more replacements... the last being in white: so, I ended up with a white washer after all, although it's gradually becoming yellow :-D

Take care every1

Post# 526864 , Reply# 22   6/25/2011 at 15:29 (4,715 days old) by freshlinen (south africa)        
for mieleforever

Dear Aldo

Louis vz also on this forum has been in contact with me.I have stopped using both Lavamats.Called Claremont home appliances and sourced the parts.I called a very good independant repairman to have a look at them once I have the parts in hand for both.From Germany the parts will come between 2-3 weeks wait.In the meantime I am using a brand new Defy Maximaid 8.5kg machine.Whats your thought on these Defy's?

Also Louis thinks it might be bearings going on both Lavamats.I think maybe new shocks or both bearings and shocks?

I would love to hear your input?Thanks as always-Freshlinen

Post# 526919 , Reply# 23   6/25/2011 at 23:20 (4,715 days old) by whirlcool (Just North Of Houston, Texas)        

We have been really lucky. We had a 83' Maytag machine that we had until 1993. It didn't break, we just thought it was too boring and had too lazy of a roll over. So we replaced it in Feb 93 with the Whirlpool Electronic Control machine that we are still using today. I've overhauled the agitator dogs and bearing, and it started to act up with the electronic controls, but a reseating of the cable to the controls fixed that. So in all these years we've only owned two washers.

Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      

Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In

New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.

Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy