Thread Number: 78647  /  Tag: Other Home Products or Autos
Help me choosing a coffee maker
[Down to Last]'s exclusive eBay Watch:
scroll >>> for more items
Post# 1026465   3/7/2019 at 01:27 by harriserickson (Canada)        

Hey guys. Iím not a barista or anything. Just a regular person who likes his coffee. Iíve been googling and searching and it seems I canít find anything consistent. So hereís a little back story to help with helping me find a coffee maker.
I work a 12-hour shift and I live about an hour away from my office. However, I live alone so it isnít feasible for me to make a 12 cup pot on my days off. Iíve been wanting to get a nice coffee maker that I could potentially replace my Keurig and my drip maker with(when I take my thermos). Iím really interested in the grind and brew systems. A long time ago I was given an espresso-style grind and brew with the frother thing on the side. I never used the frother but the coffee was always rich bold and so fresh tasting.
I just want a good cup or two to have to brew a whole pot. I hope to hear something about the espresso machine ( ) back soon. My Keurig's pump is starting to get loud which is why Iím in the market for a good coffee maker.

Thanks for the help!!

Post# 1026481 , Reply# 1   3/7/2019 at 09:15 by lakewebsterkid (Dayton, Ohio)        
Large French Press?

My French press takes about 6 minutes from start to finish. The taste is incredible. Also, itís cheap! Keurig coffee is horrible tasting in comparison.

Post# 1026484 , Reply# 2   3/7/2019 at 10:07 by thomasortega (We have a famous sign, earthquakes, bushfires and weed)        

Kitchenaid + Brazilian Melitta "Extra Forte" coffee that you can find in Brazilian stores all over the country.

1) Brazilians don't care about french Braristas say about water temperature.
2) Coffee must be like men (Black, hot, strong and tasty and with a touch of sweetness)
3) Most cheap coffee makers make a lukewarm coffee that tastes like pee. (not that I ever tasted pee. but...)
4) I discovered a Kitchenaid Coffee Maker that makes a HOT coffee.

If you want to try before you buy the coffee, go to a 7-Eleven and ask them to brew a fresh batch of the Brazilian Roast. They import the Melitta coffee from Brazil and theyr coffee maker is great (Bunn)

Post# 1026485 , Reply# 3   3/7/2019 at 10:46 by Iheartmaytag (Wichita, Kansas)        

iheartmaytag's profile picture
Bunn even makes a single serve coffee maker.
They do pay attention to temperature, and brew/contact time.

Post# 1026493 , Reply# 4   3/7/2019 at 13:11 by RP2813 (West Coast)        

rp2813's profile picture

The basic Cuisinart auto drip maker that's been around for many years consistently receives top ratings by CR as well as various coffee authorities.   I had a few of their burr grind & brew machines, because they kept having issues under warranty.  I'd steer clear of those.  Maybe the kind with blade grinders are more reliable.


Ultimately, when I was done with Cuisinart and in the market for a replacement, I ended up with a glass carafe Bonavita auto drip teamed up with a '60s/'70s vintage KitchenAid grinder (which took a while to find at a reasonable price on line).  I hacked the Bonavita with a glass Chemex carafe and the brew it rendered got even better.  No frills, no blue tooth, no clock, it won't tell you who won the World Series of 1934 or how bad the traffic is, and as a result it does the one thing it's designed for really well with just a single on/off flip switch.


I don't like the idea of storing brewed coffee in a metal thermos.  Glass lined is OK, but most that are included with auto drip makers these days are not glass lined.

Post# 1026494 , Reply# 5   3/7/2019 at 13:32 by luxflairguy (Wilmington NC)        

Love my French press!  Faster than anything else and the quality is better too!

Post# 1026496 , Reply# 6   3/7/2019 at 13:36 by vacerator (Macomb, Michigan)        
I, and We've had several over the decades.

The MR. Coffee ones used to last a long time, but our most recent only 2.5 years. Of course, we had used it nearly every day. We had a Bunn, and it began leaking water after 2 or 3 years. A small Kitchen Aid prior to that, which I gave to someone at work for their cabin up north. We had one Braun, nothing special either.
Last summer, we got the Cusinart 12 cup with the Kuerig self contained. So far it has been excellent. Each reservoir has a charcoal filter, and Amazon has a 12 pack of those for about $10. They last at least 2 months. It takes the Melita cone No. 4 filters, and came with a gold filter also. Full retail is $199, but they can be bought for $169, and Bed Bath and Beyond sends out 20% off coupons in the mail frequently.

Post# 1026498 , Reply# 7   3/7/2019 at 13:51 by ea56 (Sonoma Co.,CA)        

ea56's profile picture
Iíve owned and used just about every kind of coffeemaker and coffeepot known to man. I have enjoyed collecting them and learning how to make coffee in all the many different ways possible.

That being said, this past summer I bought a Braun Aromaster 10 on ebay, and it is bar none the very best coffeemaker Iíve ever owned! It makes constantly excellent coffee, quickly and easily. It has a small footprint on my kitchen counter and its simplicity makes it look very nice sitting out on the counter too.

I have a digital electric outlet timer programmed for both my morning pot and evening pot of coffee, and I mostly just use plain old preground Maxwell House Colombian coffee, and always get a nice rich, strong full flavored brew. I have the permanent gold filter, but I find that I like the brown Mellita #4 paper filters better. This is a very easy coffee carafe to keep clean too.

Out of all the over 100 different coffeemakers Iíve owned, Iíve used this Braun for a longer period of time than any of the others. In fact, its cured me of my obsession to continually acquire another coffeepot. Got that monkey off my back, LOL.


  Photos...       <              >      Photo 1 of 2         View Full Size
Post# 1026503 , Reply# 8   3/7/2019 at 14:32 by RP2813 (West Coast)        
What Eddie Said!

rp2813's profile picture

I completely forgot about the Braun Aromaster!  That brewer has always received high marks.  We had one for many years (paired with the same Sunbeam toaster) until I upgraded to Braun's variant, the "FlavorSelect," which employed an additional side-shot of brewing water into the basket.  I still have that one as a spare/camping brewer (like we camp or have an RV anymore, lol).


I've sworn off thrift stores since making my giant purge before moving last year, but in my experience Aromasters could often be found on thrift store shelves or just their carafes to have on hand in case of breakage.


The big thing that confirmed the excellence of the Aromaster happened on TV when I spotted one on a counter in Ina Garten's kitchen.  Even if it was only a prop, it made a statement.

This post was last edited 03/07/2019 at 19:27
Post# 1026511 , Reply# 9   3/7/2019 at 17:05 by funktionalart (Rison, AR)        
An oddball choice for most, but I swear by these:

funktionalart's profile picture
Krups Moka (aka t8). I probably wouldn't buy the newest version (made in China, I believe). I use one of the late 90s/early 2000s French made ones (mine's the black one in pic below). Mine was made for the US/North American market electric power...though you can get a 220v European one and either convert it for power here or rig up a 220 outlet in your house.. These were HUGELY popular in Europe since the 60s. They deliver the tastiest brew (to me, at least). Use great quality water and equally good beans of your choice, and you'll be hooked. The flavour is not far off from French Press method. The brew system is by steam/pressure, and it leaves a quite dry "hockey puck" of grounds behind in the filter holder. You can basically smack the back of it and the compacted ground drop into the trash.

The downside (to alot of Americans, anyway) is that they can seem time consuming to set up. There is only on/off (no timers, etc). If you want coffee ready when you wake up, you'll have to fill the machine at night and plug it into a timer. I also agree with the recommendations of older Braun Aromasters.

  Photos...       <              >      Photo 1 of 2         View Full Size
Post# 1026552 , Reply# 10   3/8/2019 at 02:52 by MattL (Flushing, MI)        

I use the classic highly rated Cuisinart pot, and have for many many years.  That said I'm thinking of picking up a cheap MR. Coffee. We had one at work and it turned out decent, albeit not great coffee, no matter the brand of coffee.  Plus it uses significantly less coffee to do it.  I'm in no way a coffee snob, Maxwell House is my daily grind, but have always hated Folgers but in the Mr. coffee it was fine, as were other inexpensive coffees.  in the Cuisinart I use 2/3c for 10 cups of coffee, the Mr. Coffee I'd use 4 heaping scoops for 12 cups, significantly less.


I've ground my own beans, used a vac pot for many years, but the difference to me did not outweigh the extra cost and effort. YMMV, but I'd suggest trying several different pots from a place you can return them if your not happy. 

Post# 1026553 , Reply# 11   3/8/2019 at 06:16 by foraloysius (Leeuwarden, the Netherlands)        

foraloysius's profile picture
I have one of those Krups T8 models too, I bought it in the nineties. In the past I have had one of the original ones too. In comparison the newer versions are lighter built, the carafe is thinner (more vulnerable to breakage) and they take longer to make a full pot of coffee. I have had it on my countertop a few times to use it as a daily coffee maker, but I never got excited about it. It takes more coffee to get a decent cup of coffee in comparison to other systems I have used.

Right now I have a Moccamaster again for daily use. It's much faster and gets more flavour out of the coffee. Don't use brown paper filters though, they influence the taste of the coffee in a negative way. I use white paper filters (Melitta) at the moment, but also have a gold filter.

French press is good too, it's a fast way of making a good cup of coffee. It takes a bit more time to clean it though. If you consider a French press, look at a Bodum, their filter is better than most of the other ones.

If you don't want to spend a lot of money and you want to grind your own coffee, consider a french press or a glass poor over and a Krups F203 coffee grinder. In general buur grinders are better than blade grinders, but this is a good blade grinder and much better than a lot of the cheaper burr grinders. The Krups is available on Amazon for $18.95 and a french press will set you back $15.- - $30.-

Post# 1026582 , Reply# 12   3/8/2019 at 13:05 by Superocd (PNW)        
I'm very picky when it comes to certain kinds of applian

Like I need to have stainless steel kitchen appliances, a front loading washer with steam, no in-door ice or water on my fridge, a high-CFM range hood, an NSF certified sani cycle on my dishwasher, a direct-air vacuum cleaner, etc., but my coffeemaker is nothing special, it's just a simple $15 Mr. Coffee model from Wal-Mart and it does the job really well. It's just the kind with a simple switch. When it dies it will be replaced with another one, though I might get a Bunn.

Post# 1026584 , Reply# 13   3/8/2019 at 13:39 by lotsosudz (Sacramento, CA)        
Perked Coffee

lotsosudz's profile picture
I have a 12 cup Farberware Superfast Percolator, that makes a nice, hot whole bodied cup of brew. Sometimes I think in this day of automation, and Technology, we often overlook the simple methods, that were tried and true. I think we over complicate our lives with all this gadgetry. P.S. the farberware is quick for those mornings when you need the caffeine kick fast.

Post# 1026590 , Reply# 14   3/8/2019 at 16:13 by Xraytech (Rural southwest Pennsylvania )        

xraytech's profile picture
I have to say that my favorite pot is my Corning Ware Drip-o-latorits simple to use, makes a good cup of coffee fairly quick, and itís eady to clean.

  View Full Size
Post# 1026594 , Reply# 15   3/8/2019 at 18:20 by GusHerb (Chicago/NWI)        

My drip brewer is a Bunn VP-17 commercial brewer. Almost impossible to screw up coffee in that, always comes out good (provided you put something good in it). I have a shelf full of brewers and thatís my go-to.

Post# 1026597 , Reply# 16   3/8/2019 at 18:57 by twintubdexter (Palm Springs)        

twintubdexter's profile picture

I like reading all these coffee maker reviews. Just about everyone loves their coffee. I guess I've just been lucky with my choice of brewers. 17 years ago when I bought this house I purchased a Capresso machine. I chose it because of the thermal carafe and that the water reservoir is removable for easy filling. All these years later it still works  perfectly. I have never used the milk frothing feature. I occasionally use Dip-It coffee maker cleaner to keep it humming.


Unfortunately this model is no longer made. I've seen them offered used. I don't know how much the Swiss know about coffee drinking but they sure know how to build a coffee maker.

  View Full Size
Post# 1026599 , Reply# 17   3/8/2019 at 20:42 by Dustin92 (Jackson, MI)        

I'm not a coffee drinker, so take this for what it is.. My parents used Bunn for years but never got more than about 3 years out of one until they inevitably started leaking.. At first a small dribble, gradually getting worse until it's making a huge mess, or shorts out the electronics (we had both over the years) They faithfully bought numerous Bunn machines at $100+ a pop, until I picked up a 12 cup Cuisinart at a thrift store for less than $5. I had originally intended for it to last until they could afford another new Bunn, but they LOVE it, and here we are 4-5 years later and my Dad has even said he doesn't want another Bunn, he said if this one dies he wants another one just like it. He said the Bunn made fast coffee, the Cuisinart makes good coffee, and with the timer, no waiting for it. They both say it makes better coffee than a Bunn ever did. Bunn coffee makers can make a pot of coffee in 3 minutes, sure. But they require a lot of maintenance to do so, if it clogs up, plan on waiting 15-20 minutes for a pot, and once the brew cycle is started, it can't be stopped.

Post# 1026600 , Reply# 18   3/8/2019 at 21:37 by wayupnorth (On a lake between Bangor and Bar Harbor)        

wayupnorth's profile picture
I have an exact same Brawn but finding cheap V filters and a new carafe is not easy. I use an old Proctor Silex. Makes me 2 mugs every morning and thats all that counts now that I am retired.

Post# 1026601 , Reply# 19   3/8/2019 at 22:05 by fan-of-fans (Florida)        

I have one of those white Braun Aromaster 12 cup makers. I don't even drink coffee, only got it because it was the one on Keeping Up Appearances. I lent it to my mom to use when her machine broke - she said it made great coffee.

I still see those Aromasters once in a while at thrift shops. They also made a programmable version - also in black.

I see the carafes once in a while at thrift stores too. Unfortunately the clear flavor seal piece on the lid that's supposed to help keep the coffee fresh is almost always missing.

Post# 1026603 , Reply# 20   3/8/2019 at 22:18 by Hunter (Colorado)        
Vintage percolator

I use a late 60s aluminum GE.electric percolator I got at Goodwill for $5. Best coffee Iíve tasted.

Post# 1026612 , Reply# 21   3/8/2019 at 23:29 by sarahperdue (Alabama)        
Sunbeam Coffeemaster

sarahperdue's profile picture
Vintage, automatic, vacuum coffee--deep, rich brew. I use Cafe Bustello ground espresso coffee in it. It's chrome plated copper and heats evenly all around the pot so the coffee doesn't get that burned flavor when kept on warm for a long time. It tastes fresh. I confess that I often warm up yesterday's coffee, and it still tastes pretty good. Paired with a Westinghouse timer, it's ready when I am.

My second favorite is the Chemex with the Chemex brand filter papers. Very clean brew.


  View Full Size
Post# 1026621 , Reply# 22   3/9/2019 at 01:55 by MattL (Flushing, MI)        

I used one of the Sunbeam vac pots for years, made really good coffee.  I think I've got 5 in my collection.  I'd chuckle as I had this 1940's tech hooked to my Samsung SmartThings to control it, talk about a blending of old and new.  I adjusted the thermostats a few times but got one too many boil overs and went back the Cuisinart.  As mentioned previously I'm  on the look out for a Mr. Coffee like we had at work.

Post# 1026649 , Reply# 23   3/9/2019 at 14:24 by RP2813 (West Coast)        

rp2813's profile picture

Tim, I see the V-shaped Melitta type filters at the 99c Only Store all the time.  Since I switched to a Chemex carafe, I use their proprietary (I think) cone type filters.  If you think the V-shaped ones are expensive, you ain't seen nothin' yet.  Chemex filters are tough to find, too.  Around here, BB&B stopped carrying them and now the only place I can find them is at ACE. 


I suppose the Braun carafes are becoming more scarce at the thrift stores, but that's your best bet for spares.  I accumulated way too many thrift store spares after repeatedly breaking carafes for my Cuisinart.  Of course, as soon as I had spares, I stopped breaking them.  They were added to the inventory of my moving sale last year.


Post# 1026650 , Reply# 24   3/9/2019 at 14:39 by ea56 (Sonoma Co.,CA)        

ea56's profile picture
The Medelco 10 cup replacement carafes fit the Braun Aromaster perfectly, and are easy to find on ebay and many other places. And you can get #4 cone filters at Walmart and Target at very reasonable cost. I have posted a link for an ebay listing for the Medelco 10 cup carafe.

And I agree with Matt about the Coffeemaster thermostat issues. They are very difficult adjust, and they donít hold the adjustments well, unless you have the special small wrench to get the nuts tightened down properly. The Coffeemasterís do make very excellent coffee when they are functioning properly, but they are a hassle to clean and maintain. I too have owned five of them, they are all gone now. Iím glad that I had the opportunity to experience using them, but Iíve got that checked off my bucket list for now.


Post# 1026659 , Reply# 25   3/9/2019 at 16:48 by JustJunque (Western MA)        

I have to agree with Eddie and Ralph.
I've been using a Braun Aromaster 10 cup forever.
I've had to replace carafes over the years, because I'm a klutz.
I use the same Melitta brown #4 filters, and we've used the newer bamboo version of them.
It's not fancy, but it just makes great coffee!
Our current go-to coffee brand is Original Chock Full O' Nuts.
When I found a NIB Aromaster on Craigslist a few years back, I grabbed it, just so I'd have another one when mine finally gives out.
Fortunately, the first one is still going strong!


Post# 1026661 , Reply# 26   3/9/2019 at 16:57 by ea56 (Sonoma Co.,CA)        

ea56's profile picture
I like the new Bamboo Mellita filters better than the regular brown paper #4 cone filters. The last box I bought are the regular brown paper, and I donít like them as well as the bamboo. The finished brew has a cleaner flavor with the bamboo filters. And I always used filtered water for brewing, the chlorine in tap water just ruins the flavor of coffee IMHO.


Post# 1026669 , Reply# 27   3/9/2019 at 17:54 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        

lordkenmore's profile picture
One option I've liked in the past are small drip makers that sit on top of my coffee cup.

The one I used was a 3 part design. There was a filter assembly (with permanent filter), a water reservoir that would fit on top of the filter, and a lid. (I often didn't bother with using the lid, figuring that the heat loss probably wasn't a significant factor.) One simply poured hot water into the water reservoir, and the water would slowly drip down into the coffee grounds. Unfortunately, I don't know if this style is even made now--it's been years since I've seen it in a store, and I just checked one place that had these on-line a few years ago, with no luck. Also this coffee maker was obviously more work than an electric coffee pot with disposable filters.

Melitta (and others) make similar coffee makers that use cone filters. These seem common enough--the last I knew, several stores in my area had these. Some love these. I, however, wasn't overwhelmed when I tried one. I can see pluses (disposable filters make them more convenient). But the coffee wasn't as good IMO as the style I used years back. A large part of this, I think, is that the Melitta system requires more care--my old system you could just dump in the hot water, and be done. The Melitta system may need more care with putting water in for optimal coffee. Also the permanent filter of my older coffee maker might have been better than paper filters. Still...the Melitta system is cheap enough for most people to gamble a few dollars on, and even if one doesn't like it, well, it might be good enough to be a backup coffee maker.

Post# 1026670 , Reply# 28   3/9/2019 at 18:10 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        
Farberware Superfast Percolator

lordkenmore's profile picture
Years back, I went through at least a couple of phases (and maybe more...) of using old percolators. I was inspired by this site. This site has a lot to answer for. LOL

During that time, one percolator I used was a smallish Farberware (4-6 cups), which is a nice size for those looking to brew a small amount of coffee. It didn't make the best coffee ever, but it was a very nice daily driver coffee pot. Coffee snobs hate percolators, but based on my experience, a good percolator carefully used can make better coffee than a bad drip maker. One day I'd like to have another Farberware like that one.

And, as mentioned above, the Farberware is fast, which is nice in the morning when one is rushing about to get ready for the day. I defaulted to my Farberware many days just because of how fast it was.

Post# 1026672 , Reply# 29   3/9/2019 at 18:10 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        

lordkenmore's profile picture
>Sometimes I think in this day of automation, and Technology, we often overlook the simple methods, that were tried and true. I think we over complicate our lives with all this gadgetry.

Very true!

Post# 1026673 , Reply# 30   3/9/2019 at 18:16 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        
Sunbeam Coffeemaster

lordkenmore's profile picture
I also went through a phase of using one of these... I can't remember my impressions of the coffee. It must have been drinkable, at least, because I wouldn't have continued using it. But I wasn't wowed to the point of "I'll never use anything else again!" Honestly, I think I might have enjoyed my time with percolators more, even though I think the Coffeemaster coffee would be better. One thing to note: I used it "as is" from the thrift store. Thermostat adjustments might have made it work better.

I'm not sure I'll go back to using a Coffeemaster ever, although "never say never." I'd like to use a vacuum pot again...but I'd rather have glass so one can watch the coffee brew. This would be for "relaxed after dinner" coffee, not first thing in the morning.

Although I will the Coffeemaster does look pretty sitting on a shelf... I don't have it on display, but I could see doing that, like I have several old percolators that I've never used that are entirely decoration at this point.

Post# 1026674 , Reply# 31   3/9/2019 at 18:17 by polkanut (Wausau, WI )        

polkanut's profile picture

One can never go wrong with a vintage Norelco Dial-A-Brew.  The unit in the photo was found at a church rummage sale about 6-7 years ago for $5.00.  My wife has a standing order that if I see one at a estate/tag sale I'm to buy it.  We have 2 spares already, but she wants to be on the safe side because she loves it so much.

  View Full Size
Post# 1026676 , Reply# 32   3/9/2019 at 18:25 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        

lordkenmore's profile picture
My mother had one of these from the late 80s to early 90s. While we both agreed French press was better, the Braun was a nice, convenient daily driver.

For some reason, I'm thinking it was top rated by CONSUMER REPORTS.

Post# 1026678 , Reply# 33   3/9/2019 at 18:30 by LordKenmore (The Laundry Room)        
Cone filters

lordkenmore's profile picture
From my memories, the paper filters are a bit more expensive. But they are common, and there are ways of saving money (generic filters--very common--or IIRC Target had good prices once on big boxes of filters).

Another option: they make (or used to make) permanent cone filters. These aren't as convenient when its time to clean up, however. My mother had one of these, and she felt the coffee was better, too, although this is probably one of those "your mileage may vary."

Post# 1026747 , Reply# 34   3/10/2019 at 15:16 by PassatDoc (Orange County, California)        

I do very well with a Cuisinart 1150. Hotplate keeps coffee hot (until I pour it into a thermos) and there is a 1-4 cup setting for small jobs. Auto Clean cycle as well, which I use quarterly to descale it.

Forum Index:       Other Forums:                      

Comes to the Rescue!

The Discuss-o-Mat has stopped, buzzer is sounding!!!
If you would like to reply to this thread please log-in...

Discuss-O-MAT Log-In

New Members
Click Here To Sign Up.

Discuss-o-Mat Forums
Vintage Brochures, Service and Owners Manuals
Fun Vintage Washer Ephemera
See It Wash!
Video Downloads
Audio Downloads
Picture of the Day
Patent of the Day
Photos of our Collections
The Old Aberdeen Farm
Vintage Service Manuals
Vintage washer/dryer/dishwasher to sell?
Technical/service questions?
Looking for Parts?
Website related questions?
Digital Millennium Copyright Act Policy
Our Privacy Policy